I've watched it about 5 times and I don't see what VVD does to warrant a red.

yellow, yes but red, no.

As for the only part he got right, so he got it right by not sending off Cifti?

I've already said my view on it:

Brown - Possible red
VVD - Yellow
Butcher - Yellow
Cifti - Red
Dixon- possible red (harsh)

Joking aside on McGowan's tackle, it was a nasty one and he didn't even get a booking for it

I want a still image of it NNH

I thought dixons was harsh tbh

brown I wouldn't have given a red, a booking though
cifti - red
butcher yellow
dijk yellow
McGowan - yellow (its a red but its not on purpose so i'd say yellow)

NNH - I think the initial tackle was borderline red, could go either way, but I'd say it was worthy of a red. The fighting on the ground was also red-worthy, but you seem to think Butcher was only deserving of a yellow, so maybe that's up to interpretation as well.

As for "As for the only part he got right, so he got it right by not sending off Cifti?" - mind putting that in English for me?

Wait ...which Butcher tackle are you talking about? I thought you meant the one he got booked for in the second half?

If you mean the tackle in the melee then it's nowhere near as bad as Brown's ffs.

I also wouldn't have had too many complaints if McGowan was ordered off for that tackle. I said it was ugly ffs.

And Keny I'm not saying we were hard done by - you're seeing what you want to see.

If Butcher hasnt been cited then i suspect VVD will get away with it

also same for the diver

we move on to Sunday

And Keny we were hard done by

===========

well if that's how u feel...

As for "As for the only part he got right, so he got it right by not sending off Cifti?" - mind putting that in English for me?






You said the ref only got one thing right (the ordering off of VVD)

So do you believe he was correct in NOT showing Cifti a red card?

If VVD doesn't win his appeal and no Dundee United player involved in that incident is banned also then it makes a farce of the system.

No one should be banned, there was flook all in it apart from Cifti kicking someone on the head.

"So do you believe he was correct in NOT showing Cifti a red card?"

No, I said the only part he got right was sending VvD off. That means he got it wrong by not sending off Brown or Çiftçi. Both should have gone, and the two teams should have each been down to 9 men, with Butcher off instead of Paton.

Ah I get you

comment by NNH - SCENES (U10730)
posted 2 minutes ago
If VVD doesn't win his appeal and no Dundee United player involved in that incident is banned also then it makes a farce of the system.

No one should be banned, there was flook all in it apart from Cifti kicking someone on the head.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

agreed nnh

paranoid united fans, that used to getting their way man

Anyway, good debating guy's. Please don't like this get in the way of my love for you Ivan

See you at Lesser Hampden at half 2 on Sunday for a wee scrap

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

If he does get off then our team will likely be:

Gordon

Matthews
Denny
VVD
Izzy

Brown
Bitton

Forrest
Johansen
Commons

Griffiths

NNH, perhaps too many double negatives flying around. Or you just need to learn how to read better.

For clarification, my opinion:
Brown - red
Çiftçi - red
van Dijk - red
Butcher - red
Dixon - red
McGowan - don't remember the tackle
Paton - red for not spitting on anybody
Connolly - dived, but there was contact. Eduardo got off with his dive against Celtic a few years ago because of minimal contact, which probably marked a precedent.

Probably the latter mate

Thank flook you aren't a ref though, we would be playing 7s every week

rnr

The Celtic statement is hilariously desperate

It's genious, I said it today, this now puts pressure on the SFA to clear VVD

Well played

I really hope he doesn't get off. There will be a meltdown.

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Quite right from celtic