Welbeck, Ashley Young, Tripper, Rose, Joe Hart, Wilshere and Livermore shouldn't have been picked
Young and Wilshere deserve to be in it. The others though wtf
Phenom
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
No way Livermore or Welbeck should be anywhere near that squad... barely recognizable as Premier league quality never mind intl footy. The rest of it is OK all things considered
Young is getting on now but there isnt many LBs to choose from and he's one of the best in the league on current form
Who should be our back up RB if not Trippier? Don;t go suggesting Trent Alexander Arnold...
Rose also in a position where we don't have much strength in depth right now so makes sense.
Welbeck, Hart and Livermore should consider themselves very lucky though
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilshere is 26 yrs old!
I guess that's Cahill''s England career done.
Young is only being picked on current form, he was solid against LFC and plays regularly. granted he's in his 30s but if you're performing better than 7 other English wing backs you deserve to be in contention
comment by AFCISMYTEAM (U14931)
posted 1 minute ago
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilshere is 26 yrs old!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hadn't mentioned age, Wilshere has had a lot of injuries and Spurs biased aside I liked him for England but we need to look forward.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
best XI out of that lot on current form
Butland
Walker Stones Tarkowski Young
Dier ??
Sterling Dele Rashford
Vardy
Horrendous squad. Makes me as a Scotsman pleased Southgate is in charge because he's clearly not got a clue what's going on.
Anyone watching football this season can see that Joe Hart is finished.
Jake Livermore's stats this season are embarrassingly poor, I don't remember him doing anything positive.
How on earth is Welbeck in it
Mawson isnt very good either, Gomez needs more games before being considered. Cook pretty run of the mill, Young too old and doesnt overlap enough
Wilshere you can at least see the reasoning behind, he when at it is one of your best midfielders.
comment by THudd (U1029)
posted 18 seconds ago
comment by AFCISMYTEAM (U14931)
posted 1 minute ago
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilshere is 26 yrs old!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hadn't mentioned age, Wilshere has had a lot of injuries and Spurs biased aside I liked him for England but we need to look forward.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The fact is we don't have many other English CM's like him, so he's got to be in the team.
Also, the last time we spoke about our young team for the future, we went out to Iceland.
comment by 🎼Galv🎼 Third burglars ♿ rip Steve &... (U10415)
posted 2 minutes ago
I think he misread the Young bit
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't rate Henderson or Wilshere for England, Lewis Cook isn't the answer neither is Livermore.
centre back and central midfield are real problems
In my opinion your best squad would be.
GK Pickford (1st Choice)
GK Butland
GK Pope
LB Rose
LB Bertrand
CB Stones
CB Maguire
CB Jones
CB Tarkowski
RB Walker
RB Trippier
CM Wilshere
CM Dier
CM Loftus-Cheek
CM Hughes
AM Alli
AM Lallana
LW Rashford
LW Lingard
RW Sterling
RW Ox
FW Kane
FW Vardy
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Not Young’s greatest fan but a fair inclusion. Done well in numerous full back and wing back positions and has experience so could be a useful squad player for the world cup - especially with Southgate switchinh between a baxk four and back five.
Still a lack of quality there in quite a few positions. But should still have enough to make the second round.
Joe Hart, Livermore and Welbeck shouldn't be near the team.
At least there is no false hope of us winning the thing, or even making the QF's.
comment by 🎼Galv🎼 Third burglars ♿ rip Steve & Jim♿ (U10415)
posted 49 seconds ago
Has he named 4 keepers?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nah, he's named 3 and Joe Hart.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Sign in if you want to comment
England Squad Announced
Page 1 of 3
posted on 15/3/18
Welbeck, Ashley Young, Tripper, Rose, Joe Hart, Wilshere and Livermore shouldn't have been picked
Young and Wilshere deserve to be in it. The others though wtf
posted on 15/3/18
Phenom
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
posted on 15/3/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 15/3/18
No way Livermore or Welbeck should be anywhere near that squad... barely recognizable as Premier league quality never mind intl footy. The rest of it is OK all things considered
posted on 15/3/18
Young is getting on now but there isnt many LBs to choose from and he's one of the best in the league on current form
posted on 15/3/18
Who should be our back up RB if not Trippier? Don;t go suggesting Trent Alexander Arnold...
Rose also in a position where we don't have much strength in depth right now so makes sense.
Welbeck, Hart and Livermore should consider themselves very lucky though
posted on 15/3/18
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilshere is 26 yrs old!
posted on 15/3/18
I guess that's Cahill''s England career done.
posted on 15/3/18
Young is only being picked on current form, he was solid against LFC and plays regularly. granted he's in his 30s but if you're performing better than 7 other English wing backs you deserve to be in contention
posted on 15/3/18
Ditto Jones & Smalling
posted on 15/3/18
comment by AFCISMYTEAM (U14931)
posted 1 minute ago
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilshere is 26 yrs old!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hadn't mentioned age, Wilshere has had a lot of injuries and Spurs biased aside I liked him for England but we need to look forward.
posted on 15/3/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 15/3/18
best XI out of that lot on current form
Butland
Walker Stones Tarkowski Young
Dier ??
Sterling Dele Rashford
Vardy
posted on 15/3/18
Horrendous squad. Makes me as a Scotsman pleased Southgate is in charge because he's clearly not got a clue what's going on.
Anyone watching football this season can see that Joe Hart is finished.
Jake Livermore's stats this season are embarrassingly poor, I don't remember him doing anything positive.
How on earth is Welbeck in it
Mawson isnt very good either, Gomez needs more games before being considered. Cook pretty run of the mill, Young too old and doesnt overlap enough
Wilshere you can at least see the reasoning behind, he when at it is one of your best midfielders.
posted on 15/3/18
comment by THudd (U1029)
posted 18 seconds ago
comment by AFCISMYTEAM (U14931)
posted 1 minute ago
Wilshere and Young have been good players for England in the past, but I don't see them as the future
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wilshere is 26 yrs old!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hadn't mentioned age, Wilshere has had a lot of injuries and Spurs biased aside I liked him for England but we need to look forward.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The fact is we don't have many other English CM's like him, so he's got to be in the team.
Also, the last time we spoke about our young team for the future, we went out to Iceland.
posted on 15/3/18
comment by 🎼Galv🎼 Third burglars ♿ rip Steve &... (U10415)
posted 2 minutes ago
I think he misread the Young bit
----------------------------------------------------------------------
posted on 15/3/18
I don't rate Henderson or Wilshere for England, Lewis Cook isn't the answer neither is Livermore.
posted on 15/3/18
centre back and central midfield are real problems
posted on 15/3/18
In my opinion your best squad would be.
GK Pickford (1st Choice)
GK Butland
GK Pope
LB Rose
LB Bertrand
CB Stones
CB Maguire
CB Jones
CB Tarkowski
RB Walker
RB Trippier
CM Wilshere
CM Dier
CM Loftus-Cheek
CM Hughes
AM Alli
AM Lallana
LW Rashford
LW Lingard
RW Sterling
RW Ox
FW Kane
FW Vardy
posted on 15/3/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 15/3/18
Not Young’s greatest fan but a fair inclusion. Done well in numerous full back and wing back positions and has experience so could be a useful squad player for the world cup - especially with Southgate switchinh between a baxk four and back five.
Still a lack of quality there in quite a few positions. But should still have enough to make the second round.
posted on 15/3/18
Joe Hart, Livermore and Welbeck shouldn't be near the team.
At least there is no false hope of us winning the thing, or even making the QF's.
posted on 15/3/18
fack he did wtf
posted on 15/3/18
comment by 🎼Galv🎼 Third burglars ♿ rip Steve & Jim♿ (U10415)
posted 49 seconds ago
Has he named 4 keepers?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Nah, he's named 3 and Joe Hart.
posted on 15/3/18
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Page 1 of 3