Its alright you got fellaini...
comment by Suso The Magician - Ilori's Pace (U11770)
posted 3 minutes ago
Its alright you got fellaini...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Even with Rio gone, we have Vidic, Smalling, Jones and Evans with Micheal Keane also in the running. We did not need Garay.
What we did need was some CMs and a winger. Adnan seems to be the one to step up for the winger role and only Fellaini has been bought in, who hasn't set things alight. I'll give him time, but we really needed a creative player and we haven;t got it.
Even with Rio gone, we have Vidic, Smalling, Jones and Evans with Micheal Keane also in the running. We did not need Garay.
------------
what youve got there is vidic, who is coming towards the end of his career and 3 very unreliable defenders in terms of picking up regular injuries in smalling, jones and evans.
we do need a decent CB who is reliable and will play the majority of games.
Garay is better than Smalling, Evans and Jones, whilst we have looked atrociously weak in defence this season.
How do we NOT need a CB??
Sorry, but it's no good having half a dozen CBs if only one of them is close in ability to the other top CBs in the world/league.
Jones, Evans and Smalling wouldn't look out of place at lower-mid-table clubs.
Must be a different garay then because the one iv'e seen is nothing special
Neither are Smalling, Jones and Evans.. Out of interest, how many times have you seen this Garay?
Jesus wept, you think Evans is poor then you know fook all about football!
Jesus wept, u made up me saying 'Evans is poor.'
Evans is good, if not a little inconsistent. He's certainly not a top centre back though.
I would be very worried if the future of our defence was Johnny Evans, unless you can explain to me how he is on a level with the likes of Vidic, Rio, Stam, Pallister etc....
Never understood the hype around Garay.
Smalling is better than Garay. It is not even close.
The same Smalling who is prone to errors in both judgement and concentration ? I'm not advocating we should have signed Garay, but i think we need to sign an accomplished CB to replace Rio, not hope for the beat with players who quite frankly are nowhere near as good as rio was at their age.
And Garay is not prone to errors? We have 3 fantastic young cbs in the club who need games and will play them over garay any day of the week.
Not sure looking to Portugal for defenders is a wise option considering their poor record in developing CBs
Good news he isn't that good anyway and the reported 20 million needs to be spent in central midfield on a playmaker.
French did you actually read the post, Evans is a very good player and was vital to united winning the title in 09, 11 and last season. Always played in the biggest games hence there's talent and pally at first was very shaky.....I'm defending Evans after someone called him poor ffs and not comparing him to anyone all called him world class for crying out load! A poor defender does not play this amount of games for united and defender like he did against ronaldo and co for Northern Ireland and he will be a big part of uniteds future. Also this defender for Porto, ffs never played here and most probably another sideshow bib who can't defend for toffee......I take it you've never seen him play and judge him on another sad computer game
Im one of those who believes its time to give Smalling & Jones a extended run as our two central defenders.
They formed a excellent partnership at under 21's and its no surprise they where both snapped up by Fergie.
Time for them to be given their preferred roles and see how they get on.
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Moyes' arrival ended United dream - Garay
Page 1 of 1
posted on 14/10/13
Good
posted on 14/10/13
Its alright you got fellaini...
posted on 14/10/13
comment by Suso The Magician - Ilori's Pace (U11770)
posted 3 minutes ago
Its alright you got fellaini...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 14/10/13
Even with Rio gone, we have Vidic, Smalling, Jones and Evans with Micheal Keane also in the running. We did not need Garay.
What we did need was some CMs and a winger. Adnan seems to be the one to step up for the winger role and only Fellaini has been bought in, who hasn't set things alight. I'll give him time, but we really needed a creative player and we haven;t got it.
posted on 14/10/13
Moyes out!
posted on 14/10/13
Even with Rio gone, we have Vidic, Smalling, Jones and Evans with Micheal Keane also in the running. We did not need Garay.
------------
what youve got there is vidic, who is coming towards the end of his career and 3 very unreliable defenders in terms of picking up regular injuries in smalling, jones and evans.
we do need a decent CB who is reliable and will play the majority of games.
posted on 14/10/13
Garay is better than Smalling, Evans and Jones, whilst we have looked atrociously weak in defence this season.
How do we NOT need a CB??
Sorry, but it's no good having half a dozen CBs if only one of them is close in ability to the other top CBs in the world/league.
Jones, Evans and Smalling wouldn't look out of place at lower-mid-table clubs.
posted on 14/10/13
Must be a different garay then because the one iv'e seen is nothing special
posted on 14/10/13
Neither are Smalling, Jones and Evans.. Out of interest, how many times have you seen this Garay?
posted on 14/10/13
Jesus wept, you think Evans is poor then you know fook all about football!
posted on 14/10/13
Jesus wept, u made up me saying 'Evans is poor.'
Evans is good, if not a little inconsistent. He's certainly not a top centre back though.
I would be very worried if the future of our defence was Johnny Evans, unless you can explain to me how he is on a level with the likes of Vidic, Rio, Stam, Pallister etc....
posted on 14/10/13
Never understood the hype around Garay.
posted on 14/10/13
Smalling is better than Garay. It is not even close.
posted on 14/10/13
The same Smalling who is prone to errors in both judgement and concentration ? I'm not advocating we should have signed Garay, but i think we need to sign an accomplished CB to replace Rio, not hope for the beat with players who quite frankly are nowhere near as good as rio was at their age.
posted on 14/10/13
And Garay is not prone to errors? We have 3 fantastic young cbs in the club who need games and will play them over garay any day of the week.
Not sure looking to Portugal for defenders is a wise option considering their poor record in developing CBs
posted on 14/10/13
Good news he isn't that good anyway and the reported 20 million needs to be spent in central midfield on a playmaker.
posted on 14/10/13
French did you actually read the post, Evans is a very good player and was vital to united winning the title in 09, 11 and last season. Always played in the biggest games hence there's talent and pally at first was very shaky.....I'm defending Evans after someone called him poor ffs and not comparing him to anyone all called him world class for crying out load! A poor defender does not play this amount of games for united and defender like he did against ronaldo and co for Northern Ireland and he will be a big part of uniteds future. Also this defender for Porto, ffs never played here and most probably another sideshow bib who can't defend for toffee......I take it you've never seen him play and judge him on another sad computer game
posted on 15/10/13
Im one of those who believes its time to give Smalling & Jones a extended run as our two central defenders.
They formed a excellent partnership at under 21's and its no surprise they where both snapped up by Fergie.
Time for them to be given their preferred roles and see how they get on.
Page 1 of 1