or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 430199 comments are related to an article called:

Fan's Barclays Premiership Season 16

Page 4148 of 17208

comment by Robin (U3899)

posted on 3/12/12

Menez would be a starter for you LRF

posted on 3/12/12

You tell me then Loyal, what has Menez done that has been so good this season? Dzagoev better, Pastore better AM...

'only way' wasn't the best way of sayng what I was meant to say. Maybe the injury has now 'helped' him out to pretty much garantee a first team place. Wasn't all garanteed in the past as I'm sure they liked to rotate their defence?

posted on 3/12/12

No he wouldn't Robin

Dzagoev and Pastore > Menez

posted on 3/12/12

Pastors hasn't been that great so far this season IMO I'm not sure what everyone else thinks... LRF there's no point talking to you as your players are always the better players...

comment by Robin (U3899)

posted on 3/12/12

Fair enough Renegade

--
but Lamela will be the best

You can't justify that. Ridiculous comment.

And apart from the two 0-0 you conceded in each of the nine games before that Barely conceded

posted on 3/12/12

-----------------------Mandanda-----------------------
---Juanfran---Collocini---Dominguez---Criscito---
-------------------Essien------Sahin-------------------
---Dzagoev----------Pastore------------Gaitan-------
-----------------------Llorente-------------------------


----------

LRF this side is better than my side. I mean that.

We can now stop the wilshere wolves vs lrfs wolves discussions

And theres no point having a lrf vs wilshere discussion cause we all know im better

posted on 3/12/12

were barely doing any worse than other defences, 3rd best in the pl is hardly bad lol

trust me he will, he has huge potential

posted on 3/12/12

Loyal you say that about Pastore, but then Lavezzi has been just as bad and you wouldn't negotiate with me for him

posted on 3/12/12

imo if you had to separate the teams into small sections it would be

Arsenal
Chelsea
Birmingham
------------------
City
Liverpool
United
Villa
--------------
Hull
Newcastle
Wolves
Pompey
-------------
Wba
Qpr
------------
Sunderland
Reading
Everton
--------
Norwich
Spurs
Wigan
Southampton

posted on 3/12/12

Renegade I'd need a replacement and I can't see one in your squad really by all means make offers...

posted on 3/12/12

But how do you think he will start though? Dzagoev's ratngs have shot up since the Euro's where he was class for Russia and stood outin the tournament and Pastor hasn't been great no but he still has a handful of goals and assists to his name. Lets compare.

Pastore - 17 apps, 2 goals, 6 assists coming on 4 times, comig off 5 times

Menez - 24 apps, 4 goals and 5 assists coming on 4 times, coming off 15 times

Who would you say is better Loyal?

7 more games and coming off 15 times? Yes, with the players they are both with they are going to get plenty of goals and assists but if you add up and goals and assists:

Menez = 9 in total
Pastore = 8 in total

In 7 less games? Not too bad. And he is gettng better and back to form? Not too shaby atually this season from Pastore and Menez done nothing special, partly because he has come off so many times.

comment by Robin (U3899)

posted on 3/12/12

Wilshere You rate Villa and Hull higher than me eh...

posted on 3/12/12

But my squad is better than your squad so that's silly

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 3/12/12

you lot must have these debates every couple of days

comment by Robin (U3899)

posted on 3/12/12

Kanga this thread > the pro clubs thread.

posted on 3/12/12

Kanga, Almost evey day never mind a couple of days. Bet your glad your not on often eh.

Loyal, Renegade's squad better than yours and he might not be able to offer someone better than Lavezzi but he can improve you in numerous places without a doubt.

Ayway, I;m off now guys, see ya tommorow.

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 3/12/12

I've had to hold back on my comments a bit cos of my ban, this definitely wouldnt be allowed on pro clubs thread atm. too many complaints would come from it.

posted on 3/12/12

LRF tbh your boring me now... But saying Menez is average is just stupid

comment by Robin (U3899)

posted on 3/12/12

what wouldn't have been allowed?

a debate

What awful thread it is

posted on 3/12/12

Why would a debate about the quality of players not be allowed?

posted on 3/12/12

I didn't say his squad wasn't better than mine I just said I cant see a replacement and as I have no back up for lavezzi I'd be stupid to sell him read it properly LRF...

posted on 3/12/12

Debating on a football forum, about players/teams being better than other players/team

That's just about the majority of threads on this site!

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 3/12/12

thats what it feels like to me, Robin. whether thats really the case i dont know.

posted on 3/12/12

Not just me who has said it, LSTD has aid it. You ell me, you tell me Loyal, what has Menez done that makes him not deserve to go by the word 'average' this season? What has he done to have caught your eye eh? Nothing. Coming off 15 times in 24 games as well?

comment by Robin (U3899)

posted on 3/12/12

So you debate, and then somebody puts a complain in

Page 4148 of 17208

Sign in if you want to comment