or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 120 comments are related to an article called:

Man City >>>>>>> Man U

Page 3 of 5

posted on 2/9/11

Ashley 'Headless' Young is one of the worst footballers to grace this planet.

I came across the idiot in the Bullring, Birmingham.
Didn't think he deserved my attention. Logical though.
He plays like ordinary rubbish, so I'll ignore him like the rest of the ordinary people.

Yet Fergie felt the need to sign that bull.

posted on 2/9/11

7_The_Best (U5768)

I wasn't asking whether or not you were trying to start an argument...I was referring to your comment that the OP was trying to start one!



Anyway, maybe he was. My point still stands though about the way a lot of United fans react to comments from City/Arsenal/Liverpool fans...

The fans of those clubs know that United have/have had a stronger team recently, yet in this instance the OP has a point (whatever his intentions were!).

To simply react by rubbishing his team is childish, would you not agree?



Imagine if we were back in the 80's, and you as a United fan had an opinion that United were beginning to show signs of a return to winning ways...do you think it would be fair comment for a Liverpool fan to reply, 'shut up, your opinion means nothing because you lot have not won the title for x amount of years', thus ending the debate?



posted on 2/9/11

Dubbed the New Wenger, I take it you did'nt enjoy his two goals and assist then against Arsenal?

Also, Arshavin is probably the worst, most selfish, lazy player in the League, I'm not just saying that now, even during the United match I was telling my mates just how useless this player is!

A detriment to Arsenal is all he is

posted on 2/9/11

"Also, Arshavin is probably the worst, most selfish, lazy player in the League, I'm not just saying that now, even during the United match I was telling my mates just how useless this player is!"

Arshavin is 'useless', but Young is a top player, eh? Typical Manc delusion. They have something go their way, and all of a sudden they rule the world, possessing the best players in the world.

posted on 2/9/11

Asley Young = Quality Player and a Bargain

posted on 2/9/11

comment by Dubbed The New Wenger (U9163)

-----------------------

Oh I just know you'd get on your knees and beg to have someone who can curl in shots like Young did against your 'great' keeper

posted on 2/9/11

Anyway, maybe he was. My point still stands though about the way a lot of United fans react to comments from City/Arsenal/Liverpool fans...
.....................................

You mean in the same way the City fan acted ?

Please don't tell me your trying to say the scousers don't get defensive and rubbish an opponents club rather than debate their points...

I have seen a Chelsea and Liverpool debate turn into a bunch of laughing faces with the names Carroll, Henderson, Shevchenko and Torres thrown about..

Hell even when your not trying to wum the pool board you can get your team abused (although after all the wumming its not that surprising the scousers are a little sensitive)

What point does the op have ?!

He states City are clearly far superior, outside of maybe a few scousers (who always put United down) you wouldn't find many people agreeing with that. Even the City fans themselves wouldn't say they are clearly far superior...

If he had kept it realistic he would have been taken seriously, as it is he was on the wind up, so why give a wum the satisfaction of doing what he wants ?

Most people intrested in debate will get it, most people intresting in wumming will get wummed back, the op wummed and got wummed back, I fail to see the big deal ?

...................................................
Imagine if we were back in the 80's, and you as a United fan had an opinion that United were beginning to show signs of a return to winning ways...do you think it would be fair comment for a Liverpool fan to reply, 'shut up, your opinion means nothing because you lot have not won the title for x amount of years', thus ending the debate?
..............................................

If I went up to a pool fan and made a bunch of idiotic comments would I be suprised that it didn't break out into a mature debate ?

No, you get out what you put in

posted on 2/9/11

An opinion from an arsenal fan.... who gives a ****e??!

posted on 2/9/11

7_The_Best (U5768)

What point does the op have ?!

He states City are clearly far superior, outside of maybe a few scousers (who always put United down) you wouldn't find many people agreeing with that.
--------------------------------------------

Isn't this exactly why there should be debate, isn't this the point of this forum? I think that City's squad is superior to United's...just because you don't doesn't mean it is a ridiculous concept and not worthy of debate!

Listen, I understand that the guy was probably on a wind up, but my points still stand, far too often on this board a superiority complex comes out and is seen as a way to end any debate, without actually debating the issues put forward!

This article is obviously a poor example of what I am trying to say, I hope you are clever enough to get my point besides that!

posted on 2/9/11

My point being that just because your team enjoys more success, this does not automatically negate the opinion of others!!

posted on 2/9/11

There is a big difference between stating City's squad is superior (I disagree but can understand where that opinion comes from) and stating that City's squad is clearly far superior....

It's the words clearly and far that make it unrealistic. The word clearly implies obvious to all who know anything about football. Far superior implies not just better but streets ahead. Both of which are rubbish really...

.....................................................
far too often on this board a superiority complex comes out and is seen as a way to end any debate, without actually debating the issues put forward!
....................................................

If by this board you mean it only happens on the United board then you are wrong as even in this topic a City fan made a comment similar to the ones United fans are making...

The liverpool board is terrible for it, practically every time a chelsea fan makes a criticism its Torres 50m or talking about champions league trophies..

I get your point, but do you understand that fans of all the big teams do it, to call it a superority complex of just the United board would be folly as evidenced in this very thread..

posted on 2/9/11

It's down the the individual, whether they want to treat someone with the contempt they deserve or not. It's a **** article designed to wind up. So give some back end of.

posted on 2/9/11

7_The_Best

I can only really talk about the United board, seeing as I camp out on there, hence my specific comments!

...if you are saying that Liverpool and Arsenal fans (and others) are ending debates with United fans by using their clubs superiority then I doubt you are being truthful (seeing as they are not superior that is!)...however, at least you get my point!



Oh, and if it is happening, then I disagree with that...it still doesn't make it right though does it!

posted on 2/9/11

Oh, forgot to mention the fact that the use of 'far' and 'clearly' can be seen as misguided, however, he could be proven to be correct, it is after all just an opinion!

posted on 2/9/11

.if you are saying that Liverpool and Arsenal fans (and others) are ending debates with United fans by using their clubs superiority then I doubt you are being truthful
..........................................

If we are just talking about superority then thats a little different, the original discussion was about fans mocking article makers teams rather than debating their points. We attempting a little shift as the previous ground was shall we say, a little thin ?

Even if we are going to talk of superority then pool fans at least do it all the time... I can't tell you the number of times one of them has stated the number of european cups they have won... they also like telling Chelsea fans this one...

But back onto the original discussion most wum articles get wum responses dirced at the article makes team, as you said you rarely visit other teams so you'll have to take my word for it...

.....................................................
Oh, forgot to mention the fact that the use of 'far' and 'clearly' can be seen as misguided, however, he could be proven to be correct, it is after all just an opinion!
.....................................................

If they were clearly far superior it would be alot more apparent to people, the fact that even Citys own fans would not agree (mostly) with that statement indicates that there is no clearly about it...

Far is a more debatable term but based on what we have seen this season there really isn't much in the way of evidence to back up his theory..

What do we call those who make comments to wind people up with no or little evidence to support their assertions ?

Wums...

posted on 2/9/11

Wum logs... do exactly what it says on the tin.

posted on 2/9/11

"so you'll have to take my word for it..."

I'm happy with that



------------------
Secondly, you are now debating the matter, which is good to see!

That is what I like to see, reasoned opinion without having to resort to petty mudslinging and irrelevant mocking!

Football is all about opinions, some sound, some misguided, but all opinions...glad to see you are on board with this!

And finally, a WUM needs no evidence...they just put stuff out there and people bite!!!

posted on 2/9/11

19 times. Best team in the land. Manchester United.

posted on 2/9/11

I am glad we agree it is a problem across the boards!

I am pretty sure I was debating all along, don't think I wummed or mocked once...

I am also glad we agree the word clearly was seriously misused in the OP...

posted on 2/9/11

7_The_Best (U5768)

I didn't say I agreed, I just said I'm happy to take your word on it...let's hope you are being truthful seeing as I have put my faith in you!

My 'reasoned opinion without resorting to mocking' comment(s) was not aimed at you personally!

And the word clearly was misused, he should have said definitely! ...

...only joking!

posted on 2/9/11

19............ best team in the land.

posted on 2/9/11

Good talking, hopefully we get something with a bit more bite to it next time... all the best... love 7.
<SomeKindOfSmoochySmiley>

posted on 2/9/11

Roadhouse!

posted on 2/9/11

7 best

posted on 2/9/11

Dubbed The New Wenger (U9163)

-----

You're so neutral we could rename you 'Battery Acid'.

Page 3 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment