Buffon and Casillas have got to be up near the top !
Sorry ,not paying attention !
Solid list but Reina and Lehmann should be on there instead of Cudicini and Given.
I’d have Alisson over Ederson as well. I haven’t seen Ederson make many good saves tbh.
De Gea should be about 2 or 3 places below Seaman.
Joe Hart seems a bit of an outlier. But maybe I’m biased cos his career’s gone so far off the pan
comment by Kunta Kante (U1641)
posted 4 minutes ago
Joe Hart seems a bit of an outlier. But maybe I’m biased cos his career’s gone so far off the pan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Peaked in 2014 and it all went downhill from there, he’s actually still quite young for a keeper too.
Nah Hart was good in his prime.
Really good.
I remember a CL game City played against Barca when he was basically Spiderman in goal. There was another masterclass as well, maybe vs Dortmund but I can’t recall.
comment by #LiquidGenius (U20571)
posted 16 minutes ago
I’d have Alisson over Ederson as well. I haven’t seen Ederson make many good saves tbh.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is a Wahl list of best ever. There is no way in hell he is going to put any Liverpool players in his list.
Alisson has won more individual awards in the last 2 seasons than some on that list have won in their entire careers yet doesn't even get into the top 10.
Not in Wahl's list
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alisson#Honours
In Wahl's list https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ederson_(footballer,_born_1993)#Honours
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Cudicini#Honours
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shay_Given#Honours
Wahl is a pathetic cretin and always finds a way to leave any Liverpool player off his lists. How sad must you be to try and wind people up, so transparent. Jealousy will get you nowhere.
Alisson hasn't even been in the pl for two years...
That's just one season less than the inferior Ederson.
Well, one CL and in the near future one PL too.
CL is irrelevant, PL goalkeepers.
Hasn't Adrian been in goal most of this season as well anyway?
11 PL appearance for Adrian
so over 1/3 of the season
If Allison gets in the top 10 goalkeepers for the PL then Michu gets in the top 10 strikers.
comment by Wahl Icht - (U22332)
posted 6 minutes ago
11 PL appearance for Adrian
so over 1/3 of the season
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So not "most" then? You have just contradicted your own claim.
20 ~ half a full season.
So Alisson in total has only played 1 1/2 pl seasons. How can he then be on a list of top 10 greatest PL goalkeepers?
Sign in if you want to comment
Top 10 Greatest PL goalkeepers
Page 1 of 2
posted on 1/5/20
Buffon and Casillas have got to be up near the top !
posted on 1/5/20
Sorry ,not paying attention !
posted on 1/5/20
Solid list but Reina and Lehmann should be on there instead of Cudicini and Given.
posted on 1/5/20
I’d have Alisson over Ederson as well. I haven’t seen Ederson make many good saves tbh.
posted on 1/5/20
De Gea should be about 2 or 3 places below Seaman.
posted on 1/5/20
Joe Hart seems a bit of an outlier. But maybe I’m biased cos his career’s gone so far off the pan
posted on 1/5/20
comment by Kunta Kante (U1641)
posted 4 minutes ago
Joe Hart seems a bit of an outlier. But maybe I’m biased cos his career’s gone so far off the pan
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Peaked in 2014 and it all went downhill from there, he’s actually still quite young for a keeper too.
posted on 1/5/20
Nah Hart was good in his prime.
Really good.
I remember a CL game City played against Barca when he was basically Spiderman in goal. There was another masterclass as well, maybe vs Dortmund but I can’t recall.
posted on 1/5/20
Plus he’s got 2 Chips.
posted on 1/5/20
posted on 1/5/20
comment by #LiquidGenius (U20571)
posted 16 minutes ago
I’d have Alisson over Ederson as well. I haven’t seen Ederson make many good saves tbh.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is a Wahl list of best ever. There is no way in hell he is going to put any Liverpool players in his list.
Alisson has won more individual awards in the last 2 seasons than some on that list have won in their entire careers yet doesn't even get into the top 10.
posted on 1/5/20
Not in Wahl's list
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alisson#Honours
In Wahl's list https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ederson_(footballer,_born_1993)#Honours
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Cudicini#Honours
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shay_Given#Honours
posted on 1/5/20
Wahl is a pathetic cretin and always finds a way to leave any Liverpool player off his lists. How sad must you be to try and wind people up, so transparent. Jealousy will get you nowhere.
posted on 1/5/20
Alisson hasn't even been in the pl for two years...
posted on 1/5/20
That's just one season less than the inferior Ederson.
posted on 1/5/20
And two titles less too.
posted on 1/5/20
Well, one CL and in the near future one PL too.
posted on 1/5/20
CL is irrelevant, PL goalkeepers.
posted on 1/5/20
Hasn't Adrian been in goal most of this season as well anyway?
posted on 1/5/20
No
posted on 1/5/20
11 PL appearance for Adrian
so over 1/3 of the season
posted on 1/5/20
And 20 for Alisson.
posted on 1/5/20
If Allison gets in the top 10 goalkeepers for the PL then Michu gets in the top 10 strikers.
posted on 1/5/20
comment by Wahl Icht - (U22332)
posted 6 minutes ago
11 PL appearance for Adrian
so over 1/3 of the season
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So not "most" then? You have just contradicted your own claim.
posted on 1/5/20
20 ~ half a full season.
So Alisson in total has only played 1 1/2 pl seasons. How can he then be on a list of top 10 greatest PL goalkeepers?
Page 1 of 2