Brook is too big for Khan now. I expect Khan to go back to his natural 147 while Brook will operate at 154.
Both fighters are out injured now and wont fight until next spring for Khan, maybe longer for Brook.
Khan will probably go back to Garcia while Brook V Canelo maybe if Canelo continue to avoid GGG.
brook vs smith, you heard it here first.
Canelo will be moving up, probably fight Lemieux or BJS in december.
Khan gets a points decision over Brook? No way. Brook lands clean on him at some point and sends him to the canvas.
comment by Mr Chelsea. (U3579)
posted 1 hour, 12 minutes ago
Khan gets a points decision over Brook? No way. Brook lands clean on him at some point and sends him to the canvas.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
nah brook will be on the floor bleeding again after trying to give another guy a sloppy bj.
Why are you polluting the boxing board with rubbish posts? It's not funny nor clever. Just keep it boxing related. It isn't hard.
comment by Mr Chelsea. (U3579)
posted 45 minutes ago
Why are you polluting the boxing board with rubbish posts? It's not funny nor clever. Just keep it boxing related. It isn't hard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
okay, brook looking to cash out, will try to get a fight with canelo or cotto. No one in the super welterweight gives brook the pay day he is looking for.
if he couldn't get a payday at welterweight, how is he gonna get a payday from super welterweight where no casual has heard about a boxer in that division.
Yeah I think Canelo and Brook would be a good fight to be honest however I see Canelo winning that one. Why don't Khan and Brook meet in the muffle weight wise. At a catch weight. Khan doesn't have to boil down to 147 and nor does Brook. You can be sure that Khan will be demanding Kell comes down to 147 when he knows Brook will find it hard.
Won't ever happen.
Khan is a very one dimensional fighter, what he does is very good, but is still one dimension.
Brook has a lot more to his game, better chin, and more power, and has a great variety of shots to land on Khan.
Won't happen though.
khan and brook will happen, its too much £££ for both not to happen now. I said all along khan beats him, better boxer than kell and a has better footwork. He'll have enough to win a decision on the back foot.
Brooks got a slightly bigger profile in the uk after GGG fight. Eddie will do his usual bull crap and sell the fight "they don't like each other"
Casuals will get involved as its a British grudge match
They have got a diverse skill set between them:
Kahn – hand & foot speed.
Brook - Poise, power, reflexes, accuracy, creative angles, punch selection, chin, ring IQ, defence.
Brook wins with conclusive knockout within 8.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
comment by The Guvnor IV -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 14 minutes ago
If the fight happens at 147, I'd favour Khan. Brook's power at 147 isn't as good as it would be at 154. He drains himself to make 147. Khan could decision Brook using his speed but then Brook could land a big shot so it it's a 50/50 fight for me at 147.
At 154, I'd favour Brook.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Problem with that anaysis is that your assuming Brook would have to hit Khan with power to knock him out, which isnt the case. Brook just has to hit Khan cleanly and the KO will come.
All of Khans undoubted ability is critically undermined by the fact that he gets put over / rocked / buzzed by relativley soft punches.
What weight this fight gets made at hardly matters in that regard.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Vik you're over analysing things here. Khan got rocked by Chris Algeiri. He will get rocked and put down by Brook too. The weight doesn't make a bit of difference. We've seen enough of Khan and Brook to see who can take big shots and who can't.
Brook is still a world champion at 147 so he either relinquishes his title or comes back down to 147. Even at 147 you have to favour Brook 60/40 in his favour.
Khan's problem is that when he get's hit with big blows to the body he then leaves his face exposed. Happened against Garcia and more recently against Canelo. That's a basic ploy that Brook will look to use.
I would though still say Brook is unproven even at 147. His CV is weak other than Porter but even Porter is no where near elite level. All this nonsense that he was the best WW V the best MW was very exaggerated.
Brook has 25 KO's on his record at welter. He can punch more than hard enough to give Khan nightmares.
IMO its really that simple.
Oh and the point about Khan getting hit by "countless big shots before he got knocked out" by Garcia nope, cant agree there I'm afraid
From what I remember Khan was out boxing Garcia until Danny started to time him from round 3 onwards and then he just started swinging for Khan, knocked him down twice/three times? before the ref stepped in
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Thats how I remember it too Mr C. Still I've I've not anaylsed it since, so I could be wrong.
Even so, for me Brook is bigger, stronger and has more in his locker than Garcia, so the point is moot.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Sign in if you want to comment
Khan v Brook
Page 1 of 3
posted on 19/9/16
Brook is too big for Khan now. I expect Khan to go back to his natural 147 while Brook will operate at 154.
Both fighters are out injured now and wont fight until next spring for Khan, maybe longer for Brook.
