or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 46 comments are related to an article called:

Wilshere - The most overated player

Page 1 of 2

comment by Cohort (U3722)

posted on 24/7/11

He's better than any of Liverpule's midfielders. However he does get too much tabloid time.

posted on 24/7/11

"DISCUSS!! - all WUMs are welcome"
===

Don't feed to troll guys, he just wants to get loads of comments on this pathetic article.

posted on 24/7/11

Why are Liverpool fans so obssessed with wums? Obviously unable to take any criticism.

posted on 24/7/11

I don't think he's overrated just bogged up by the English media, tbf to the lad he's only 19 and when Barca played Arsenal he kept Barca pretty quiet and not many people can do that!!

posted on 24/7/11

Wilshire is not overated by many, only Arsenal supporters, deep down, most of them know the truth.

The rest of us don't overate him.

posted on 24/7/11

I totally disagree. He is obviously gonna be overrated as he is English, but he is such a talented footballer. He isn't like a Gerrard or Lampard who you look for assists and goals, but more like a Paul Scholes type of player. He is there to conrtol the play, and form defense to attack with his link up play.

We never gave Scholes the chance at international level, which is a big mistake. Players like Xavi, Alonso, Scholes, Wilshire are important at international level at holding the ball. Wilshire is so different to the type of player we have had in the past.

comment by Marslfc (U8595)

posted on 24/7/11

so 1 half decent appearance against barcelona and now all of a sudden hes better than gerrard ? what kind of stupid logic is that?

comment by Ruiney (U1005)

posted on 24/7/11

I agree he's overrated, probably because he's English, but he's still a good player.

comment by Marslfc (U8595)

posted on 24/7/11

Kamran - ArshAttack

and which part of this article is pathetic

posted on 24/7/11

No I never said that did I? I don't think he's better than Gerrard but he's still a great player who's only going to improve!

posted on 24/7/11

Its on the Liverpool board only because you didnt have the balls to put it on the Arsenal board

comment by Marslfc (U8595)

posted on 24/7/11

the arsenal board is monumental mate. why would i put it there ... none of them will see it coz theyll all be here

comment by Tomkins (U1116)

posted on 24/7/11

Hahahaha he is twice the player of any liverpool midfielder.

Jordo hendo? Wow he is going to be some player. The biggest fraud since george weah's cousin.

Jealousy and delusion is in liverpoos blood

posted on 24/7/11

"Don't feed to troll guys, he just wants to get loads of comments on this pathetic article."

And I guess you'd know all about that

posted on 24/7/11

Jack Wilshire is a fantastic footballer - cant believe some of the stuff i read on here

he is a technical player...much like xavi and inesta (and has the potential to be as good)

he makes room for himself in the tightest of areas and always looks like he has 10 mins to decide what to do with it - for me a sign of true quality

a future England star

and im a spurs fan

posted on 24/7/11

he is a bit of t#@t though

comment by Ruiney (U1005)

posted on 24/7/11

posted on 24/7/11

he is a bit of t#@t though

-

I agree you can tell hes up himself, and was probably a chav when younger, but his ability is great. A type of player England have missed since Scholes was messed around with.

comment by Philo (U3120)

posted on 24/7/11

wilshere is the first player in england to show the same technique that people always rave about when talking about the foreign sides. he is the only player in england that has the technical ability to fit into a barcelona type side. whether he is barcelona quality is yet to be clear but the point is that he has the tecnical capability to fit in abroad.

posted on 24/7/11

He is quite overrated to the point I'm underwhelmed with his performances on the pitch. And his tackling is rubbish.

posted on 24/7/11

for the same way people will never like john terry no matter how good he is. il never like jack wilshere. cant stand the guy at all and hes not even done anything yet.

comment by Marslfc (U8595)

posted on 24/7/11

philo

this is sort of rubbish i tcant understand. "he is the only player in england that has the technical ability to fit into a barcelona type side"

and how did you conclude this? from his 1 perfomance against barce? or maybe is was his epic perfomances against the mighty premireship teams which are all on par with barcelona?

when pep gaudiola was asked about his opinion on wilshere, he said he has 20 wilsheres in his B team! so how would he be able to get in the barrce side?

posted on 24/7/11

whether he is barcelona quality is yet to be clear but the point is that he has the tecnical capability to fit in abroad.

You better hope not, Arsenal seem to be their feeder club.

posted on 24/7/11

A type of player England have missed since Scholes was messed around with.

-----

Now come on, I didn't like Eriksson either, but those are some serious accusations.

posted on 24/7/11

Wilshere is seriously the worst player from any of the top teams. He is so bad it's almost funny. Not premiership material. The biggest joke in football history is that gooners actually mentions him in the same sentence as scholes, xavi, gerrard or iniesta

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment