or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 50 comments are related to an article called:

Why PEP is overrated ....

Page 1 of 2

posted on 9/5/14

LVG is the greatest manager of all time. Well, right behind Roberto Martinez, obviously.

posted on 9/5/14

Lvg is disliked at every big club he's ever managed at by fans. Ask yourself why.

posted on 9/5/14

They hate him because they can't handle is awesomeness.

It's jealousy. Simple.

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

Started by LVG

Johann Cruyff is the name you're looking for if you want to take credit away from Pep

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

yes Pep did win alot with Barca but who wouldnt with that team???
--------------
Tito Villanova and Gerardo Martino?

posted on 9/5/14

pep is not over-rated but is a manager with only a plan A

tika-taka, and nothing else.
He is not a team builder imo though and for that reason would not be suited to the utd job.

comment by (U19549)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by Andy Carrot (U2440)
posted 2 minutes ago
Lvg is disliked at every big club he's ever managed at by fans. Ask yourself why.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
didnt sir alex fall out with some very big names at Old Trafford including the former owners?? every big manager falls out with those who dont agree with him,whats ur point?

comment by (U19549)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by the GINGER PRINCE'S apprentice (U13920)
posted 1 minute ago
pep is not over-rated but is a manager with only a plan A

tika-taka, and nothing else.
He is not a team builder imo though and for that reason would not be suited to the utd job.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thats my point exactly

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

Pep's plan A was pretty much the most successful plan in history in terms of the trophies won in 3 seasons.

The times it failed get highlighted quite a lot, much like this season Mourinho's tactical 'masterclasses' get lauded.....and have earned Chelsea precisely zero silverware.

posted on 9/5/14

alot of people give Pep alot of credit for `inventing -keep-the-ball`

----------------------

I don't think anyone has said this, ever.

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

Pep worked with the B team, he brought in the likes of Pedro and Busquets from that team. He took advantage of Messi's talents and moved him into the middle.

I don't know what your definition of 'building a team' is, but Pep certainly did just that with Barca.

comment by (U19549)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by ● (U4443)
posted 5 minutes ago
Started by LVG

Johann Cruyff is the name you're looking for if you want to take credit away from Pep
----------------------------------------------------------------------
im not trying to take credit from him but facts are facts, if Bayern is humiliated again next year in the champions league then Pep will be chased out of Germany all the way to Spain trust me

comment by (U19549)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by ● (U4443)
posted 24 seconds ago
Pep worked with the B team, he brought in the likes of Pedro and Busquets from that team. He took advantage of Messi's talents and moved him into the middle.

I don't know what your definition of 'building a team' is, but Pep certainly did just that with Barca.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Barca had already won everything there is to win so how did Pep build Barca exactly? how?

comment by (U19549)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by FatJanMolby *I'm a boogie monster* (U4297)
posted 3 minutes ago
alot of people give Pep alot of credit for `inventing -keep-the-ball`

----------------------

I don't think anyone has said this, ever.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
they say this all the time,pundits on the telly,fans also

posted on 9/5/14

If Plan A works 95% of the time there is no need for Plan B

Plan B is just code for hoofball anyway. Pep has Plan A, B, C, D etc. and it involves different players, subs, changes in formation.

He just doesn't do route 1 or sideways hoofball (crossing to heads percentage hopeful football)

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by (U19549)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by ● (U4443)
posted 24 seconds ago
Pep worked with the B team, he brought in the likes of Pedro and Busquets from that team. He took advantage of Messi's talents and moved him into the middle.

I don't know what your definition of 'building a team' is, but Pep certainly did just that with Barca.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Barca had already won everything there is to win so how did Pep build Barca exactly? how?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You need to tell me what your definition of building a team is though.

How long can there be between a team's successes in a competition for a team to be built?

The team he inherited and built was NOT the 2006 CL winning team.

Why is Mourinho failing with a Chelsea team that won the CL?

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

For all the perceived problems with the tiki taka style.....just look at Barca and Spain from 2008 to present and name me a more successful style of play

All achieved 'without a Plan B'

posted on 9/5/14

"If Plan A works 95% of the time there is no need for Plan B"

Well yeah, there actually is. Because the other 5% of the time tends to be against the top teams in key games that can and often will prove the difference between winning silverware and failing to do so. It's why his record in one off games against great teams often ended in defeat in his latter days at Barca and again why Bayern were so easily dispatched by Real. Predictable and can be countered with relative ease by the best.

posted on 9/5/14

"Why is Mourinho failing with a Chelsea team that won the CL?"

1. they fluked it unconvincingly so it's not as if he inherited the best side in Europe
2. He's a bus parker who doesn't like attacking and he bottled the easiest league title in ages by not scoring/winning in 4 easy matches in the last month or so.

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

comment by The Kaisers Trainers (U5676)
posted 2 minutes ago
"Why is Mourinho failing with a Chelsea team that won the CL?"

1. they fluked it unconvincingly so it's not as if he inherited the best side in Europe
2. He's a bus parker who doesn't like attacking and he bottled the easiest league title in ages by not scoring/winning in 4 easy matches in the last month or so.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yet he is lauded as one of the greatest managers ever?

As an Arsenal fan, obviously Barca fluked the 2006 CL final, making Pep's achievements all the more amazing

posted on 9/5/14

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/5/14

The transfers Barca did under Pep were awful. Paid god knows how much and Eto for Ibra and then put him on the bench.

Bayern pass the ball so slowly in the final third compared to last year. That made them soo much less dangerous, I remember they used to pass the ball into space and rip teams with Robben and Ribery.

posted on 9/5/14

Jose is one of the best managers ever

that doesn't mean he's flawless - everyone has chinks in their armour / shortcomings

comment by ● (U4443)

posted on 9/5/14

Yeah, Barca were a one man team. Their one man, however, only looked good because of the service from Xavi and Iniesta

posted on 9/5/14

It's not just messi he's missing. Iniesta, busquets and xavi are just as big misses. Bayern have good midfielders but none of them are on that level.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment