or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 25 comments are related to an article called:

Whoever it is ...........

Page 1 of 1

posted on 6/2/23

You Guys should hire Poch.. Decent young players would probably buy into his high energy/hard work approach.

posted on 6/2/23

I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

You'll know more than me. Did he actually deserve the sack? I think people forget he did take over a sinking ship anyway which isn't easy to turnaround.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by Diamondlights (U20501)
posted 55 seconds ago
You Guys should hire Poch.. Decent young players would probably buy into his high energy/hard work approach.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you mad, Diamond? We might need a manager ourselves in a few months.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Diamondlights (U20501)
posted 55 seconds ago
You Guys should hire Poch.. Decent young players would probably buy into his high energy/hard work approach.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you mad, Diamond? We might need a manager ourselves in a few months.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Haha.. Yeah I know. Id be OK with Poch back at Spurs but I think he'd do well at Leeds.... Lots of good young players that would buy into his Philosophy.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 5 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

You'll know more than me. Did he actually deserve the sack? I think people forget he did take over a sinking ship anyway which isn't easy to turnaround.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If you keep losing its no longer bad luck...he hadn't got a plan B, never addressed our leaky defence and thought netflix movies was the pep talk lol

posted on 6/2/23

Hopefully it’s Bielsa. We need to get our goal difference up.

posted on 6/2/23

Get Hockaday !

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 36 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
What?

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 38 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

You'll know more than me. Did he actually deserve the sack? I think people forget he did take over a sinking ship anyway which isn't easy to turnaround.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
he deserved never to be hired.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by Diamondlights (U20501)
posted 41 minutes ago
You Guys should hire Poch.. Decent young players would probably buy into his high energy/hard work approach.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
would take poch in a second. hed have us playing good high energy football with a purpose.
no headless chickens with his setup.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by Elsbels - El Jugador (U21658)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 36 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
What?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
From that response I assume you believe he's been woeful? On what grounds is he any worse than Biesla was in his final year? He took over a side that were shipping 4,5 and 6 goals for fun every week and saved you from certain relegation. What on earth did you expect from Marsch? That he was suddenly going to achieve mid-table with little to no backing financially? Come on. You're dreaming.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Elsbels - El Jugador (U21658)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 36 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
What?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
From that response I assume you believe he's been woeful? On what grounds is he any worse than Biesla was in his final year? He took over a side that were shipping 4,5 and 6 goals for fun every week and saved you from certain relegation. What on earth did you expect from Marsch? That he was suddenly going to achieve mid-table with little to no backing financially? Come on. You're dreaming.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Some of them thought they’d be pushing for Europe.

posted on 6/2/23

Seems the well informed journos agree with me...

https://twitter.com/OliverKay/status/1622616946926669824?cxt=HHwWgMC-gYXh2IQtAAAA


Oliver Kay
@OliverKay
I find the hostility/sneering towards Jesse Marsch very unjust. Did well to keep Leeds up last season, having taken over a team who conceded 20 goals in Bielsa’s final five games. Struggled this season, but that seemed fairly inevitable #LUFC

posted on 6/2/23

One Leeds fan here who agrees with you fridgeboy but I’m definitely in the minority. . Better side in a lot of games, more chances in a lot of games. But Missed chances and defensive errors killed us. Small margins between midtable and relegation trouble in this league. This side is a rcb and a left back off being a decent premier league side. Marsch’s biggest mistake in my view was not addressing that/demanding upgrades.

Others will tell you the football was rubbish, narrow , frantic, but the figures tell you on almost every stat we’re a midtable side - except the only one that counts. And the one that counts is what gets managers sacked.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 13 minutes ago
Seems the well informed journos agree with me...

https://twitter.com/OliverKay/status/1622616946926669824?cxt=HHwWgMC-gYXh2IQtAAAA


Oliver Kay
@OliverKay
I find the hostility/sneering towards Jesse Marsch very unjust. Did well to keep Leeds up last season, having taken over a team who conceded 20 goals in Bielsa’s final five games. Struggled this season, but that seemed fairly inevitable #LUFC
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Surprised this journalist didn't see what every Leeds supporter and almost all the TV pundits were seeing every week.
Tactically inept, played far too narrow, stuck with players who were totally out of form or in wrong positions and only replaced like for like subs.
Nice guy, talked a good game but really was out of his depth

comment by NJS (U8272)

posted on 6/2/23

Please not back to Bielsa, back to ‘basketball tactics’
Good and strong defensive strength is not one of his priorities….slam dunk football is good if you win, but hell if you lose games consistently, which he did.
He reminded me of an athletics coach with emphasis on running and less on ball skills, the players looked like 5000m or 10000m runners.
I was disappointed also with his attitude to team selection in FA Cup games, his record of winning games was woeful, didn’t seem to recognise the tradition of the competition, the fans feeling of a good cup run.
In my opinion we would have been relegated had he not been sacked, the players looked burnt out, the defence was a joke!
I fear Leeds are in downward spiral now, coaches will probably come and go…that for me will be the Bielsa legacy, I thought he was overrated his defensive failures are forgotten by the fans, a kind of amnesia!

posted on 6/2/23

comment by Lisandro The King Martinez (U10026)
posted 50 minutes ago
comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Elsbels - El Jugador (U21658)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 36 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
What?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
From that response I assume you believe he's been woeful? On what grounds is he any worse than Biesla was in his final year? He took over a side that were shipping 4,5 and 6 goals for fun every week and saved you from certain relegation. What on earth did you expect from Marsch? That he was suddenly going to achieve mid-table with little to no backing financially? Come on. You're dreaming.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Some of them thought they’d be pushing for Europe.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Why not? We finished ninth in our first year back. We thought we would surely strengthen but we didn't and then we were decimated by injuries to an already small side. Imo marsch didn't save us at all, the players did. I wouldn't want bielsa back, he did his job brilliantly but was too stubborn to make the changes nessesary to succeed in the pl.

posted on 6/2/23

comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 1 hour, 2 minutes ago
comment by Elsbels - El Jugador (U21658)
posted 11 minutes ago
comment by fridgeboy (U1053)
posted 36 minutes ago
I'm not as well informed as some of you Leeds fans but from the outside looking in, I felt he was quite unlucky in a lot of games. He had you playing some proper thrilling football at times. That Liverpool game was brilliant.

---------------------------------------------------------------------
What?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
From that response I assume you believe he's been woeful? On what grounds is he any worse than Biesla was in his final year? He took over a side that were shipping 4,5 and 6 goals for fun every week and saved you from certain relegation. What on earth did you expect from Marsch? That he was suddenly going to achieve mid-table with little to no backing financially? Come on. You're dreaming.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He got great financial backing.I don't know what you mean

posted on 6/2/23

I know it's beside the point now, but I'm getting really tired of the 'Bielsa shipped 4/5/6 goals a week crowd'. Yes, it got ugly towards the end but some have used that to distort the narrative and make it seem that this was the norm week in week out. It wasn't. Look beyond games against the big 6 in 21/22 and Man Utd in one match in 20/21, West Brom and Derby in a couple of freak games in 18/19 and there's nothing there at all.

As for who comes in next, well, I'm not too fussed as long as we don't see any ex-England basket cases (Rooney, Lampard, Gerrard) or anything sticking with the Red Bull style (Hasenhuttl - god no). A bit concerned that Chris Armas is apparently still with us.

posted on 6/2/23

It would be hilarious if Poch did take the Leeds job... I know it seems unlikely but don't underestimate what clout The 49ers may be able to yield.
Spurs fans would abolutely conbust especially as it would virtually ensure our survival this season and pip them for a Champions League spot next season.
Oh please God make this happen just for comedy value alone 🙏

posted on 6/2/23

comment by cornwallwhite22 (U2190)
posted 7 minutes ago
I know it's beside the point now, but I'm getting really tired of the 'Bielsa shipped 4/5/6 goals a week crowd'. Yes, it got ugly towards the end but some have used that to distort the narrative and make it seem that this was the norm week in week out. It wasn't. Look beyond games against the big 6 in 21/22 and Man Utd in one match in 20/21, West Brom and Derby in a couple of freak games in 18/19 and there's nothing there at all.

As for who comes in next, well, I'm not too fussed as long as we don't see any ex-England basket cases (Rooney, Lampard, Gerrard) or anything sticking with the Red Bull style (Hasenhuttl - god no). A bit concerned that Chris Armas is apparently still with us.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Totally agree - Rooney, Lampard or Gerrard are never going to cut it as top-level managers. Bring on Poch.

posted on 6/2/23

Why not?
———
Because the players aren’t good enough.

posted on 6/2/23

"Totally agree - Rooney, Lampard or Gerrard are never going to cut it as top-level managers. Bring on Poch.
---------------------------------------
Why not?
———
Because the players aren’t good enough."

Or they're not good enough!..

This club is big enough to get as good as any, its up to the people in charge of this club to do better!..

Now's the time for them to show which way they want to go!..

posted on 6/2/23

With regards to the OP - Never did.

Love MB but his small squad philosophy at PL Level was his achilles heal in the end.

posted on 6/2/23

Absolutely OP

Although the manager will be compared to Jesse ...... and then should have gotten Bielsa back.

Page 1 of 1

Sign in if you want to comment