Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
Im kind of leaning towards Rvp Eventhough Sanchez was unreal for us
Arsenal are like the reverse of us, where we've alwasy (usually) had top cbs, arsenal have always had great strikers.
RVP, could do it all.
Aubameyang is an out and out goal scorer but not as silky or as special a talent.
Sanchez it's hard to look at him now and think he was a very good player at one point as he's probably not played a good game since he left you.
RvP
For me it's not even close.
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
RVP for me. He had everthing which included long list of injuries.
Auba is close and is scoring even when playing out of position. No offence to Arsenal but he is wasted over there hence why he will look to leave.
RvP's main (only) problem at Arsenal was his fitness.
'Prime RvP' presumably means 'fit RvP'.
That being the case, he wouldn't have been a 'one-season wonder' (which I dispute, anyway) and therefore a better option than either Alexis or Auba.
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
Rvp in his final season pretty much got top 4 single handedly. If Arsenal get CL this season, it’ll be because of Aubameyang and the arrival of Arteta to make his contribution count.
With Alexis we won the most. However has to be RvP. A generational player
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 3 minutes ago
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
obviously fitness plays a part.
If RVP was fit more this wouldn't be a question.
2009/10 14 starts 9 goals 7 assists
10/11 - 19 starts 18 goals 7 assists
11/12 - 27 starts 30 goals 10 assists
Outrageous stats.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alright Stevie Wonder.
Ironically I think it J99 who’s judgement is clouded. In terms of goal scoring it’s flip of a coin. But in terms of overall play there isn’t a debate to be had.
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 6 minutes ago
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sanchez and Rvp had far more to their game then Auba.
comment by 50... (U1147)
posted 51 seconds ago
Ironically I think it J99 who’s judgement is clouded. In terms of goal scoring it’s flip of a coin. But in terms of overall play there isn’t a debate to be had.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah, can only judge a player on when he plays, and rvp averaged over a goal contribution a game in his last 3 years at arsenal. Whoscored dindn't go back further.
And not forgetting he won utd a premier league
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 54 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats cause RVP played in very good teams. May not have been winning trophies but perennial top 4, Champions League. Look at who was feeding him. Cesc, Nasri, Rosicky, Arshavin and even a young promising Walcott.
Its always questionable to compare players in a team game.
RVP
2004/5 - 26 apps, 5 goals, With Pires/Freddie/Vieira
5/6 - 24 apps, 4 goals
6/7 - 22 apps, 11 goals
7/8 - 15 apps, 7 goals,
8/9 - 28 apps, 11 goals
9/10 - 16 apps, 9 goals
10/11 - 25 apps, 18 goals
11/12 - 38 apps, 30 goals.
Except for his final two years RVP would be considered a flop.
comment by Castor Troy (U8700)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 6 minutes ago
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sanchez and Rvp had far more to their game then Auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ask yourself what you want in a striker.
He has one job. Score goals. It doesn't matter how many dribbles, fancy flicks or spectacular volleys he scores. Points count.
Our best two strikers by far have been Henry and then WWW.
Jenius99 seems to have missed the part where the OP said prime lol
comment by Michael Edwards FC {Proud owner of the 5 000 000th comment} Super European Champions of the World (U2720)
posted 31 seconds ago
Jenius99 seems to have missed the part where the OP said prime lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't want to print Aubemeyang's record at Dortmund. So kept it to their Arsenal careers.
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 54 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats cause RVP played in very good teams. May not have been winning trophies but perennial top 4, Champions League. Look at who was feeding him. Cesc, Nasri, Rosicky, Arshavin and even a young promising Walcott.
Its always questionable to compare players in a team game.
RVP
2004/5 - 26 apps, 5 goals, With Pires/Freddie/Vieira
5/6 - 24 apps, 4 goals
6/7 - 22 apps, 11 goals
7/8 - 15 apps, 7 goals,
8/9 - 28 apps, 11 goals
9/10 - 16 apps, 9 goals
10/11 - 25 apps, 18 goals
11/12 - 38 apps, 30 goals.
Except for his final two years RVP would be considered a flop.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many were starts? how many were fit. He'd never be considered a flop with those stats.
You dont seem have included assists either.
And you mention cesc etc but by the time van persie left arsenal had regressed massively, and his best stats were before he left...so throws that theory out the window.
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 39 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 54 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats cause RVP played in very good teams. May not have been winning trophies but perennial top 4, Champions League. Look at who was feeding him. Cesc, Nasri, Rosicky, Arshavin and even a young promising Walcott.
Its always questionable to compare players in a team game.
RVP
2004/5 - 26 apps, 5 goals, With Pires/Freddie/Vieira
5/6 - 24 apps, 4 goals
6/7 - 22 apps, 11 goals
7/8 - 15 apps, 7 goals,
8/9 - 28 apps, 11 goals
9/10 - 16 apps, 9 goals
10/11 - 25 apps, 18 goals
11/12 - 38 apps, 30 goals.
Except for his final two years RVP would be considered a flop.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many were starts? how many were fit. He'd never be considered a flop with those stats.
You dont seem have included assists either.
And you mention cesc etc but by the time van persie left arsenal had regressed massively, and his best stats were before he left...so throws that theory out the window.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
A young Wilshere, Arshavin, Rosicky, Ramsey, Santi and assists king Walcott were pretty good.
Still qualifying for the Champions League, season after season. We did that even Giroud. Didn't see his name above?
Sign in if you want to comment
Prime Rvp, Sanchez or Auba?
Page 1 of 3
posted on 24/2/20
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
posted on 24/2/20
RVP
posted on 24/2/20
Im kind of leaning towards Rvp Eventhough Sanchez was unreal for us
posted on 24/2/20
Arsenal are like the reverse of us, where we've alwasy (usually) had top cbs, arsenal have always had great strikers.
posted on 24/2/20
RVP, could do it all.
Aubameyang is an out and out goal scorer but not as silky or as special a talent.
Sanchez it's hard to look at him now and think he was a very good player at one point as he's probably not played a good game since he left you.
posted on 24/2/20
RvP
For me it's not even close.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
posted on 24/2/20
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
posted on 24/2/20
RVP for me. He had everthing which included long list of injuries.
Auba is close and is scoring even when playing out of position. No offence to Arsenal but he is wasted over there hence why he will look to leave.
posted on 24/2/20
RvP's main (only) problem at Arsenal was his fitness.
'Prime RvP' presumably means 'fit RvP'.
That being the case, he wouldn't have been a 'one-season wonder' (which I dispute, anyway) and therefore a better option than either Alexis or Auba.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
posted on 24/2/20
Rvp in his final season pretty much got top 4 single handedly. If Arsenal get CL this season, it’ll be because of Aubameyang and the arrival of Arteta to make his contribution count.
With Alexis we won the most. However has to be RvP. A generational player
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 3 minutes ago
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
obviously fitness plays a part.
If RVP was fit more this wouldn't be a question.
2009/10 14 starts 9 goals 7 assists
10/11 - 19 starts 18 goals 7 assists
11/12 - 27 starts 30 goals 10 assists
Outrageous stats.
posted on 24/2/20
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Alright Stevie Wonder.
posted on 24/2/20
Ironically I think it J99 who’s judgement is clouded. In terms of goal scoring it’s flip of a coin. But in terms of overall play there isn’t a debate to be had.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 6 minutes ago
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sanchez and Rvp had far more to their game then Auba.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by 50... (U1147)
posted 51 seconds ago
Ironically I think it J99 who’s judgement is clouded. In terms of goal scoring it’s flip of a coin. But in terms of overall play there isn’t a debate to be had.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah, can only judge a player on when he plays, and rvp averaged over a goal contribution a game in his last 3 years at arsenal. Whoscored dindn't go back further.
And not forgetting he won utd a premier league
posted on 24/2/20
RVP.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 54 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats cause RVP played in very good teams. May not have been winning trophies but perennial top 4, Champions League. Look at who was feeding him. Cesc, Nasri, Rosicky, Arshavin and even a young promising Walcott.
Its always questionable to compare players in a team game.
RVP
2004/5 - 26 apps, 5 goals, With Pires/Freddie/Vieira
5/6 - 24 apps, 4 goals
6/7 - 22 apps, 11 goals
7/8 - 15 apps, 7 goals,
8/9 - 28 apps, 11 goals
9/10 - 16 apps, 9 goals
10/11 - 25 apps, 18 goals
11/12 - 38 apps, 30 goals.
Except for his final two years RVP would be considered a flop.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Castor Troy (U8700)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 6 minutes ago
Though Alexis and RVP both also won the golden boot like Auba, they were, literally one season wonders for us. Alexis only had one other season of 15+ goals and RVP best season for us apart from his golden boot season was 18 goals and that in a far more successful and creative team.
Auba has already scored 17 goals for us this season following his golden boot last season and in a team that is underperforming.
There really isn't a debate on who is the better player between those 3.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sanchez and Rvp had far more to their game then Auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ask yourself what you want in a striker.
He has one job. Score goals. It doesn't matter how many dribbles, fancy flicks or spectacular volleys he scores. Points count.
Our best two strikers by far have been Henry and then WWW.
posted on 24/2/20
Jenius99 seems to have missed the part where the OP said prime lol
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Michael Edwards FC {Proud owner of the 5 000 000th comment} Super European Champions of the World (U2720)
posted 31 seconds ago
Jenius99 seems to have missed the part where the OP said prime lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didn't want to print Aubemeyang's record at Dortmund. So kept it to their Arsenal careers.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 54 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats cause RVP played in very good teams. May not have been winning trophies but perennial top 4, Champions League. Look at who was feeding him. Cesc, Nasri, Rosicky, Arshavin and even a young promising Walcott.
Its always questionable to compare players in a team game.
RVP
2004/5 - 26 apps, 5 goals, With Pires/Freddie/Vieira
5/6 - 24 apps, 4 goals
6/7 - 22 apps, 11 goals
7/8 - 15 apps, 7 goals,
8/9 - 28 apps, 11 goals
9/10 - 16 apps, 9 goals
10/11 - 25 apps, 18 goals
11/12 - 38 apps, 30 goals.
Except for his final two years RVP would be considered a flop.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many were starts? how many were fit. He'd never be considered a flop with those stats.
You dont seem have included assists either.
And you mention cesc etc but by the time van persie left arsenal had regressed massively, and his best stats were before he left...so throws that theory out the window.
posted on 24/2/20
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 39 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 54 seconds ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Jenius99 (U4918)
posted 9 minutes ago
Aubameyang. Is there even a debate?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
apparently, gauging the replies lol
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Romantic hindsight and emotional response always trumps commons sense.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
not by looking at your comments. Just judging them on goals.
I know who i'd rather face if given the chance as a chelsea fan and thats auba.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thats cause RVP played in very good teams. May not have been winning trophies but perennial top 4, Champions League. Look at who was feeding him. Cesc, Nasri, Rosicky, Arshavin and even a young promising Walcott.
Its always questionable to compare players in a team game.
RVP
2004/5 - 26 apps, 5 goals, With Pires/Freddie/Vieira
5/6 - 24 apps, 4 goals
6/7 - 22 apps, 11 goals
7/8 - 15 apps, 7 goals,
8/9 - 28 apps, 11 goals
9/10 - 16 apps, 9 goals
10/11 - 25 apps, 18 goals
11/12 - 38 apps, 30 goals.
Except for his final two years RVP would be considered a flop.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How many were starts? how many were fit. He'd never be considered a flop with those stats.
You dont seem have included assists either.
And you mention cesc etc but by the time van persie left arsenal had regressed massively, and his best stats were before he left...so throws that theory out the window.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
A young Wilshere, Arshavin, Rosicky, Ramsey, Santi and assists king Walcott were pretty good.
Still qualifying for the Champions League, season after season. We did that even Giroud. Didn't see his name above?
Page 1 of 3