or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 43 comments are related to an article called:

Ballon d’Or shortlist

Page 1 of 2

posted on 15/11/21

Jorginho seems the likely choice ... CL and Euro winner

posted on 15/11/21

Never paid attention to these things so do they vote for the season or the calendar year?

For last season Suarez should be close. Messi for the copa. Lewandowski for scoring shat loads again and being robbed before. Maybe an Italian for the euros

posted on 15/11/21

comment by Cinciwolf---VOTE CINCI! Bunch of cants. (U11551)
posted 6 minutes ago
Never paid attention to these things so do they vote for the season or the calendar year?

For last season Suarez should be close. Messi for the copa. Lewandowski for scoring shat loads again and being robbed before. Maybe an Italian for the euros
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It’s based on last season, rather than the calendar year

posted on 15/11/21

If based on success then Jorginho
If based on individual talent then Messi

posted on 15/11/21

It probably should be one of Lewandowski or Jorginho who have had outstanding years but it will end up being Messi I think. Haaland might be a close 4th.

posted on 15/11/21

This is a popularity contest.

Messi won copa america. he scored 30 goals in la liga and 38 overall.

Thats pretty much a slam dunk.

Jorginho won the euros and the CL. he is a defensive midfielder who takes pens, harly the best thing for a popularity contest.

Lewandowski won the german league and got 48 goals last year, 41 in league but was already awarded FIFA poty.

The simple question should be who has most insta followers.

messi 281mil
lewandowski 22mil
jorginho 2.9mil

clearly in a popularity contest theres only going to be one winner.

posted on 15/11/21

Let's not be subjective about this. I've looked up the very rigorous criteria for the award. It reads as follows:

1. The Ballon d'Or shall be awarded to the individual who is most famous for being the world's best footballer.
2. In the event that two individuals are widely regarded as the world's best footballer, the one who's team won most will be selected.
3. In a World Cup year the most famous individual for being a very good footballer in the team winning the World Cup may be considered as an alternative.
4. If the individual(s) most famous for being the world's best footballer has had a stinker of a season, the award should go to the the most famous individual for being a very good footballer in the team which won the most high profile competition. Alternatively, it can be awarded to an individual who is not the most famous very good footballer in his team if he wins both the CL and a continental national championship. Unless it happens to someone like Alvaro Arbeloa. Then everyone would just laugh at us.

Glad to have clarified.

posted on 15/11/21

Probably should be Messi tbh, brilliant individual season and national success.

posted on 15/11/21

Lewandowski or Messi, both had statistically phenomenal seasons last season. Lewa's form has continued into this season but Messi finally helped take Argentina to the Copa in the summer which adds to his chances...

I'd call them pretty even but give it to Lewandowski as he deserved it last year in a more clear cut situation. (Obviously that's not how it's actually go down)

posted on 15/11/21

Apparently it's been leaked already and messi has won

posted on 15/11/21

"Harry Kane (Tottenham)"

comedy gold!

posted on 15/11/21

Messi's last one I reckon.

posted on 15/11/21

Lewandowski for me. Partly because he was robbed the season before.

posted on 15/11/21

I didn’t watch any of the Copa America, was it really all Messi as has been portrayed? In terms of club football Lewa has been the best last season.

posted on 15/11/21

Lewa was good but thought he was rubbish when they went out of the CL to PSG. Pretty much invisible.

posted on 15/11/21

comment by Robbb Marsh (U22716)
posted 11 minutes ago
Lewa was good but thought he was rubbish when they went out of the CL to PSG. Pretty much invisible.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I hope that’s a p*ss take?

posted on 15/11/21

comment by Ji Sung Park's Cousin - It's Beekers! (U2958)
posted 2 hours, 31 minutes ago
Jorginho seems the likely choice ... CL and Euro winner
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Shouldn’t get you a Ballon D’or though.

posted on 15/11/21

Still not convinced with Jorginho, Italy were a penalty away from losing the Euro final and I can’t imagine anyone would have been praising Phillips had England won it in the same way. Not saying he’s bad, just nowhere near deserving of the ballon d’or.

posted on 15/11/21

Jorginho may not have been the best individual player this year, but that's not what this award is about. It is a team sport and there are no awards for individual performance. So has to be Jorginho for me.

posted on 15/11/21

Lewandowski if there's any justice.

3 cheers for Lewandowski!

posted on 15/11/21

Should be based on individual players form and brilliance over the year, who has been the best player that year. Not who was fortunate enough to play for the best 2 teams/teams that won the trophies. I don't think it's a stretch to say Chelsea and Italy would've gone far in those comps without Jorginho tbf, even if he did have a great year I don't think he was the best player in the world at any moment let alone across the whole year.

posted on 15/11/21

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 15/11/21

what has he facking done this year?
=================

Scored 29 goals, won the Copa and got player of the tournament.

You really shouldn't talk about football.

posted on 15/11/21

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 15/11/21

comment by Titliv - Ben Shapiro fanboy, and what about those milkers (U11882)
posted 6 minutes ago
Wow so he finally won the tournament with 4 good teams and a bunch of farmers at the 6th attempt. 29 goals? Kevin Phillips used to do that all the time and that was without the entire team told to pass to him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You like Ben Shapiro so instantly your judgement on all things is skewed.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment