Turan is better but older. Both around the price you mentioned

Get both

Iker!

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Get Griezmann.

I'm not exactly an expert, just watched a bit of Spanish football on sky but my take would be Turan would be more likely to have an immediate impact.

That said Muniain does seem to have something special, I'd guess he'll end up being the better player.

So to answer your question, or not as the case may be, for me it depends on whether you're talking long term or short term.

i cant believe there is a discussion about this.

Turan or Muniain???

seriously?
People would rather have Turan?
I was told the other day that the whole turan thing is a bit of a joke on the board, not a serious discussion.

Muniain all day long over turan. without a moments hesitation.

comment by Respected LocoLiverpool~Coutinho+Lamela>Suarez! (U18018)
posted 4 minutes ago
Get Griezmann.

==========

Over Muniain? Perhaps a more realistic alternative but I wouldn't say a better one.

Muniain is all hype. Turan is better as things stand

ok im out of this, people seem to genuinely think that turan is better than muniain as a player, leaving form aside

At 21 Muniain is better than Turan, 21!

Yes, but at the moment, Turan is easily better

Sterling

I'd have Greizmann over Munian even if they cost the same price

Loco - you either see more in Greizmann than I do or you really don't rate Muniain.

Which one is it? Am I missing something in Greizmann?

I feel Griezmann is improving as the seasons go by, Munian isn't in my opinion.
I'd be happy if we got either, impossible to tell at the moment who will become the better player.

Loco

Griezman has CL and as we're always told on here, no one will leave a CL team for one without!

Turan at 20 was one of the best players off Euro 2004.

Mata

Turan is obviously a better fit for us right now than Muniain.

We need an experienced winner to add to the team. That is Turan.

26, at his peak, 60 odd caps for his country.

Muniain might be a better player on three or four years, but we need a top player now, not another kid, we have enough of those.

Muniain is not a Coutinho who will be cheap for his quality. Bilbao will likely want £20m the same price as Turan. That's a very expensive risk for a player who had a pretty poor season, he was also poor in the U21's for Spain, and the Olympics before that. He is hot headed and while he might be brilliant there is a far bigger risk that he could be an expensive mistake.

Turan is a consistent, solid player and competitor. He doesn't really have the goals return we want to add, maybe 8 a season, but he is a consistent assister and clever player.

We won't sign either I doubt, but we certainly need a Turan more than we need a Muniain.

Dusan Tadic

Muniain is a much better player than Turan, I have no idea how anyone you could possibly think other wise.

One poor season was due to being played out of position and pretty much having the entire attacking threat of his team placed on his shoulders..

From the age of 16 has been playing regularly in the Bilbao first team and doing so at an extremely high level. The only thing he lacks is goal.

At 20 he is already an experienced player and is good as anything on the planet on the at same age group. He has played nearly 200 games at 20. I bet Messi hadn't done that.

In my opinion he is better than Isco and Gotze and if he scored more so would everyone else.

And you will never get Muniain for £20m, Bilbao wont even talk to you until £35 - £40 is on the table. Money is of no use to them, its not like they can go out and spend it.

In my opinion he is better than Isco and Gotze and if he scored more so would everyone else.

------



There is absolutely no evidence to suggest that.

What evidence do I need apart from my eyes.

Or do you need stats, expert opinion and media hype to decide what players are the best.

I suggest you re watch Muniain humiliating the Utd, Real or Barca defence to educate yourself how good he is.

Taarabt can humiliate defences once in a blue moon.

It's consistency that makes great players.

Isco and Gotze are both massively more consistent than Muniain.

He might add that to his game and then he will be in there bracket, but until he does then your comparison makes you look silly.

*their