or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 25 comments are related to an article called:

Gaz's first Derby team ? You choose....

Page 1 of 1

posted on 16/3/17

Back later to see the results

posted on 16/3/17

"Keogh"?

You're an idiot.

comment by Rameses (U7190)

posted on 16/3/17

My ideal formation would be 442 with a midfield diamond.

Carson

Christie Keogh Pearce Ollson
Baird
Ince. Johnson
Hughes
Vydra
Nugent

Horses for courses. I see Baird as a better choice of DM than either deSart or Johnson. But think Johnson should be given a run of games on the left side of midfield.

posted on 16/3/17

Just picking who I think are Gaz type players.
Put CB4 in for you !

comment by Rameses (U7190)

posted on 16/3/17

In a perfect world Fozzie would come in for ollson, Thorne at DM and I believe Vydra could profit from playing off a strong hold up player so it would be Martin for Nugent.
I know it didn't work under Pearson but that's because Pearson was faced with an old guard that didn't want to play for him. I think the mood for change is different now after Mel has kick bottom. He won't stand for any petulance or player power boIlocks because he gave them what they wanted last time and they didn't deliver.

posted on 16/3/17

Ang I did this in the car with Firstborn this morning. My team is the same as yours with Russell rather than Vydra. I think he will go for as solid and workmanlike a team as possible to begin with.

posted on 16/3/17

comment by lastapostleofvidal (U1491)
posted 1 minute ago
Ang I did this in the car with Firstborn this morning. My team is the same as yours with Russell rather than Vydra. I think he will go for as solid and workmanlike a team as possible to begin with.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"Hi, I'm Vidal's, and I need for everyone to know that I did this first. I also told you it was Rowett, remember..? Vidal's. Remember the name."

FFS.

posted on 16/3/17

............................Carson

Not Keogh Not Keogh Not Keogh Not Keogh

Not Keogh Not Keogh Not Keogh Not Keogh

..................Nugent Not Keogh

posted on 16/3/17

Agree with you about Baird, Rameses and wouldn't be surprised if he finds himself at DM sometime this season. I just thought that throwing him into a new position against Forest was a bit soon.
I guess it also depends on his situation for next season

posted on 16/3/17

666, how can you be so uncharitable to our future player/manager !

posted on 16/3/17

Anyway, off to 'work'.
Play nicely, 666

posted on 16/3/17

comment by 🏁AnglianRam🏁It's gonna be great, folks! (U17428)
posted 15 minutes ago
Anyway, off to 'work'.
Play nicely, 666
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Work.😳There's a rumour going round the gin joints here we've had a change.πŸ™„

posted on 16/3/17

What is GR's preferred formation at previous clubs?

comment by Scouse (U9675)

posted on 16/3/17

Formations FFS.

What's wrong with 9 men all chasing the ball in a gang plus a goalhanger in their penalty area?

It worked when we used to play on the park.

posted on 16/3/17

Baird better than Christie for this game agreed

posted on 16/3/17

............Carson
Christie Baird Pearce Ollson
............Keogh
..........Ince Will JR
........Nugger & Bennet

You heard it here first, that is until it becomes reality in which case it was Vidal's idea

posted on 16/3/17

McLaren to Boro?...he needs the pay day

posted on 16/3/17

______________Carson__________________
______Keogh___Baird___Pearce___________
Christie______Johnson_________Lowe_____
_________Hughes_____Bryson___________
__________Nugent___Ince_______________

3-5-2, it's the future. Back in the day they used to play 2-3-5 and I'm also tempted to bring that back, but maybe not just yet.

posted on 16/3/17

comment by ScouseR (U9675)
posted 5 hours, 22 minutes ago
Formations FFS.

What's wrong with 9 men all chasing the ball in a gang plus a goalhanger in their penalty area?

It worked when we used to play on the park.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Did Spart ask you to act as his proxy, Scouse ?

posted on 16/3/17

comment by Igor the last word. (U1993)
posted 5 hours, 26 minutes ago
What is GR's preferred formation at previous clubs?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sounds like he's a pragmatist, not an idealogue.
So whatever suits his best 11.

posted on 16/3/17

comment by 🐏Wassa🐏 (U2584)
posted 6 hours, 55 minutes ago
Baird better than Christie for this game agreed
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Christie injured anyway.

posted on 16/3/17

-----------------Carson
Baird. Keogh. Pearce Olson

Russell. Johnson Hughes. Vydra

----------------- Ince

------------------ Nugent.

We'll smash 'em !

posted on 16/3/17

I’m no expert on tactics, and I keep telling people that football is a simple, beautiful game made difficult by the bourgeoisie but I think we should start the game in a multi stakeholder cooperative formation and try and concentrate on functionality until the rest of the season.

As with most modern formations there’ll have to be a bit of tinkering.

Personally rather than have a big person at the top as we’ve relied on far too heavily for the last few seasons I’d like to see a more fluid formation, maybe if we have an AGM of members acting as the playmaker for the season, we’ll see a better balance in the team. Possibly at the expense of our regular Number 9 and 10 in the executive roles.

I think we’ve been expecting the big man at the top to bring everything else into play, but I know this is going to cause controversy, he hasn’t really done it ever for us in a Derby shirt, he struts around waiting for the ball to be played into his feet 2 yards from an open goal and then if the ball doesn’t find him he screams and shouts at everyone else rather than taking responsibility for making the space and working on his off the ball game, he’s also not the most intelligent player I’ve seen, so for me it’s bite the bullet, count our losses, drop him and start again.

I think in the cooperative formation we’d obviously lose the talismanic carthorse but I’m a big fan of playing a more total football game, where players can rotate positions, build from the ground up and entertain. We’ve tried to fit our misfits into too many traditional authoritarian footballing philosophies of late and I think if we adopted a more grass roots approach we might see some of those misfits pick up their game.

I think we’re going to lose ground in the short term playing this way, but in all honesty we’re going backwards not forwards as it is, I think lining up like this will really let us sort out the deadwood, strip us down to the core and go again from there in the summer.

The main weakness in this formation would be investment and the dictatorship of the fan base. The dictatorship bit I think we could get rid of if we have a ‘vote of no confidence’ clause where those elected to administrative positions are held accountable to the members at all times. Investment is a bit of a gamble, money in a democratic system has always looked a bit dodgy to me, but I think if we try it for the first 45-60 minutes, and it comes up short, then I’d just say balls to it and for the final third, just hand the whole club back to the supporters, pick the players that will play for the shirt not the wage slip, reduce ticket prices to zero, slap up a big screen outside the main entrance for those that can’t get a ticket and broadcast the game for free, live broadcasting also on Rams Internet TV for the exiles, supporters can band together to help the players and coaching staff and their families out with what they need in life (within reason) and then put our heads down, go back to basics, keep calm, take back the beautiful game and hit the opposition for a little full throttle 'our club’s freer than yours' football.

Bring Your Own Beer.

……….......……The……………….
People..in..various..permuatations
…….adding…...……up……………
..to….......…10………….cannot....
………..B de Feated…………

posted on 16/3/17

Evening Wellies

Post of the day.....



........I think ?

posted on 17/3/17

Evening Ang ⚽️

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment