or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 5 comments are related to an article called:

What's so wrong with Roy Keane?

Page 1 of 1

posted on 7/2/13

He did well with Sunderland for one season but was found out the following year in the Prem. He was backed at Ipswich but was a complete failure there. He can probably use his strong personality and playing experience to motivate a strong squad in this division but tactically he's weak. If he had a very good coach with him it might work but I imagine he's very pigheaded.

posted on 7/2/13

I don't believe he can manage.

posted on 7/2/13

He's not managerial material

Don't want him

posted on 7/2/13

Can't bring players along with him, his single mindedness that made him a world class player is what holds him back as a manager! He's also ridiculously stubborn and falls out with players too regularly, sent Rhodes to Huddersfield on a free coz he fell out with him who sold him 2 years later for £8m after he fired them to promotion!

posted on 7/2/13

He admitted purposefully breaking a fellow professional's leg. And he's not a Forest legend at all.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment