Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Not sure why the BBC rumours taken from such sources as the mail and star are believed!
Your boss wanted Schinderlin and why would he look at a similar player he has not worked with before in McCarthy, both are excellent and under-rated in the role they play for each side.
Arouna
Think McCarthy is a smashing player , would not suprise me in the least if indeed Poch is a fan of his.
If it's true then I'd be up for that as he's a good player. From when I've watched him he's a similar type of player to Schneiderlin in terms of style (maybe a slightly inferior version?) but would seemingly fit the style of Poch...
.... Funnily enough I also bought him on Football Manager as my ball-winning midfielder and he's done well for me
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 2 minutes ago
Arouna
Think McCarthy is a smashing player , would not suprise me in the least if indeed Poch is a fan of his.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He may well be a fan.
Sorry, posted before I finished.
But an extended contract is being worked out for him and he has followed Martinez since his transfer down from Scotland. I can't see him moving away from the North West so could only see United as a possible destination
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 37 minutes ago
Schinderlin as you say mate looks like Pochs number 1 target Levy MUST go all out and get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
At what sort of cost exactly? By that I mean if you were Levy and Poch told you he wanted him, how much would you sanction we offer for him? £20m? £30m?
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
comment by Don_tottenham (U3372)
posted 3 hours, 54 minutes ago
Chronic, different subject but as you didn't answer me on the other thread......atmosphere at the lane against ch avs on a scale of 1 - 10? did we give the ba stards stick all game?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
it was good. heard better against chelsea or arsenal in the past.
probably give it an 8. at times a 9, but long periods when it was quiet. especially first half, but yes, we were giving them loads of sticks but they pretty much all left early.
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 10 hours, 50 minutes ago
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If Lallana went for £26m you think £15m and the second coming of Lennon would tempt Everton?
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Be fair to Levy- there was no way Southampton were going to sell Morgan to us last summer.
Cabaye would be a fantastic signing. Haven't really seen enough of McCarthy, but clearly we have a CM berth going free (Mason has nowhere near the quality for us longer-term, even though his drive and desire is commendable)
He was Everton's best player last season. There was a joke floating about at one point saying 'Water covers 70% of the Earth's service, the other 30% is covered by McCarthy', top player.
posted 5 hours, 35 minutes ago
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 10 hours, 50 minutes ago
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If Lallana went for £26m you think £15m and the second coming of Lennon would tempt Everton?
------------------------------------------
I was talking about schinderlin mate.
people still blaming Levy for not signing MS
they must think we are Real Madrid
unlimited funds.
southampton made it perfectly clear that he was not for sale last summer, and we don't have the money to start bidding ridiculous money for MS of all people.
good player though, no doubt.
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 1 hour, 41 minutes ago
posted 5 hours, 35 minutes ago
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 10 hours, 50 minutes ago
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If Lallana went for £26m you think £15m and the second coming of Lennon would tempt Everton?
------------------------------------------
I was talking about schinderlin mate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank God for that! Townsend is a player I wouldnt want
Sign in if you want to comment
James McCarthy Rumour
Page 2 of 2
posted on 2/1/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/1/15
ebo, brilliant mate
posted on 2/1/15
Not sure why the BBC rumours taken from such sources as the mail and star are believed!
Your boss wanted Schinderlin and why would he look at a similar player he has not worked with before in McCarthy, both are excellent and under-rated in the role they play for each side.
posted on 2/1/15
Arouna
Think McCarthy is a smashing player , would not suprise me in the least if indeed Poch is a fan of his.
posted on 2/1/15
If it's true then I'd be up for that as he's a good player. From when I've watched him he's a similar type of player to Schneiderlin in terms of style (maybe a slightly inferior version?) but would seemingly fit the style of Poch...
.... Funnily enough I also bought him on Football Manager as my ball-winning midfielder and he's done well for me
posted on 2/1/15
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 2 minutes ago
Arouna
Think McCarthy is a smashing player , would not suprise me in the least if indeed Poch is a fan of his.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He may well be a fan.
posted on 2/1/15
Sorry, posted before I finished.
But an extended contract is being worked out for him and he has followed Martinez since his transfer down from Scotland. I can't see him moving away from the North West so could only see United as a possible destination
posted on 2/1/15
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 37 minutes ago
Schinderlin as you say mate looks like Pochs number 1 target Levy MUST go all out and get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
At what sort of cost exactly? By that I mean if you were Levy and Poch told you he wanted him, how much would you sanction we offer for him? £20m? £30m?
posted on 3/1/15
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
posted on 3/1/15
comment by Don_tottenham (U3372)
posted 3 hours, 54 minutes ago
Chronic, different subject but as you didn't answer me on the other thread......atmosphere at the lane against ch avs on a scale of 1 - 10? did we give the ba stards stick all game?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
it was good. heard better against chelsea or arsenal in the past.
probably give it an 8. at times a 9, but long periods when it was quiet. especially first half, but yes, we were giving them loads of sticks but they pretty much all left early.
posted on 3/1/15
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 10 hours, 50 minutes ago
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If Lallana went for £26m you think £15m and the second coming of Lennon would tempt Everton?
posted on 3/1/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/1/15
Be fair to Levy- there was no way Southampton were going to sell Morgan to us last summer.
Cabaye would be a fantastic signing. Haven't really seen enough of McCarthy, but clearly we have a CM berth going free (Mason has nowhere near the quality for us longer-term, even though his drive and desire is commendable)
posted on 3/1/15
He was Everton's best player last season. There was a joke floating about at one point saying 'Water covers 70% of the Earth's service, the other 30% is covered by McCarthy', top player.
posted on 3/1/15
posted 5 hours, 35 minutes ago
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 10 hours, 50 minutes ago
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If Lallana went for £26m you think £15m and the second coming of Lennon would tempt Everton?
------------------------------------------
I was talking about schinderlin mate.
posted on 3/1/15
people still blaming Levy for not signing MS
they must think we are Real Madrid
unlimited funds.
southampton made it perfectly clear that he was not for sale last summer, and we don't have the money to start bidding ridiculous money for MS of all people.
good player though, no doubt.
posted on 3/1/15
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 1 hour, 41 minutes ago
posted 5 hours, 35 minutes ago
comment by WHL Lifer #2 (U9994)
posted 10 hours, 50 minutes ago
25 million would do the trick. Maybe even do 15million and Townsend. Poch wants him so go get him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If Lallana went for £26m you think £15m and the second coming of Lennon would tempt Everton?
------------------------------------------
I was talking about schinderlin mate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thank God for that! Townsend is a player I wouldnt want
Page 2 of 2