or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 49 comments are related to an article called:

Who should United keep or sell ?

Page 1 of 2

posted on 8/7/14

Valencia
Valencia
Valencia

posted on 8/7/14

You've got some guff in your team

comment by LVG (U1720)

posted on 9/7/14

posted on 9/7/14

Agree with them all and would have gone further and added Valencia to the list (nani young fellaini cleverley Anderson and fletcher)

posted on 9/7/14

Got to wonder who the hell voted to sell Herrera, Shaw and Adnan.

Would add De Gea into that least but I think most ja606ers know who that was.

Also, why the feck do 70% of our fans want to keep Valencia?

posted on 9/7/14

City fans bloodred. That's who.

The berties. The bitters. The MASSIVES.

comment by LVG (U1720)

posted on 9/7/14

Valencia's evals is a surprise

79% K 29 S

Check Anderson out !!

posted on 9/7/14

Valencia becomes an important player on the right hand side in Van Gaal's 3-4-3 formation.

posted on 9/7/14

EVERYONE HAS THEIR DETRACTORS, BUT IT SEEMS THERE ARE THREE OR FOUR WHO ARE NOT VERY POPULAR. No doubt LvG will sort it all out and matbe surprise us all.

posted on 9/7/14

comment by Pundit /\_/\ (U16869)
posted 1 minute ago
Valencia becomes an important player on the right hand side in Van Gaal's 3-4-3 formation.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He becomes even more shittttte than he was in the first place.

posted on 9/7/14

Must be Scousers and City fans voting to sell those players and keep Valencia.

posted on 9/7/14

Germany showed tonight it isn't about the individual

Something we will never learn despite sir alf showing us the way

When watching the Germans tonight there were no superstars, nobody trying to steal the limelight, there was unselfish play in the box, none of them were trying to dribble into no mans land. None of them were trying to prove anything to themselves. It was the ultimate team performance

We have Sturridge to look forward too

It's so depressing

posted on 9/7/14

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 9 minutes ago
Got to wonder who the hell voted to sell Herrera, Shaw and Adnan.

Would add De Gea into that least but I think most ja606ers know who that was.

Also, why the feck do 70% of our fans want to keep Valencia?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You are looking in the wrong direction bud

posted on 9/7/14

But Liverpool have to buy a new biter...ooops ... I mean striker.

comment by Bruno (U1664)

posted on 9/7/14

Definately them 7 players should all go.

posted on 9/7/14

Macca

What"s your issue with Sturridge?

He has been brilliant for Liverpool and very much a team player.

posted on 9/7/14

comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 1 hour, 56 minutes ago
Macca

What"s your issue with Sturridge?

He has been brilliant for Liverpool and very much a team player.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I really do not know what he is on. The guy was part of a strike partnership that scored over 50 goals. Compare that Rooney/ RVP who hardly passed the ball to each other last season, I do not know where this bashing of Sturridge has come from.

posted on 9/7/14

Macca has been bashing Sturridge for a while now. Sturridge has that strikers drive and eye for goal cant see the problem.

posted on 9/7/14

I would sell fellaini, cleverly, valencia, young, evra seems on his way. None are good enough for where we wanna be.

fletch should be released, helll only play 8 games anyway. Same for ando, I dont even really count those as squad plyers tbh, they dont even play enough.

Oh and jones.

posted on 9/7/14

Agree with all the results including the Valencia one, Id rather keep Valencia than Young and Nani.

Although I would Keep Hernandez and sell Welbeck if it comes to keeping one of those two

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 9/7/14

For England, Sturridge reverted to type. For England, Sturridge rarely looks to pass, and shoots from ridiculous angles, and areas despite there being better passes on for an easier chance to score.

I would hate to knock Sturridge based on his England form, because like most players, they're shíte and completely different for country. It just seems that without Suarez (who clearly had an understanding with Sturridge) he just isn't that good a player.

Many of us said the same after some of the England friendlies, and the WC just further enforced that belief in many. It's the same as Townsend, really. Gets in to a good position, and then wastes it by shooting from an improbable range.

Like I say, he's probably completely different for club, can't say I watched him that much.

He was also one of England's better players in the WC, along with Welbeck &Sterling. Everyone else was disinterested.

posted on 9/7/14

comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 10 hours, 26 minutes ago
Macca

What"s your issue with Sturridge?

He has been brilliant for Liverpool and very much a team player.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Greedy egotistical who thinks about his own glory more the the teams

Nothing like a team player

It isn't something that only me thinks.

posted on 9/7/14

comment by Jay. (U16498)
posted 7 minutes ago
For England, Sturridge reverted to type. For England, Sturridge rarely looks to pass, and shoots from ridiculous angles, and areas despite there being better passes on for an easier chance to score.

I would hate to knock Sturridge based on his England form, because like most players, they're shíte and completely different for country. It just seems that without Suarez (who clearly had an understanding with Sturridge) he just isn't that good a player.

Many of us said the same after some of the England friendlies, and the WC just further enforced that belief in many. It's the same as Townsend, really. Gets in to a good position, and then wastes it by shooting from an improbable range.

Like I say, he's probably completely different for club, can't say I watched him that much.

He was also one of England's better players in the WC, along with Welbeck &Sterling. Everyone else was disinterested.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agree with all of that aside from the last paragraph

Sturridge was our out and out number 9 and was cack at it

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 9/7/14

Sturridge was our out and out number 9 and was cack at it
---

I don't want to put too much blame on him. The rest of our players were static as hell (reminiscent of watching United play!) and our midfield just wasn't good enough to pick the kind of passes he thrives on.

I don't think it's any coincidence that he scored when Rooney played the ball over the top, behind the defence. I don't think that happened often enough. We didn't really do much that exploited Sturridge's pace.

posted on 9/7/14

Jay

Sturridge had plenty of the ball and did pretty much nothing with it.

If Rooney had played at 9 and played like Sturridge, he would now be taking the blame for England's poor show

A couple of moves in the Costa Rica game summed him up. He fed Wilshere for 1/2 and got the ball back perfectly and all he needed to do was square it 8 yards for Sterling to tap it in. Instead he tries to curl it in instead. Check out Sterling's reaction. He was not happy

The other occasion was when this time, Wilshere fed Sturridge and ran for the return, only not to get it back, Sturridge just shot from a stupid position.

Sturridge has ability. That is obvious. But you only have to look at a couple of the German's goals last night to see how a team play. They coould have shot earlier in the moves that brought the goals but players unselfishly set up players in better positions.

City didn't want him. Chelsea didn't want him.

There must be some reason for it

I'll judge Sturridge over the next couple of seasons now he won't have the same space with Suarez now not keeping the opposition defence busy

I hope he proves me wrong as it can only be good for England but at this World Cup, anyone who tells me he was good, I would like to know good at what

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment