I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
I have not had the time to do an article on the tour so far due to me watching the open and wasting the rest of it trying to educate Nohlman and Scholay.
Iqbal especially has caught the eye. No idea why Hannibal hasn’t featured, I assume he is injured as well.
I have not been impressed with what I have seen with Laird. He reminds me too much of Ashley Young with continual backward passes when players are open upfield.
"I have not been impressed with what I have seen with Laird. He reminds me too much of Ashley Young with continual backward passes when players are open upfield."
Yeah I kind of felt that too. I'd heard he's a good athlete who gets up and down the pitch. But if all he does when he's up the pitch is turn back and play a safe pass, his ability to get there becomes redundant. Having said that, it was literally what, half an hour? And it was in a game that was already dead in terms of the number of substitutions. It looked like the team were being asked just to see the game out
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 12 minutes ago
I have not had the time to do an article on the tour so far due to me watching the open and wasting the rest of it trying to educate Nohlman and Scholay.
Iqbal especially has caught the eye. No idea why Hannibal hasn’t featured, I assume he is injured as well.
I have not been impressed with what I have seen with Laird. He reminds me too much of Ashley Young with continual backward passes when players are open upfield.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think we'll see a fair bit of iqbal and savage this season. The fact they know each others game inside out helps too.
Eh yo! How is it Man Utd’s last 2 games are on a Sat and Sun. July 30th - July 31st.
What kind of a madness is that? What am I missing here?
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------
If you're talking about positions then the opposite would be true. Iqbal has spent much of his time in the academy as a number 10 while Savage in the same team has been a more defensive minded midfielder who takes the ball off the defence and starts attacks from deep and defensive positioning would come more natural to him. Those are the things our current set of senior midfielders are lacking.
I'm not saying Iqbal doesn't possess attributes our other midfielders are lacking though.
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read so where that Forest have already signed their quota of loan players. I have no idea how accurate that was.
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 26 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read so where that Forest have already signed their quota of loan players. I have no idea how accurate that was.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they've already maxed out their quote for United players having already signed Henderson from us on loan. Open to being corrected on that but as far as I know, Garner couldn't be loaned back to Forest this season.
You can't loan two players from the same club and Henderson is there already.
I'm sure we won't be short of offers from lower end Premier League clubs for Garner if we do decide to loan him out again.
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 hour, 19 minutes ago
Eh yo! How is it Man Utd’s last 2 games are on a Sat and Sun. July 30th - July 31st.
What kind of a madness is that? What am I missing here?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The first one was already scheduled as part of the tour, then the second one 24 hours later was added as a bit of a money spinner to get people in to see ETH in his first home game. I guess the likes of Martinez and Eriksen who won’t be on the tour will get to play at least.
Assuming the squad will be split for both games so everyone gets close to a 90 minute or at least 65/70+ in them.
The only way Forest could have Henderson and Garner on loan is if one of the loans included an obligation to buy.
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 hour, 19 minutes ago
Eh yo! How is it Man Utd’s last 2 games are on a Sat and Sun. July 30th - July 31st.
What kind of a madness is that? What am I missing here?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The first one was already scheduled as part of the tour, then the second one 24 hours later was added as a bit of a money spinner to get people in to see ETH in his first home game. I guess the likes of Martinez and Eriksen who won’t be on the tour will get to play at least.
Assuming the squad will be split for both games so everyone gets close to a 90 minute or at least 65/70+ in them.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hmm… seems a bit risky still..
don’t need unnecessary foolishness to occur just before a big game.
Anyone ever heard of anything scheduled like that before?
Think teams play friendlies in 2 places at once or consecutive days quite often tbf with a split squad.
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 5 hours, 35 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think that they can take him on loan as they already have Hendo.
Ah, beaten to it about 50 times.
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 4 hours, 5 minutes ago
Think teams play friendlies in 2 places at once or consecutive days quite often tbf with a split squad.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok split squad sure, makes sense.
All I keep thinking is the same players doing most of the legwork..
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Garner's Return To Training
Page 1 of 1
posted on 17/7/22
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
posted on 17/7/22
I have not had the time to do an article on the tour so far due to me watching the open and wasting the rest of it trying to educate Nohlman and Scholay.
Iqbal especially has caught the eye. No idea why Hannibal hasn’t featured, I assume he is injured as well.
I have not been impressed with what I have seen with Laird. He reminds me too much of Ashley Young with continual backward passes when players are open upfield.
posted on 17/7/22
"I have not been impressed with what I have seen with Laird. He reminds me too much of Ashley Young with continual backward passes when players are open upfield."
Yeah I kind of felt that too. I'd heard he's a good athlete who gets up and down the pitch. But if all he does when he's up the pitch is turn back and play a safe pass, his ability to get there becomes redundant. Having said that, it was literally what, half an hour? And it was in a game that was already dead in terms of the number of substitutions. It looked like the team were being asked just to see the game out
posted on 17/7/22
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 12 minutes ago
I have not had the time to do an article on the tour so far due to me watching the open and wasting the rest of it trying to educate Nohlman and Scholay.
Iqbal especially has caught the eye. No idea why Hannibal hasn’t featured, I assume he is injured as well.
I have not been impressed with what I have seen with Laird. He reminds me too much of Ashley Young with continual backward passes when players are open upfield.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think we'll see a fair bit of iqbal and savage this season. The fact they know each others game inside out helps too.
posted on 17/7/22
Eh yo! How is it Man Utd’s last 2 games are on a Sat and Sun. July 30th - July 31st.
What kind of a madness is that? What am I missing here?
posted on 17/7/22
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
posted on 17/7/22
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
posted on 17/7/22
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------
If you're talking about positions then the opposite would be true. Iqbal has spent much of his time in the academy as a number 10 while Savage in the same team has been a more defensive minded midfielder who takes the ball off the defence and starts attacks from deep and defensive positioning would come more natural to him. Those are the things our current set of senior midfielders are lacking.
I'm not saying Iqbal doesn't possess attributes our other midfielders are lacking though.
posted on 17/7/22
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read so where that Forest have already signed their quota of loan players. I have no idea how accurate that was.
posted on 17/7/22
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 26 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read so where that Forest have already signed their quota of loan players. I have no idea how accurate that was.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think they've already maxed out their quote for United players having already signed Henderson from us on loan. Open to being corrected on that but as far as I know, Garner couldn't be loaned back to Forest this season.
posted on 17/7/22
You can't loan two players from the same club and Henderson is there already.
posted on 17/7/22
Beat me to it Berba
posted on 17/7/22
I'm sure we won't be short of offers from lower end Premier League clubs for Garner if we do decide to loan him out again.
posted on 17/7/22
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 hour, 19 minutes ago
Eh yo! How is it Man Utd’s last 2 games are on a Sat and Sun. July 30th - July 31st.
What kind of a madness is that? What am I missing here?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The first one was already scheduled as part of the tour, then the second one 24 hours later was added as a bit of a money spinner to get people in to see ETH in his first home game. I guess the likes of Martinez and Eriksen who won’t be on the tour will get to play at least.
Assuming the squad will be split for both games so everyone gets close to a 90 minute or at least 65/70+ in them.
posted on 17/7/22
The only way Forest could have Henderson and Garner on loan is if one of the loans included an obligation to buy.
posted on 17/7/22
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by StringerBell (U11749)
posted 1 hour, 19 minutes ago
Eh yo! How is it Man Utd’s last 2 games are on a Sat and Sun. July 30th - July 31st.
What kind of a madness is that? What am I missing here?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The first one was already scheduled as part of the tour, then the second one 24 hours later was added as a bit of a money spinner to get people in to see ETH in his first home game. I guess the likes of Martinez and Eriksen who won’t be on the tour will get to play at least.
Assuming the squad will be split for both games so everyone gets close to a 90 minute or at least 65/70+ in them.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hmm… seems a bit risky still..
don’t need unnecessary foolishness to occur just before a big game.
Anyone ever heard of anything scheduled like that before?
posted on 17/7/22
Think teams play friendlies in 2 places at once or consecutive days quite often tbf with a split squad.
posted on 17/7/22
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 5 hours, 35 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Car Van knee (U5318)
posted 26 minutes ago
I think Garber should go back to Middlesbrough for the season. Yes, he could be good for us this season as a squad player, but will he move the needle with regards to our finishing position? Likely not. But, if he goes out and is a starter for Middlesbrough in the PL it could have a significant impact on his development and therefore the chance of him becoming a top player for us in the future.
I think Iqbal should stay, his quality and position mean he can have a impact. Savage on the other hand could do with a loan in the Championship similar to Garner. The role he plays is a bit more physical and box to box, he is less likely to get game time at United and will see more benefit of a loan for a year or two.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Midlesborough?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
*nottingham
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't think that they can take him on loan as they already have Hendo.
posted on 17/7/22
Ah, beaten to it about 50 times.
posted on 17/7/22
comment by FFS Mike. (U1170)
posted 4 hours, 5 minutes ago
Think teams play friendlies in 2 places at once or consecutive days quite often tbf with a split squad.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok split squad sure, makes sense.
All I keep thinking is the same players doing most of the legwork..
Page 1 of 1