or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 430289 comments are related to an article called:

Fan's Barclays Premiership Season 16

Page 950 of 17212

posted on 5/11/11

thanks mate

posted on 5/11/11



I do agree though I put top 5 in the position but sometimes I'd widen that number maybe for CF and CMs

But personally top 5 in each position ATM

GK: Cassilas, Cech, Reina, Valdes and Neuer
RB: Alves, Maicon - no a lot of people will say he isn't now but he's still got it IMO, Ramos, Sagna, Not sure on 5th. Maybe Ivanovic
LB: Cole, Evra, Marcelo, Taiwo, Abidal
CB: Piqué, Vidic, Puyol, Thiago Silva, Kompany
CM: Xavi, Xabi Alonso, Yaya, Busquets, Schweinsteiger/Modric
AM: Iniesta, Silva, Kaka, Ozil, Fabregas
WF/SS: Messi, Ronaldo, Rooney, Aguero, Robben/Mata I'd have Nani if he played more
CF: Van Persie, Villa, Higuain, Ibrahimovic, Falcao

That's on form anyway, On actual ability a few could be in there like Torres Drogba and Essien from Chelsea. Abidal and Carvalho too

posted on 5/11/11

luka, please stay

posted on 5/11/11

Actually Gomez should probably be in that list over Ibra

My opinion of the last year or so anyway a list of best players not in great form could be quite a good side lol

Buffon
RB not sure Lucio Ferdinand Maxwell
Gerrard Essien Cambiasso Malouda
Torres Drogba

Pretty good side lol

posted on 5/11/11

Lisandro value lstd?

posted on 5/11/11

I don't think you can be called world class based on form. Wouldn't say 5 for every position either but roughly its a good gauge I think

GKs: Buffon, Casillas, Cesar, Neuer, Reina
RB: Alves, Lahm, Maicon, Ramos
CB: Pique, Vidic, Thiago Silva, Lucio, Pepe,
LB: Cole, Evra, Marcelo
CM: Xavi, Essien, Yaya, Schweinsteiger
AM: Iniesta, Silva, Fabregas, Ozil, Sneijder, Kaka
WF: Messi, Ronaldo, Robben, Ribery
CF: Villa, Van Persie, Aguero, Forlan, Rooney, Eto'o

posted on 5/11/11

I could probably add players to that as well if I thought about it

Maxwell? Is that a joke

posted on 5/11/11

Maxwell is a decent player when on form that was an out of form team lol

Cech defenitly has to be in the WC keeper list he's been amazing for Chelsea, apart from the Arsenal game our best two player for the past season nearly 2 and before the bad year he had with his injury he was arguably top 2 keepers in the world. Buffon hardly played for 2-3 seasons too very injury prone now

If its not on form I'd definitely have Drogba over Forlan and Torres in there too at his best he's amazing.

Not sure about Ribery either don't think he's ever been world class tbh bit over rated imo

15m fan

posted on 5/11/11

I don't rate Maxwell at all, never have.

Buffon has only really been injured for a long time last season He's one of the best keepers of all time for me.

Forlan at his best is obviously better than Torres or Drogba have ever been. His achievments back that up. Forlan has won European Golden boot, twice. Not to mention been the best player at a World Cup.

Ribery maybe not, but I think as far as wingers he's one of the closest to Robben.

posted on 5/11/11

Oh my god Man Utd v Sunderland on before Man City QPR game! It was worse than Chelsea game never mind the city game

So biased towards man Utd. I get it's SAFs 25 year anniversary but it's a highlights show I'd rather see a longer entertaining game than a long dull game SAF talking to fans

posted on 5/11/11

Forlan WC yes but Drogba and Torres are or have been too they've done a lot for their clubs and countries. Drogba top scorer in one of the If not the best league defensively in world football imo, 3 PL titles and other domestics. Never really had much chance to win World cups with Ivory Coast lol. African footballer of the year 3 years or 4 years too.

posted on 5/11/11

is luka leaving...

posted on 5/11/11

Ivory Coast vs Uraguay

Not a big difference really if you think about it.

League titles? Your comparing forwards.

Forlan has been top scorer in Europe twice, for teams not as good as Chelsea.

Your view is obviously a biased one, Forlan's achievments are greater than either Torres or Drogbas.

Diouf has won African footballer of the year twice. If Forlan was African he'd have won it 5 times +

posted on 5/11/11

LSTD- i aid this last week and you said i was wrong...

posted on 5/11/11

Drogba has still been a WC. The way your saying it forlans achievements are better than Van Persie, Villa and Eto'o but they are all in there....

posted on 5/11/11

Luka has left for now yes.

What did i say was wrong Wigan?

posted on 5/11/11

I'm arguing with you saying you'd put Drogba and Torres over Forlan.

I'd have Forlan over van Persie as well myself.

posted on 5/11/11

I said Drogba over Forlan but that's cause I love him lol, I do think others would put him over him too but Drogba is definitely WC imo. Torres I said has been WC but didnt say over Forlan for him

posted on 5/11/11

that motd is biast to man u and liverpool

posted on 5/11/11

I didn't argue against that I agree 100% they are. I said last season they were first rightly

posted on 5/11/11

Ye not arguing Drogba isn't WC course he is. List was off my head, forgot guys like Alonso too

posted on 5/11/11

Adam maher
Oscar Dos Santos
Bas Dost

can go on loan to anyone if they want

posted on 5/11/11

Oh right I thought you were sorry

posted on 5/11/11

who is of less value to me

Adam Maher or Bas Dost?

posted on 5/11/11

Dost for me

Page 950 of 17212

Sign in if you want to comment