Khan will probably go back to Garcia while Brook V Canelo maybe if Canelo continue to avoid GGG.
posted on 19/9/16
brook vs smith, you heard it here first.
posted on 19/9/16
Canelo will be moving up, probably fight Lemieux or BJS in december.
posted on 19/9/16
Khan gets a points decision over Brook? No way. Brook lands clean on him at some point and sends him to the canvas.
posted on 19/9/16
comment by Mr Chelsea. (U3579)
posted 1 hour, 12 minutes ago
Khan gets a points decision over Brook? No way. Brook lands clean on him at some point and sends him to the canvas.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
nah brook will be on the floor bleeding again after trying to give another guy a sloppy bj.
posted on 19/9/16
Why are you polluting the boxing board with rubbish posts? It's not funny nor clever. Just keep it boxing related. It isn't hard.
posted on 19/9/16
comment by Mr Chelsea. (U3579)
posted 45 minutes ago
Why are you polluting the boxing board with rubbish posts? It's not funny nor clever. Just keep it boxing related. It isn't hard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
okay, brook looking to cash out, will try to get a fight with canelo or cotto. No one in the super welterweight gives brook the pay day he is looking for.
posted on 19/9/16
if he couldn't get a payday at welterweight, how is he gonna get a payday from super welterweight where no casual has heard about a boxer in that division.
posted on 19/9/16
Yeah I think Canelo and Brook would be a good fight to be honest however I see Canelo winning that one. Why don't Khan and Brook meet in the muffle weight wise. At a catch weight. Khan doesn't have to boil down to 147 and nor does Brook. You can be sure that Khan will be demanding Kell comes down to 147 when he knows Brook will find it hard.
posted on 19/9/16
Won't ever happen.
Khan is a very one dimensional fighter, what he does is very good, but is still one dimension.
Brook has a lot more to his game, better chin, and more power, and has a great variety of shots to land on Khan.
Won't happen though.
posted on 19/9/16
khan and brook will happen, its too much £££ for both not to happen now. I said all along khan beats him, better boxer than kell and a has better footwork. He'll have enough to win a decision on the back foot.
posted on 19/9/16
Brooks got a slightly bigger profile in the uk after GGG fight. Eddie will do his usual bull crap and sell the fight "they don't like each other"
Casuals will get involved as its a British grudge match
posted on 20/9/16
They have got a diverse skill set between them:
Kahn – hand & foot speed.
Brook - Poise, power, reflexes, accuracy, creative angles, punch selection, chin, ring IQ, defence.
Brook wins with conclusive knockout within 8.
posted on 20/9/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 20/9/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 20/9/16
comment by The Guvnor IV -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 14 minutes ago
If the fight happens at 147, I'd favour Khan. Brook's power at 147 isn't as good as it would be at 154. He drains himself to make 147. Khan could decision Brook using his speed but then Brook could land a big shot so it it's a 50/50 fight for me at 147.
At 154, I'd favour Brook.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Problem with that anaysis is that your assuming Brook would have to hit Khan with power to knock him out, which isnt the case. Brook just has to hit Khan cleanly and the KO will come.
All of Khans undoubted ability is critically undermined by the fact that he gets put over / rocked / buzzed by relativley soft punches.
What weight this fight gets made at hardly matters in that regard.
posted on 20/9/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 20/9/16
Vik you're over analysing things here. Khan got rocked by Chris Algeiri. He will get rocked and put down by Brook too. The weight doesn't make a bit of difference. We've seen enough of Khan and Brook to see who can take big shots and who can't.
posted on 20/9/16
Brook is still a world champion at 147 so he either relinquishes his title or comes back down to 147. Even at 147 you have to favour Brook 60/40 in his favour.
Khan's problem is that when he get's hit with big blows to the body he then leaves his face exposed. Happened against Garcia and more recently against Canelo. That's a basic ploy that Brook will look to use.
I would though still say Brook is unproven even at 147. His CV is weak other than Porter but even Porter is no where near elite level. All this nonsense that he was the best WW V the best MW was very exaggerated.
posted on 20/9/16
Brook has 25 KO's on his record at welter. He can punch more than hard enough to give Khan nightmares.
IMO its really that simple.
posted on 20/9/16
Oh and the point about Khan getting hit by "countless big shots before he got knocked out" by Garcia nope, cant agree there I'm afraid
posted on 20/9/16
From what I remember Khan was out boxing Garcia until Danny started to time him from round 3 onwards and then he just started swinging for Khan, knocked him down twice/three times? before the ref stepped in
posted on 20/9/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 20/9/16
Thats how I remember it too Mr C. Still I've I've not anaylsed it since, so I could be wrong.
Even so, for me Brook is bigger, stronger and has more in his locker than Garcia, so the point is moot.
posted on 20/9/16
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Page 1 of 3