Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 3 minutes ago
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
the actual story progression isnt that bad,,, its just idiotic moments followed by moments of absolute unexplained idiocy and absolute amateur plot mistakes. I know its Star Wars and with that comes an extra layer of acceptence of sillyness or plot holes but its just constant now in every single episode.
Dont get me wrong from a cinematic POV its really quite good, sometimes she gets the mood and atmosphere spot on, but most of the time its just like I said complete amateur stuff (plot holes wise) that I wouldnt expect from a 10 yr old.
This doesn't relate to any episodes in specific but I'm confused and slightly frustrated that the music has been so poor in the show. Music has always been one of the key pillars of Star Wars success and not just the main theme either. Why have we not heard Leia's iconic theme? Why have we not heard the force theme? Why have we not heard the imperial march when we see Vader? Will they even play battle of heroes when Vader and Obi wan fight again?
Off the top of my head:
Obi Wan watches over Luke-Play Binary sunset theme
We first see Leia-Play Leia's theme
Obi Wan uses the force again-Play force theme
Vader chokes village-Play imperial march
Revas rooftop scene-Play Dual of fates
Obi Wan digs up the sabers-Play main theme
its hard to say what I men whithout acctually talking about the ep specifically. I dont know what tolerated as a spoiler.. I could talk about certain situations without spoiling it I suppose, but its borderline so will just wait
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 9 minutes ago
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ep 4 has just as many really stupid parts to it as did ep 2. there is some normal total cliche moments in film in it but also some ... wtf.... are you not gonna explain that at all!?!?!
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 7 minutes ago
its hard to say what I men whithout acctually talking about the ep specifically. I dont know what tolerated as a spoiler.. I could talk about certain situations without spoiling it I suppose, but its borderline so will just wait
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Probably wise not to get into anymore detail.
I think the main issue with Deborah Chow and these writers is that there is nobody like Filoni and Favreau overseeing everything. Chow directed a few episodes of the Mandalorian and both were written by Favreau.
I thought Bryce Dallas Howard should be given a Star Wars project, based on her directing during Mando but now I have doubts, especially if Filoni and Favreau are not involved.
Guv, I already know which way you’re gonna go. I have foreseen it…
Jon Favreau wrote boba fett
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 16 minutes ago
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No spoilers at all from me but I really don't think Ep4 is as bad as some on here.
It's too short, that much I completely agree with, and a little too formulaic for my liking but there are interesting elements and a nod to Clone Wars in there. It felt like SW to me and that's my baseline requirement!
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 5 minutes ago
Jon Favreau wrote boba fett
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he did but he isn't infallible. There were some weaker episodes in Mando too but overall his credit still holds up. Let's not forget, the few good episodes in Boba, which consisted of Mando appearing, were some of the best we have seen.
yeah, and the rest was utter crap
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 5 minutes ago
Jon Favreau wrote boba fett
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he did but he isn't infallible. There were some weaker episodes in Mando too but overall his credit still holds up. Let's not forget, the few good episodes in Boba, which consisted of Mando appearing, were some of the best we have seen.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think if the last episodes of Boba were in the Mandalorian series it woulnt look out of place (wouldnt stand out either) but literally EVERYTHING else about Boba was utter dross !
i gave ep - 4 it would have been a 2/3 if it hadnt been star wars and ewan doing a decent job.
*gave ep 4 - 4/10 that should say
So where we at..:
Simon West
MK
StringerBell
Whodunnit
TBag
Cinci
Naby8
Pun
Taki
DJ
FFS Mike
Just Guv left innit?
How exclusionary. I haven’t watched it yet but I probably will tonight and spoilers don’t really bother me when it comes to average shows or films.
https://youtu.be/NdXLDvx_tHQ
Tarkin spent the whole of New Hope in a pair of slippers
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 22 minutes ago
https://youtu.be/NdXLDvx_tHQ
Tarkin spent the whole of New Hope in a pair of slippers
----------------------------------------------------------------------
brilliant
Where did you dig up that old fossil? That’s a gem.
Hmm, And where is Tarkin at this point? I mean somehow, in the next 10 years from Obi-Wan, Leia comes face to face with Vader, and is aware who Tarkin is and how powerful he is over Vader…
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 47 minutes ago
https://youtu.be/NdXLDvx_tHQ
Tarkin spent the whole of New Hope in a pair of slippers
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah saw that. His boots hurt too much or something 😂
Today will be a long day remembered…
We have overtaken the Marvel Thread!!
Now find me a Stormtrooper helmet to drum on!!!
https://youtu.be/WBrLHMCTDAA
Bit lost at the hate for this episode!!!
comment by Cinciwolf---Tenth it is. (U11551)
posted 1 minute ago
Bit lost at the hate for this episode!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not at even the glaringly obvious plot holes that 10 yr old would pick up on? IMO thats only plausible if what your watching is a outrageous action effort. but this was a story based filler episode that had glaring continuity errors
Sign in if you want to comment
A Galaxy Far Far Away......
Page 195 of 576
196 | 197 | 198 | 199 | 200
posted on 9/6/22
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
posted on 9/6/22
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 3 minutes ago
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
the actual story progression isnt that bad,,, its just idiotic moments followed by moments of absolute unexplained idiocy and absolute amateur plot mistakes. I know its Star Wars and with that comes an extra layer of acceptence of sillyness or plot holes but its just constant now in every single episode.
