Don't think Sanchez played against forest?

Cause Sanchez didn't play against Nottigham forest

Mkhi played vs Bristol City but Alexis didn’t play vs Forest

The question I want answered is why can Mkhi play in the Europa for Arsenal when Aubameyang, should be join, can not?

Because Dortmund are in the Europa now, whereas United arent.
The rule says you cannot play for 2 teams who are in the same competition- even if you played for the first in a different competition.

'The question I want answered is why can Mkhi play in the Europa for Arsenal when Aubameyang, should be join, can not?'

Think it's something to do with being able to register one player only, or something.

I read it through a couple of times but, as you can tell, the info didn't really stick.

Which is a surprise to me too, being as UEFA rules are such an interesting, not to mention straight forward. subject.

comment by Lexington 125.2 (U8879)
posted 7 minutes ago
'The question I want answered is why can Mkhi play in the Europa for Arsenal when Aubameyang, should be join, can not?'

Think it's something to do with being able to register one player only, or something.

I read it through a couple of times but, as you can tell, the info didn't really stick.

Which is a surprise to me too, being as UEFA rules are such an interesting, not to mention straight forward. subject.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is true, you can only register one player who has played in Europe for another club.
However, it does not answer why Mkhitaryan can but Aubameyang can't - for that choice would not be made if both were eligible until next month - which is answered with the following:


"One player from the above quota of three who has been fielded in a UEFA club
competition group stage match for another club in the current season may
exceptionally be registered, provided that the player has not been fielded:
a. in the same competition for another club; or
b. for another club that is currently in the same competition"

DJ

Mkhitaryan wasn’t an Arsenal player when the first leg was played, so he was banned from the 2nd leg.

He will be able to play in the final if he didn’t play for Utd in the competition.

Sanchez is irrelevant to this.

comment by selbstgerechtein (U7048)
posted 17 seconds ago
Mkhitaryan wasn’t an Arsenal player when the first leg was played, so he was banned from the 2nd leg.

He will be able to play in the final if he didn’t play for Utd in the competition.

Sanchez is irrelevant to this.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is not true. He is cup tied from the final.

comment by selbstgerechtein (U7048)
posted 1 minute ago
Mkhitaryan wasn’t an Arsenal player when the first leg was played, so he was banned from the 2nd leg.

He will be able to play in the final if he didn’t play for Utd in the competition.

Sanchez is irrelevant to this.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Played for United at Bristol City

Can Mkhitaryan play in the Europa for us?

Yes.

Thank god for that

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by selbstgerechtein (U7048)
posted 17 seconds ago
Mkhitaryan wasn’t an Arsenal player when the first leg was played, so he was banned from the 2nd leg.

He will be able to play in the final if he didn’t play for Utd in the competition.

Sanchez is irrelevant to this.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is not true. He is cup tied from the final.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Well it is true, the reason he is cuptied is because he played for Utd in an earlier round, which I did not know and questioned.

It isn't true - the rules state " in the case of a Premier League Club, one who would be registered and eligible to participate in a Premier League match commencing at the same time and on the same date as the Competition match in accordance with the Premier League Rules"

Mkhitaryan would have been eligible to play for Arsenal in the league the night of the Carabao Cup semi final second leg, thus available for the cup semi if he hadn't been cup tied.

You are thinking of the FA Cup - wherein a player cannot play in a replay if he was not registered for the original tie.

An example of this is Oumar Niasse playing in the second leg of last years competition, despite signing for Hull two days after the first leg.

I'm pretty sure Ales Sanchez played one league cup match for us, think it may have been the 3rd round. So if he did then he should be cup tied.

comment by Arsenal_49 (U10665)
posted 1 minute ago
I'm pretty sure Ales Sanchez played one league cup match for us, think it may have been the 3rd round. So if he did then he should be cup tied.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Man Utd went out of the League Cup to Bristol City before he signed for them...

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Arsenal_49 (U10665)
posted 1 minute ago
I'm pretty sure Ales Sanchez played one league cup match for us, think it may have been the 3rd round. So if he did then he should be cup tied.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Man Utd went out of the League Cup to Bristol City before he signed for them...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah but he played for Man United in the FA cup. I assumed cup tied would apply to both domestic competitions not just the one...

Why would it apply to two different competitions?