No news on Scholes, Butt and Neville yet though
thats good news. a coach who has actually won something and has pedigree. Phil and the rest of the class of 92 should work their way up management and not just expect to be handed roles at united, same with R. Giggs...the media needs to stop promoting this idea of old boys brigade as panacea to united problems
Scholes, Butt probably...
I doubt Neville will be part of the coaching staff
Don't want scholes or butt anywhere near the coaching team
If we're going on recent interviews (and his own blog) Scholes seems to pushing himself out of the door.
Which I'm in favour of.
comment by De Gea's Legs (U14210)
posted 51 minutes ago
Don't want scholes or butt anywhere near the coaching team
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why not? Scholes can teach any player a thing or ten. Butt has done good work with the youth team.
I'm open to the idea of Scholes as a coach but it should be based on ability, not sentiment. I reckon Scholes coukd do a job as a coach though. He's level headed ans could offer some very good advice to any CM on how to play the game
I like Schiles he's honest, which you need from a coach. He knows the values held at OT, he is a club legend and should be the perfect role model for any young footballer.
I think he should be a part of the youth setup as opposed to the first team, that's where I see him having the biggest impact.
Personally, if I was van Gaal I'd tell everyone to do one.
The coaches that were brought in were a joke from Moyes, but the biggest joke is that Phil Neville got to keep his job. The only reason for this is some sort of sentimental loyalty because he's part of the '92 class.
This attitude we need to get rid off, make the place far more professional again.
Butt has done well at reserve level, so keep. Giggs should not have become assistant manager so easily but it seems the players respect him and get on with him. It could be something LVG needs. Scholes would be a decent coach but like Butt should start at reserve level.
It's a trade off. You want great servants like Giggs and Scholes around the club and especially the younger players, but at the same time, you don't want to create and Old Boys Club or have people on the staff who aren't yet qualified for the role, regardless of what they achieved in their playing days...
Butt and Scholes to the youth team. Giggs is already assistant - I'm a bit skeptical on that one. Phil Neville should have left with Moyes.
Yeah, they have to earn your stripes as a coach baded on your coaching ability, not your services as a player
why could Scholes teach player a thing ot two. being a good coach is a different different kettle of fish than being a great player
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Albert Stuivenberg
Page 1 of 1
posted on 6/7/14
Champions '14-'15
posted on 6/7/14
No news on Scholes, Butt and Neville yet though
posted on 6/7/14
thats good news. a coach who has actually won something and has pedigree. Phil and the rest of the class of 92 should work their way up management and not just expect to be handed roles at united, same with R. Giggs...the media needs to stop promoting this idea of old boys brigade as panacea to united problems
posted on 6/7/14
Scholes, Butt probably...
I doubt Neville will be part of the coaching staff
posted on 6/7/14
Don't want scholes or butt anywhere near the coaching team
posted on 6/7/14
If we're going on recent interviews (and his own blog) Scholes seems to pushing himself out of the door.
Which I'm in favour of.
posted on 6/7/14
The Dutch Steve Round.
posted on 6/7/14
comment by De Gea's Legs (U14210)
posted 51 minutes ago
Don't want scholes or butt anywhere near the coaching team
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why not? Scholes can teach any player a thing or ten. Butt has done good work with the youth team.
posted on 6/7/14
I'm open to the idea of Scholes as a coach but it should be based on ability, not sentiment. I reckon Scholes coukd do a job as a coach though. He's level headed ans could offer some very good advice to any CM on how to play the game
posted on 6/7/14
I like Schiles he's honest, which you need from a coach. He knows the values held at OT, he is a club legend and should be the perfect role model for any young footballer.
I think he should be a part of the youth setup as opposed to the first team, that's where I see him having the biggest impact.
posted on 6/7/14
Personally, if I was van Gaal I'd tell everyone to do one.
The coaches that were brought in were a joke from Moyes, but the biggest joke is that Phil Neville got to keep his job. The only reason for this is some sort of sentimental loyalty because he's part of the '92 class.
This attitude we need to get rid off, make the place far more professional again.
posted on 6/7/14
Butt has done well at reserve level, so keep. Giggs should not have become assistant manager so easily but it seems the players respect him and get on with him. It could be something LVG needs. Scholes would be a decent coach but like Butt should start at reserve level.
posted on 6/7/14
It's a trade off. You want great servants like Giggs and Scholes around the club and especially the younger players, but at the same time, you don't want to create and Old Boys Club or have people on the staff who aren't yet qualified for the role, regardless of what they achieved in their playing days...
Butt and Scholes to the youth team. Giggs is already assistant - I'm a bit skeptical on that one. Phil Neville should have left with Moyes.
posted on 6/7/14
Yeah, they have to earn your stripes as a coach baded on your coaching ability, not your services as a player
posted on 6/7/14
why could Scholes teach player a thing ot two. being a good coach is a different different kettle of fish than being a great player
Page 1 of 1