or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 108 comments are related to an article called:

PNE V Forest Match Thead

Page 2 of 5

posted on 16/2/19

comment by Redfor50yrs (U2973)
posted 33 minutes ago
Agree with last two sentences of yours Will; but no manager should defend cheating.

I'd prefer the Wenger Way: "I didn't see the incident; I've not seen the replay yet". Still not being honest but he doesn't defend cheating. All teams cheat - the authorities need to clamp down on it but don't have the bottle. I suppose the genie's out of the bottle anyway and there is no way of getting it back in.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In fairness, if he hadn’t watched it back you couldn’t call it as a dive live. Gayle made the list of the situation and it looked fairly convincing on first viewing. It’s not until you see it slowed down that it was clearly an excellently executed swan dive!

posted on 16/2/19

comment by Will Scarlet (U17891)
posted less than a minute ago
comment by Redfor50yrs (U2973)
posted 33 minutes ago
Agree with last two sentences of yours Will; but no manager should defend cheating.

I'd prefer the Wenger Way: "I didn't see the incident; I've not seen the replay yet". Still not being honest but he doesn't defend cheating. All teams cheat - the authorities need to clamp down on it but don't have the bottle. I suppose the genie's out of the bottle anyway and there is no way of getting it back in.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
In fairness, if he hadn’t watched it back you couldn’t call it as a dive live. Gayle made the list of the situation and it looked fairly convincing on first viewing. It’s not until you see it slowed down that it was clearly an excellently executed swan dive!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Grabban was very fortunate to get a penalty against Brentford too IMO so we shouldn’t get too high and mighty.

posted on 16/2/19

I agree Grabban was a bit lucky.

But refs are at fault. The ref was in a good position to see the Gayle incident. He couldn't have seen contact so he shouldn't have given it. In the Grabban incident the ref should have had help from his lino. In both cases it was just a guess.

In both cases VAR might have resulted in the correct decision without taking anything away from the flow of game.

posted on 16/2/19

If Cash is still injured Carvalho should start. Lolley wide right.

posted on 16/2/19

Pantilimon

Darikwa, Milosevic, Benalouane, Robinson

Lolley, Yates, Colback, Osborn

Grabban, Murphy

Subs: Steele, Carvalho, Wague, Goncalves, Yacob, Pele, Bonatini

comment by reddave (U8660)

posted on 16/2/19

Would VAR have awarde us a penalty for the shirt pull on Lolley ? Tbh I doubt it purely because Lolley was ‘too honest’ and didn’t dive too the ground.

posted on 16/2/19

Pantilimon

Darikwa, Milosevic, Benalouane, Robinson

Lolley, Yates, Colback, Osborn

Grabban, Murphy

Subs: Steele, Carvalho, Wague, Goncalves, Yacob, Pele, Bonatini

Interesting. Looks ok on paper, but two up front didn't work last time.

Let's see.

comment by reddave (U8660)

posted on 16/2/19

We are in massive trouble, anyone who considers Darikwa to be a footballer shouldn’t be in management, he is a complete liability. I also get the impression MON doesn’t rate Carvalho.

posted on 16/2/19

Looks like route one approach then.

posted on 16/2/19

Grabban & Murphy haven't looked as if they can play together so far.

posted on 16/2/19

comment by Red Forest Bear ( Bear Knows) (U6288)
posted 2 minutes ago
Grabban & Murphy haven't looked as if they can play together so far.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
They’ve only had one go at it so a little early for jusge?

posted on 16/2/19

comment by reddave (U8660)
posted 11 minutes ago
We are in massive trouble, anyone who considers Darikwa to be a footballer shouldn’t be in management, he is a complete liability. I also get the impression MON doesn’t rate Carvalho.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
To be fair, Janko has looked very shakey the last couple of games.

posted on 16/2/19

Janko could be injured if he is not on the bench.

Not going to judge MON's team selection. I've learnt my lesson.

posted on 16/2/19

comment by Redfor50yrs (U2973)
posted 8 minutes ago
Janko could be injured if he is not on the bench.

Not going to judge MON's team selection. I've learnt my lesson.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
🤣

posted on 16/2/19

It’s this year’s big thing! Slate MoN at 2.15pm every match day!

posted on 16/2/19

Did it once, won't do it again.

posted on 16/2/19

comment by Will Scarlet (U17891)
posted 14 minutes ago
comment by Red Forest Bear ( Bear Knows) (U6288)
posted 2 minutes ago
Grabban & Murphy haven't looked as if they can play together so far.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
They’ve only had one go at it so a little early for jusge?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
A.K played them together once.

posted on 16/2/19

The good thing is the back line looks very solid whether it's Janko or Darikwa.

comment by reddave (U8660)

posted on 16/2/19

Not slating MON at all just do not rate Darikwa, shame he only got a 3 game ban.
Would like to see Carvalho given a chance though.

comment by reddave (U8660)

posted on 16/2/19

Not slating MON at all just do not rate Darikwa, shame he only got a 3 game ban.
Would like to see Carvalho given a chance though.

posted on 16/2/19

No bloody commentary yet, I wonder if they realise that they're talking to them selves atm?

posted on 16/2/19

Notts are playing the stags at home in an early KO. The match is live on RN

posted on 16/2/19

I think both Janko and Darikwa are inconsistent. We've done OK without Carvalho these last few weeks so I am not in such a hurry to see him return as I was initially.

MON is still assessing his squad and is yet to find his best formation and starting eleven. We need to cut him some slack and be patient. That includes the owner.

posted on 16/2/19

comment by El Bosque [Basoa in Euskara] (U1617)
posted less than a minute ago
Notts are playing the stags at home in an early KO. The match is live on RN
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately I can't pick up R.N on F.M just about 6 miles from the Bath/N.E Somerset border!

IFollow leaves a lot to be desired.

posted on 16/2/19

In fact I can't even get Radio Glos either.

Page 2 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment