or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 304 comments are related to an article called:

New UEFA Champions League Seeding System!

Page 4 of 13

posted on 9/10/14

Darren
Get back to us when your team can manage to qualify for Europe then we can talk football until then be quiet

posted on 9/10/14

How the fek did Russia get in the top 7 ahead of the Netherlands, Belgium, Greece etc.

More brown envelopes?

posted on 9/10/14

comment by Bentaleb - The Algerian Zidane (U5073)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by TikiTakaFootball49 (U17636)
posted 1 minute ago
City might not even be in pot 1 next season as they may not win it. So they could be in pot 2 or even 3 where as CSKA Moscow and Benfica are in pot 1.What a joke.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think Man City fans would complain if they weren't top seeds because they didn't win the league.

Maybe it is up to Arsenal to actually do something like win the league or champions league to show why they should be considered top seeds.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Benfica, CSKA Moscow top seeds while Barcelona, RM, City, Arsenal are not.

posted on 9/10/14

comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 1 minute ago
Isle of Manc
Liverpool are also a bigger club than us and you,
===============

Liverpool are a bigger club than Arsenal, agreed not Utd.

Stop posting kak

posted on 9/10/14

Normally from a club that is works against.

City fans will say they should be in the 1st pot as champions.

Arsenal say they should be in pot1 because they are consistently better in the CL than City
-------------------------------------------
I say the winner of the big four leagues should be in pot 1, but then the rest of the pot should be decided on coefficients, with a 3 year deciding time.

There's no way Madrid or Barca should ever be in pot 2, and there's no way anyone from Russia or Porto should be in pot 1 at the moment either.

Maybe last year's runner up should get a place in pot 1 as well. At least reward teams for recent performances in the competition rather than just topping a weak league

comment by Neo (U9135)

posted on 9/10/14

I think pretty much the only ones who think it's a bad idea is arsenal, understandably

posted on 9/10/14

M.U.D.D
Channel 5 cup is something your club cant even manage to be in so don't knock it

posted on 9/10/14

comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 1 minute ago
Darren
Get back to us when your team can manage to qualify for Europe then we can talk football until then be quiet
----------------------------------------------------------------------

posted on 9/10/14

City have, and could be this season, in the Europa League with the current format.

I don't think it will have that huge an effect in terms of the groups anyway.

Benfica and Porto have been top seeds for years anyway. PSG would likely be one soon anyway. It's only really the Russian and Italian teams that will benefit. And they'd still potentially get knocked out anyway.

posted on 9/10/14

M.U.D.D
Liverpool are bigger than the both of us so stop posting kak

posted on 9/10/14

"Imagine CSKA Moscow and Benfica battling it out for the Champions League while City, Arsenal, PSG, Atletico Madrid, Schalke battling it out for the
Europa League. Such a flawed system."

It would help bridge the outrageous gap between the CL and the Europa. And return some excitement and unpredictability to both competitions.

posted on 9/10/14

comment by Isle of Manc - Year of the Januzaj (U18323)
posted 20 seconds ago
Normally from a club that is works against.

City fans will say they should be in the 1st pot as champions.

Arsenal say they should be in pot1 because they are consistently better in the CL than City
-------------------------------------------
I say the winner of the big four leagues should be in pot 1, but then the rest of the pot should be decided on coefficients, with a 3 year deciding time.

There's no way Madrid or Barca should ever be in pot 2, and there's no way anyone from Russia or Porto should be in pot 1 at the moment either.

Maybe last year's runner up should get a place in pot 1 as well. At least reward teams for recent performances in the competition rather than just topping a weak league
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly, the system is flawed.

posted on 9/10/14

comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 36 seconds ago
M.U.D.D
Channel 5 cup is something your club cant even manage to be in so don't knock it
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Who was knocking the channel 5 cup? A team coming 4th consistently over a decade with no league title on the horizon really should not be seeded in the "Champions League."

posted on 9/10/14

comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 50 seconds ago
M.U.D.D
Liverpool are bigger than the both of us so stop posting kak
----------------------------------------------------------------------

How are Liverpool bigger than Utd?

posted on 9/10/14

comment by M.U.D.D - Luke Shaw makes me throb with desire... (U9612)
posted 28 seconds ago
comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 36 seconds ago
M.U.D.D
Channel 5 cup is something your club cant even manage to be in so don't knock it
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Who was knocking the channel 5 cup? A team coming 4th consistently over a decade with no league title on the horizon really should not be seeded in the "Champions League."
----------------------------------------------------------------------
<yawn> MUFC starting to talk about the past now like Liverpool fans were as MUFC are rubbish now.

posted on 9/10/14

WNM, you are possibly the most retárded person on here.

Get back to me when you're able to construct a sentence and not act like a complete twaat everyday of your life.

Until then be quiet.

posted on 9/10/14

comment by TikiTakaFootball49 (U17636)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Bentaleb - The Algerian Zidane (U5073)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by TikiTakaFootball49 (U17636)
posted 1 minute ago
City might not even be in pot 1 next season as they may not win it. So they could be in pot 2 or even 3 where as CSKA Moscow and Benfica are in pot 1.What a joke.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think Man City fans would complain if they weren't top seeds because they didn't win the league.

Maybe it is up to Arsenal to actually do something like win the league or champions league to show why they should be considered top seeds.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Benfica, CSKA Moscow top seeds while Barcelona, RM, City, Arsenal are not.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Arsenal considered top seeds currently alongside Barcelona and Real Madrid despite never winning the competition

posted on 9/10/14

Excellent idea. one of the best I have heard. WTF is wrong with the Russian champions being in Pot 1, and a team like Arsenal who continually finish 4th in their domestic league and have to go through qualifying each year being seeded lower. It is a complete nonsense they get automatic Pot 1 seeding every year. Champions of whatever country should always be seeded as high as possible. Teams finishing 4th should be in the bottom pot.

posted on 9/10/14

The PL is the most competitive league in Europe. RM, Barca and Bayern could probably field a reserve team in domestic games and still finish in the top 4. There isn't a team in the Prem that can be guaranteed a CL place these days.

posted on 9/10/14

M.U.D.D
For starters they have won 5 CL's

posted on 9/10/14

comment by TikiTakaFootball49 (U17636)
posted 5 seconds ago
comment by M.U.D.D - Luke Shaw makes me throb with desire... (U9612)
posted 28 seconds ago
comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 36 seconds ago
M.U.D.D
Channel 5 cup is something your club cant even manage to be in so don't knock it
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Who was knocking the channel 5 cup? A team coming 4th consistently over a decade with no league title on the horizon really should not be seeded in the "Champions League."
----------------------------------------------------------------------
<yawn> MUFC starting to talk about the past now like Liverpool fans were as MUFC are rubbish now.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I am talking about the present. You have not won the league in a decade and should not be seeded in the "Champions League."

posted on 9/10/14

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 9/10/14

comment by WengersNearlyMen™ (U5041)
posted 8 seconds ago
M.U.D.D
For starters they have won 5 CL's
----------------------------------------------------------------------

They have won, 1 CL

posted on 9/10/14

comment by thesingingangel (U20025)
posted 24 seconds ago
Excellent idea. one of the best I have heard. WTF is wrong with the Russian champions being in Pot 1, and a team like Arsenal who continually finish 4th in their domestic league and have to go through qualifying each year being seeded lower. It is a complete nonsense they get automatic Pot 1 seeding every year. Champions of whatever country should always be seeded as high as possible. Teams finishing 4th should be in the bottom pot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What if City finish 2nd in the PL and are in the 2nd or 3rd pot while Benfica and CSKA Moscow are in pot 1?

comment by Busby (U19985)

posted on 9/10/14

100

Page 4 of 13

Sign in if you want to comment