or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 35 comments are related to an article called:

Holtby

Page 1 of 2

posted on 29/1/14

No.

posted on 29/1/14

He's not that good, so no.

posted on 29/1/14

I miss read the story anyway coz it's only on loan

posted on 29/1/14

Well this was a resounding success

posted on 29/1/14

Haha a bit pointless I know

posted on 29/1/14

I'd take him in a heartbeat. He's a German international, can play anywhere across midfield, capable of scoring the occasional worldy and has a similar attitude to Kuyt.

posted on 29/1/14

I'd give him the chance.

JimmyTheRed

posted on 29/1/14

I'd take him, yes. But Spurs would be idiots to sell him to a rival.

posted on 29/1/14

shirtlight confirming further hes a wum

posted on 29/1/14

comment by Ilori (U18764)
posted 1 minute ago
shirtlight confirming further hes a wum
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Everything he says is true. It does make me wonder why Spurs are apparently selling him though.

posted on 29/1/14

Why are these bids always "cheeky"

posted on 29/1/14

In a heartbeat. I thought when they signed him that they had got a real bargain for £2M - although only on loan, and I really can't see them loaning to us, I think he would be a brilliant addition - plays across the midfield and has the 'never say die' attitude that Kuyt & Gerrard had/have

posted on 29/1/14

comment by Ilori (U18764)
posted 7 minutes ago
shirtlight confirming further hes a wum
-------------------

Can you elaborate further please?

posted on 29/1/14

Holtby has been poor in the Premiership so far, he would be a risk.

comment by Reggie (U13390)

posted on 29/1/14

if he ain't good enough for spurs, then he certainly isn't good enough for us.

posted on 29/1/14

ARE.

Yeah, he's been inconsistent but, IMO, he has genuine quality and would be worth a gamble.

posted on 29/1/14

REG.

Was Coutinho not good enough for Inter?

posted on 29/1/14

posted 1 minute ago
ARE.

Yeah, he's been inconsistent but, IMO, he has genuine quality and would be worth a gamble.

------

Spurs will be dumping a lot of their new signings now AVB has gone, so he may be worth a punt. He's a bluenose though which puts me off a bit, then again we have had a few playing for is down the years....

comment by Reggie (U13390)

posted on 29/1/14

yeah coutinho was unproven in the uk, it's not like holtby hasn't been here long enough to have made some impact but the fact is, he hasn't at all.

posted on 29/1/14

REG.

Yes he has.

posted on 29/1/14

Holtby ...no thnx

comment by Reggie (U13390)

posted on 29/1/14

really? where's all teh occasional worldies for spurs then? 1 whole goal in the league buddy..... realllly made an impact there then.

posted on 29/1/14

Can't see the club going for him tbh. I can't see what he'll add to the team.

comment by Neo (U9135)

posted on 29/1/14

No No No

Holtby is a very ordinary player, such a poor man's Coutinho.

posted on 29/1/14

Not for me. He won't leave for another premier league club now for a while, until he has 3/4 seasons where he has improved. A waste of space at Spurs but such a good player. Could have worked magic anywhere else, but there.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment