or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 64 comments are related to an article called:

Jimmy Anderson Englands best ever???

Page 3 of 3

posted on 8/9/11

i dont need to look anyone up pal. ive told you the spell with most swing and it was dermott reeve

....................................

And I have told you it is not.

Pal.

posted on 8/9/11

And I have told you it is not.
==========================

well, seeing as you have been able to compare the two spells, what spell of reeve's bowling am i talking about ?

posted on 8/9/11

comment by elvis is a spurs fan (U1059)
posted 3 minutes ago

And I have told you it is not.
==========================

well, seeing as you have been able to compare the two spells, what spell of reeve's bowling am i talking about ?

.................

I have no idea.

There is nothing in his cricket history to suggest he got anywehre near taking 16 wickets on his test debut in an Ashes match at Lords.

Which is what Bob Massie did with the best demonstration of swing bowling ever seen at the home of cricket.

Feel free to point out to me something better.

posted on 8/9/11

Did someone mention Dr Pringle.
He could swing it but at a slow pace.

Not quite a Steyn or Anderson

posted on 8/9/11

comment by Gingerfinch (U2200)
posted 7 minutes ago

Did someone mention Dr Pringle.
He could swing it but at a slow pace.

..............

I was being sarcastic with that one.

posted on 8/9/11

Feel free to point out to me something better.
====================

would i not be allowed to then if you hadnt given your approval for me to do so ?

wisden on bob massie's spell :

"Massie maintained excellent length and direction and his late swing either way always troubled the England batsmen"

coment 218 on the blog :"http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/tms/2007/01/englands_best_odi_xi.shtml

"there must be a place for Dermot Reeve.He produced probabaly the most amazing bowling spell i remember.Can,t remember the full details but it was in Oz i think.All i remember is he was well nigh unplayable because he landed the ball consistently on the right spot(albeit on a helpful wicket) .I seem to recall he got about four wickets but could have had them all.Even though the batsmen couldn't lay bat on ball as Dermot got it to move allways.Can anyone confirm that i remember correctly?Boyks anyone?"


he has got the opponent wrong, but the bowler right. he got it swining so much the players were falling about laughing. there is no way anyone has ever swung a cricket ball as much which is the point i made, before you jumped in without knowing what it was you were commenting on.

posted on 8/9/11

Did someone mention Dr Pringle.
He could swing it but at a slow pace.

..............

I was being sarcastic with that one.

------------------------

I guessed that

posted on 8/9/11

I was being sarcastic with that one.
==============================

you sound like a completetwat

posted on 8/9/11

comment by elvis is a spurs fan (U1059) posted 3 hours, 23 minutes ago

I was being sarcastic with that one.
==============================

you sound like a completetwat

.........................

I would say that a completetwat is someone who thinks taking four wickets in a match is the greatest feat of swing bowling, when you compare it to someone who actualy took 16 wickets in an ashes Test match.

posted on 9/9/11

Best ever? Not yet. Trueman, Botham, Laker, Verity, Larwood all rank above him at the moment. However, his form over the last three years has been spectacular from a slow start.
Afer 36 tests, Anderson had taken 119 wkts at 35.4.
In the next 27 games he's taken 121 at 25.8, including series home and away vs Australia and away against SA, with only 2 games vs Bangaldesh. If he continues that trajectory for the next four years, he'll earn teh right to be grouped with Trueman et al.

posted on 9/9/11

I would say that a completetwat is someone who thinks taking four wickets in a match is the greatest feat of swing bowling,
====================

Let’s recap here, just to set things straight. This is what has happened on this part of the thread :

1. I stated that the most anyone has swung a ball in a spell of bowling is dermott reeve.

2. You introduce yourself by stating that i “might want to look up” bob massey

3. I advised that i do not need to “look up” bob massey and repeated the statement that the most swing on a ball was in a spell from reeve.

4. You stated that you had “told” me that it wasn’t reeve’s spell.

5. I asked you what spell of reeve’s i was talking about, seeing as you have been able to judge in which of the spells the ball swung the most.

6. You said you didn’t know.

7. You said that reeve’s spell can not have been the “greatest” spell of wing bowling because he only took 4 wickets.


The following conclusions can be reached from this series of comments :

1. You are arrogant, rude and ignorant in purporting to correct me without knowing what it is that I was referring to, and also rude and arrogant in assuming that i had never heard of bob massey.

2. You are deceitful, in trying to pretend that the point being made was the “greatest” spell of bowling, not the spell in which the ball swung the most, which is the point that i made before you rudely jumped in.

3. You do not know the difference between a “spell” of bowling, an innings, and a match.

posted on 9/9/11

Let me recap.


You think Dermott Reeve had the best spell of swing bowling ever seen, that he only took four wickets with it, and no one of any note actually saw it, apart from one person on an old BBC Blog.


I thing Bob Massie provided the greatest ever performance of swing bowling ever witness in test cricket. Witnessed at Lords IN AN Ashes test match and annotated in Wisden, and just about any other site you want to look at if you google Bob Massie. Such was the swing he was getting on the ball, that he took 16 wickets in that test match.


To conclude, you sir are an idiot of the highest order.

posted on 9/9/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/9/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Page 3 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment