or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 430214 comments are related to an article called:

Fan's Barclays Premiership Season 16

Page 1527 of 17209

posted on 22/1/12

Just done mine

posted on 22/1/12

Dissapointed with the report saying I lost because I had a player sent off, don't see how it can be fair to give someone a sending off. Would rather it just said Chelsea were better.

posted on 22/1/12

because sending offs are part of the game

if you dont think sendings off are fair then please go to fifa and question the rules

posted on 22/1/12

Everyone agreed to yellow and reds there are 2 reds a week game drawn randomly and then team drawn randomly, plenty of teams have been effected by it

Had it gone the other way you'd have probably got the point but with you going down to 10 it gave them more space so that was the reason because you got your tactics spot on/Chelsea game plan didn allow them to use much width

posted on 22/1/12

ive added the motms for spurs vs norwich. forgot to do it

posted on 22/1/12

i got a sending off vs chelsea too mate

posted on 22/1/12

I got one vs hull too soon enough you will benefit from them

posted on 22/1/12

lstd you could meet him half way by doing the draw like

0-2 cards in a weekend. you do a draw on how many red cards there will be in that weekend of games and then if the generator lands on 1 or 2 then you do a draw on which game it is

posted on 22/1/12

Have had sendings off for and against..it happens may work to yopur adv next time

posted on 22/1/12

No 2 each week in the league keep it with a fair chance of effecting everyone

posted on 22/1/12

comment by iV wIL5H3RE iV (U9880) posted 7 minutes ago

because sending offs are part of the game

if you dont think sendings off are fair then please go to fifa and question the rules

--------------------------------------------------



Just don't like the idea myself since it's random, and can't be controlled for. Would rather it was simply just down to whose side and tactics are better myself.

posted on 22/1/12

Danilo-Rami-Ruiz-Kolarov
---March-Vidal-Milner---

posted on 22/1/12

Am thinkin and

Willian-Bent-Neymar

posted on 22/1/12

Against city, meant to hit preview instead of send lol damn phone

posted on 22/1/12

well maybe lstd takes the tactics into account

for example if in hull vs wolves - the wolves tactics were very physical while in chelsea vs united the tactics wernt as bad then lstd may make it more likely for a sending off to occur in the hull vs wolves game

posted on 22/1/12

But that can't be true if it is randomly drawn.

Just annoying, although I got my tactics spot on and still to lose. May as well have not bothered.

posted on 22/1/12

i think the red cards are good. they happen in real life and they can spoil a managers tactics irl. tbh to get around this problem when writing your tactics write section about dealing with a sending off

posted on 22/1/12

But this is a game.

Not too surprised it happened to me against one of the top clubs either.

posted on 22/1/12

Och red cards happen, how else id lstd gonna make it work? It works fine and am sure everyone will get one...maybe 1-5 and give more than 2 per week sometimes?

posted on 22/1/12

its happened to all of us though at some point. lstd doesnt try and single you out lol

i really cant see your problem. just work around the red card in your next set of tactics

posted on 22/1/12

i really cant see your problem

-------------------------------------------

Got my tactics spot on, yet lost because of a random card. Makes the whole point of doing tactics and playing the game pointless in my opinion.

I'm just stating that I disagree with it thats all.

posted on 22/1/12

but some managers may get their tactics spot on irl but the tactics get ruined by red cards. this league is meant to be realistic and the red card thing only supports that.

League Table
LSTD 123(8)
TJ 123 (9)
Fan 118(9)
JET 118 (10)
Wigan 116 (8)
Wilshere 115(9)

posted on 22/1/12

It doesn't really make tactics pointless there's a 1/20 chance of it effecting you, at some stage it's going to go your way and you will get points you didn't expect to get

posted on 22/1/12

just put in yr tactics something like this

if in the case of a red card i want my team to go 4-4-1. This player will come on for this player to strengthen the defence of this team. blah blah yeah

posted on 22/1/12

The league is meant to be realistic, but the league is a game, wouldn't play if it was decided by a random generator.

Would have even prefered knowing I was going to have a player sent off before hand so I could have done tactics.

Page 1527 of 17209

Sign in if you want to comment