Dont get me wrong from a cinematic POV its really quite good, sometimes she gets the mood and atmosphere spot on, but most of the time its just like I said complete amateur stuff (plot holes wise) that I wouldnt expect from a 10 yr old.
posted on 9/6/22
This doesn't relate to any episodes in specific but I'm confused and slightly frustrated that the music has been so poor in the show. Music has always been one of the key pillars of Star Wars success and not just the main theme either. Why have we not heard Leia's iconic theme? Why have we not heard the force theme? Why have we not heard the imperial march when we see Vader? Will they even play battle of heroes when Vader and Obi wan fight again?
Off the top of my head:
Obi Wan watches over Luke-Play Binary sunset theme
We first see Leia-Play Leia's theme
Obi Wan uses the force again-Play force theme
Vader chokes village-Play imperial march
Revas rooftop scene-Play Dual of fates
Obi Wan digs up the sabers-Play main theme
posted on 9/6/22
its hard to say what I men whithout acctually talking about the ep specifically. I dont know what tolerated as a spoiler.. I could talk about certain situations without spoiling it I suppose, but its borderline so will just wait
posted on 9/6/22
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 9 minutes ago
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
ep 4 has just as many really stupid parts to it as did ep 2. there is some normal total cliche moments in film in it but also some ... wtf.... are you not gonna explain that at all!?!?!
posted on 9/6/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 7 minutes ago
its hard to say what I men whithout acctually talking about the ep specifically. I dont know what tolerated as a spoiler.. I could talk about certain situations without spoiling it I suppose, but its borderline so will just wait
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Probably wise not to get into anymore detail.
posted on 9/6/22
I think the main issue with Deborah Chow and these writers is that there is nobody like Filoni and Favreau overseeing everything. Chow directed a few episodes of the Mandalorian and both were written by Favreau.
I thought Bryce Dallas Howard should be given a Star Wars project, based on her directing during Mando but now I have doubts, especially if Filoni and Favreau are not involved.
posted on 9/6/22
Guv, I already know which way you’re gonna go. I have foreseen it…
posted on 9/6/22
Jon Favreau wrote boba fett
posted on 9/6/22
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 16 minutes ago
Episode 2 has easily been the worst for me,so episode 4 will have to be really bad, to take that spot.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No spoilers at all from me but I really don't think Ep4 is as bad as some on here.
It's too short, that much I completely agree with, and a little too formulaic for my liking but there are interesting elements and a nod to Clone Wars in there. It felt like SW to me and that's my baseline requirement!
posted on 9/6/22
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 5 minutes ago
Jon Favreau wrote boba fett
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he did but he isn't infallible. There were some weaker episodes in Mando too but overall his credit still holds up. Let's not forget, the few good episodes in Boba, which consisted of Mando appearing, were some of the best we have seen.
posted on 9/6/22
yeah, and the rest was utter crap
posted on 9/6/22
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 5 minutes ago
Jon Favreau wrote boba fett
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yes he did but he isn't infallible. There were some weaker episodes in Mando too but overall his credit still holds up. Let's not forget, the few good episodes in Boba, which consisted of Mando appearing, were some of the best we have seen.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think if the last episodes of Boba were in the Mandalorian series it woulnt look out of place (wouldnt stand out either) but literally EVERYTHING else about Boba was utter dross !
i gave ep - 4 it would have been a 2/3 if it hadnt been star wars and ewan doing a decent job.
posted on 9/6/22
*gave ep 4 - 4/10 that should say
posted on 9/6/22
So where we at..:
Simon West
MK
StringerBell
Whodunnit
TBag
Cinci
Naby8
Pun
Taki
DJ
FFS Mike
Just Guv left innit?
posted on 9/6/22
4za and Superb I think
posted on 9/6/22
How exclusionary. I haven’t watched it yet but I probably will tonight and spoilers don’t really bother me when it comes to average shows or films.
posted on 9/6/22
I'll watch it tonight
posted on 9/6/22
https://youtu.be/NdXLDvx_tHQ
Tarkin spent the whole of New Hope in a pair of slippers
posted on 9/6/22
And Sat Nav
posted on 9/6/22
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 22 minutes ago
https://youtu.be/NdXLDvx_tHQ
Tarkin spent the whole of New Hope in a pair of slippers
----------------------------------------------------------------------
brilliant
Where did you dig up that old fossil? That’s a gem.
Hmm, And where is Tarkin at this point? I mean somehow, in the next 10 years from Obi-Wan, Leia comes face to face with Vader, and is aware who Tarkin is and how powerful he is over Vader…
posted on 9/6/22
comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 47 minutes ago
https://youtu.be/NdXLDvx_tHQ
Tarkin spent the whole of New Hope in a pair of slippers
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah saw that. His boots hurt too much or something 😂
posted on 9/6/22
Today will be a long day remembered…
We have overtaken the Marvel Thread!!
Now find me a Stormtrooper helmet to drum on!!!
https://youtu.be/WBrLHMCTDAA
posted on 9/6/22
Bit lost at the hate for this episode!!!
posted on 9/6/22
comment by Cinciwolf---Tenth it is. (U11551)
posted 1 minute ago
Bit lost at the hate for this episode!!!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not at even the glaringly obvious plot holes that 10 yr old would pick up on? IMO thats only plausible if what your watching is a outrageous action effort. but this was a story based filler episode that had glaring continuity errors
Page 195 of 576
196 | 197 | 198 | 199 | 200