no
he has his own set of issues
if we change managers it would have to be someone proven recently. If we're going to roll the dice on someone with an all-in attacking ethos that can be hit or miss, we may as well stick with Rodgers
How could anyone say no?
Wenger, although deeply flawed in the last decade, is a proven trophy winner.
Ideally fantasy world I wouldn't want either, but as its a straight choice offered I would have to go with Wenger.
your board would encourage wenger to spend, you would make much better signings
Wenger is in a different league to Rodgers
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
No thanks
2 FA cups in a decade, zero chance of winning the CL, League Cup, St Johnstone Paint Trophy or the PL...
Better stick to the devil you know for now
Its only the last 2 season where hes had money to spend and hes delivered 2 trophies again.
In our lean 9 years he had nothing to spend and kept us in the CL.
If Rodgers had nothing to spend u guys would be mid table cannon fodder which u almost are.
I want Wenger replaced at Arsenal, but only by a big name.
He'd definitely be better than Rodgers, because his name value would help attract players.
Wenger is also a specialist at achieving what Liverpool want to achieve... Top 4.
Wenger every day.
He has won the league, got Tony Adams playing football.
The reason I was banned from the Arsenal board was 2 years ago I said that Wenger had taken Arsenal as far as he could. I don't think I was wrong either.
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
So you think BR can win old big ears and the PL anytime soon?
comment by manusince52 (U9692)
posted 1 minute ago
So you think BR can win old big ears and the PL anytime soon?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
No, but nor can Wenger so, on those terms, a swap would be pointless.
Not dissin Wenger or his record, but for the sake of balance it has to be said that Rodgers has brought Liverpool closer to the title than Wenger has Arsenal in the last 10 years
comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)
posted 6 minutes ago
The reason I was banned from the Arsenal board was 2 years ago I said that Wenger had taken Arsenal as far as he could. I don't think I was wrong either.
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seriously? You got banned for that?
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
That's irrelevant.
Liverpool are a 6th-8th place team trying to make the step up to being a Top 4 team.
Wenger's flawless record in that respect, makes him almost perfect for Liverpool.
Wenger was Manager of the Decade 🏆 - his mere appointment would elevate Liverpool in the eyes of the footballing world.
For a club like Arsenal, he's not good enough anymore, but let's not pretend he's not good enough for Liverpool.
I don't think we have a realistic chance at major honours (but not completely impossible either) with Wenger or Rodgers. We're too financially outgunned and our targets know it (that's why they reject us so often).
Wenger would try Plan A every year for 5 years
Brodge would try Plan A, B, C, D, E, F and G over 5 years
Some of Brodge's plans would be humiliatingly bad
Some quite good but still not as Good as Wenger's Plan A
But one of them will lead to a 20 match run of nearly all wins (2 at the back with 2 left wingers or some completely bizarre thing) it will smoke Wenger's plan A giving us 1 actual chance at a title.
Considering I think we may not (and should not) ever win a title again anyway, I'll stick with Rodgers.
Plan E
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
It's a shiitt package all around RAP
I wouldn't swap but that has little to do with respective abilities (Wenger is clearly the better manager at the moment) and everything to do with Wenger being at retirement age!
If Wenger was 10 years younger then I'd swap without a second thought.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by Peggy (U20614)
posted 54 minutes ago
comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)
posted 6 minutes ago
The reason I was banned from the Arsenal board was 2 years ago I said that Wenger had taken Arsenal as far as he could. I don't think I was wrong either.
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seriously? You got banned for that?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It was actually a well written article. Even Admin said it should of stayed. I hardly ever write articles on other teams boards but did that to see what the arsenal fans thought.
Would Pool fans swap him for Pellegrini?
No purely for the fact we need to make signings to improve and he wouldn't be prepared to do it
you're on crack Vic
of course not.
At the moment, barring possibly Chelsea, every top club in England has a manager where it's at least 50/50 if not more people thinking changing the manager isn't a bad idea.
LvG is a freak
Brodge had a horrid season last year
Wenger's few remaing supporters seem to be giving up after the transfer window
Pelle had a rubbish season last year and up until this xfer window, didn't have any changes for the better to their XI for years.
It's not pretty reading
Sign in if you want to comment
Would you swap Rodgers for Wenger?
Page 1 of 2
posted on 3/9/15
no
he has his own set of issues
if we change managers it would have to be someone proven recently. If we're going to roll the dice on someone with an all-in attacking ethos that can be hit or miss, we may as well stick with Rodgers
posted on 3/9/15
How could anyone say no?
Wenger, although deeply flawed in the last decade, is a proven trophy winner.
Ideally fantasy world I wouldn't want either, but as its a straight choice offered I would have to go with Wenger.
posted on 3/9/15
No
posted on 3/9/15
your board would encourage wenger to spend, you would make much better signings
posted on 3/9/15
Wenger is in a different league to Rodgers
posted on 3/9/15
Yes
posted on 3/9/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/9/15
No thanks
2 FA cups in a decade, zero chance of winning the CL, League Cup, St Johnstone Paint Trophy or the PL...
Better stick to the devil you know for now
posted on 3/9/15
Its only the last 2 season where hes had money to spend and hes delivered 2 trophies again.
In our lean 9 years he had nothing to spend and kept us in the CL.
If Rodgers had nothing to spend u guys would be mid table cannon fodder which u almost are.
posted on 3/9/15
I want Wenger replaced at Arsenal, but only by a big name.
He'd definitely be better than Rodgers, because his name value would help attract players.
Wenger is also a specialist at achieving what Liverpool want to achieve... Top 4.
posted on 3/9/15
Wenger every day.
He has won the league, got Tony Adams playing football.
posted on 3/9/15
The reason I was banned from the Arsenal board was 2 years ago I said that Wenger had taken Arsenal as far as he could. I don't think I was wrong either.
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
posted on 3/9/15
So you think BR can win old big ears and the PL anytime soon?
posted on 3/9/15
comment by manusince52 (U9692)
posted 1 minute ago
So you think BR can win old big ears and the PL anytime soon?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
No, but nor can Wenger so, on those terms, a swap would be pointless.
Not dissin Wenger or his record, but for the sake of balance it has to be said that Rodgers has brought Liverpool closer to the title than Wenger has Arsenal in the last 10 years
posted on 3/9/15
comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)
posted 6 minutes ago
The reason I was banned from the Arsenal board was 2 years ago I said that Wenger had taken Arsenal as far as he could. I don't think I was wrong either.
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seriously? You got banned for that?
posted on 3/9/15
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
That's irrelevant.
Liverpool are a 6th-8th place team trying to make the step up to being a Top 4 team.
Wenger's flawless record in that respect, makes him almost perfect for Liverpool.
Wenger was Manager of the Decade 🏆 - his mere appointment would elevate Liverpool in the eyes of the footballing world.
For a club like Arsenal, he's not good enough anymore, but let's not pretend he's not good enough for Liverpool.
posted on 3/9/15
I don't think we have a realistic chance at major honours (but not completely impossible either) with Wenger or Rodgers. We're too financially outgunned and our targets know it (that's why they reject us so often).
Wenger would try Plan A every year for 5 years
Brodge would try Plan A, B, C, D, E, F and G over 5 years
Some of Brodge's plans would be humiliatingly bad
Some quite good but still not as Good as Wenger's Plan A
But one of them will lead to a 20 match run of nearly all wins (2 at the back with 2 left wingers or some completely bizarre thing) it will smoke Wenger's plan A giving us 1 actual chance at a title.
Considering I think we may not (and should not) ever win a title again anyway, I'll stick with Rodgers.
Plan E
posted on 3/9/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/9/15
It's a shiitt package all around RAP
posted on 3/9/15
I wouldn't swap but that has little to do with respective abilities (Wenger is clearly the better manager at the moment) and everything to do with Wenger being at retirement age!
If Wenger was 10 years younger then I'd swap without a second thought.
posted on 3/9/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 3/9/15
comment by Peggy (U20614)
posted 54 minutes ago
comment by T Bone Steak Roysters (U3947)
posted 6 minutes ago
The reason I was banned from the Arsenal board was 2 years ago I said that Wenger had taken Arsenal as far as he could. I don't think I was wrong either.
He will never win old big ears and i think he will not win the league in the near future either.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seriously? You got banned for that?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It was actually a well written article. Even Admin said it should of stayed. I hardly ever write articles on other teams boards but did that to see what the arsenal fans thought.
posted on 3/9/15
Would Pool fans swap him for Pellegrini?
posted on 3/9/15
No purely for the fact we need to make signings to improve and he wouldn't be prepared to do it
posted on 3/9/15
you're on crack Vic
of course not.
At the moment, barring possibly Chelsea, every top club in England has a manager where it's at least 50/50 if not more people thinking changing the manager isn't a bad idea.
LvG is a freak
Brodge had a horrid season last year
Wenger's few remaing supporters seem to be giving up after the transfer window
Pelle had a rubbish season last year and up until this xfer window, didn't have any changes for the better to their XI for years.
It's not pretty reading
Page 1 of 2