or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 69 comments are related to an article called:

Who would you keep?

Page 1 of 3

posted on 17/12/23

I’d add Palma and remove Ralston, and maybe Iwata. Pretty short list, eh?! Gets even more grim when you factor in that CCV, Hatate and MOR will almost certainly be gone next summer … maybe earlier!

posted on 17/12/23

Rodgers, I'd definitely keep Rodgers, good manager, serial winner

posted on 17/12/23

Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

posted on 17/12/23

comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?

posted on 17/12/23

We started the season with a good Team/Squad - minus Jota, no? In recent weeks it’s become apparent how much we miss Mooy?
The managers outdated philosophy is failing to get the best out of the players available.
Every week, he starts games with HIS players and formation. By halftime he realises it’s pash. Panics and starts throwing subs on (3 sht LBs on the pitch at the same time!!!), hoping for a miracle.
Then repeats this the following game/week.

posted on 17/12/23

Rodgers ego is why we are in this mess. Nothing else.

posted on 17/12/23

comment by System-Addict ••• ••&... (U9239)
posted 5 minutes ago
We started the season with a good Team/Squad - minus Jota, no? In recent weeks it’s become apparent how much we miss Mooy?
The managers outdated philosophy is failing to get the best out of the players available.
Every week, he starts games with HIS players and formation. By halftime he realises it’s pash. Panics and starts throwing subs on (3 sht LBs on the pitch at the same time!!!), hoping for a miracle.
Then repeats this the following game/week.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If at first you don't succeed keep trying the same thing.
Like the definition of insanity.

posted on 17/12/23

if we lose to Rangers, BR can gft)
—-
Why, what’s showing?

posted on 17/12/23

ritchie … Out of interest, who are the players we haven’t seen in the hoops yet?

Of the summer additions, I’ve certainly seen enough of the following to form a judgement that they’re not currently good enough …

Nat Phillips
Lagerbloke
Yang
Holm
Kwon

Nawrocki MIGHT have something, but appears to be a perma-crock … arrived injured, played a handful of games looking OK at best, then injured for ages. Now fit, but is seemingly rated behind Welsh, Lager and Phillips … if that was me I’d be looking for a different career.

Tillio … even the club admit he isn’t ready for SPFL level, which is a fecking low bar.

posted on 17/12/23

comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??

posted on 17/12/23

comment by Dave The Jackal (U22179)
posted 4 minutes ago
ritchie … Out of interest, who are the players we haven’t seen in the hoops yet?

Of the summer additions, I’ve certainly seen enough of the following to form a judgement that they’re not currently good enough …

Nat Phillips
Lagerbloke
Yang
Holm
Kwon

Nawrocki MIGHT have something, but appears to be a perma-crock … arrived injured, played a handful of games looking OK at best, then injured for ages. Now fit, but is seemingly rated behind Welsh, Lager and Phillips … if that was me I’d be looking for a different career.

Tillio … even the club admit he isn’t ready for SPFL level, which is a fecking low bar.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I hear you but some of those guys have only played a few games or in some cases a few minutes ,bit early to dismiss them at this stage ? Another thing being overlooked is that this hoops team were struggling towards the end of Anges reign we were bloody awful at the end of last season long b4 the title was clinched .

posted on 17/12/23

ritchie … Hear what you’re saying about giving players time, but I don’t think anyone can really argue against our summer window looking like a disaster at this point. Palma is the only decent recruit IMO, and even he’s a significant downgrade on the player he replaced (Jota).

On the entitlement stuff, I certainly don’t expect us to win every week domestically. Football doesn’t work like that. What I DO expect is for us to be coached well (defensively as well as offensively), have a clear style of play, and to at least look decent every week … given we’re up against teams with a tenth of our resources (at best), outwith Rangers. We’re showing none of that, and haven’t been all season, even when we were at least getting results. This isn’t a blip in form, it’s a major problem … and BR is a major part of that problem. Let’s be honest, he was up against fook all in his first stint, yet we were still tailing off badly and dropping points regularly in his last 18 months. Yes, we weren’t that great latterly under Ange, but we only dropped 15 points all season … we’ve dropped 12 already, and got papped out of a cup by Killie. That happens … did the great one learn from it? Nope. Blames the players.

posted on 17/12/23

Not like ritchie to take a contrary position on things.

Phillips is absolutely dire. Kwon can’t get a game for the B team.

There’s some merit that the others ‘might’ have something in them, but Rodgers is complaining about inconsistency while constantly changing the line up and playing players out of the position they’re used to. Issue for me is that if Rodgers wasn’t involved in bringing them in, he’s not interested in their development.

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 17/12/23

Let's be honest, Rodgers is a property tycoon indulging his hobby of football manager.

I'd be letting a new manager try get a tune out the current squad. Whether they've chucked it under him or not it damn well looks like it. He's playing stupid power games since he was just in the door. OK Ange did a bit of mouthing off but generally he tried to play the best team he could.

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 17/12/23

And, out of interest, Heed, what other academy prospects would you keep for potential?

posted on 17/12/23

comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 1 hour, 1 minute ago
And, out of interest, Heed, what other academy prospects would you keep for potential?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Haven’t seen enough of them to form an opinion

comment by 12In13 (U9258)

posted on 17/12/23

comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.

posted on 17/12/23

comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 58 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For repeatedly feckin up from a position of strength? Not ridiculous at all.

comment by St3vie (U11028)

posted on 17/12/23

comment by Why the pallaver, aka Count Binface (a little ... (U10168)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 58 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For repeatedly feckin up from a position of strength? Not ridiculous at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't mean to sound daft....but see when you are on top, it's somewhat inevitable that the only way is down after a while

posted on 17/12/23

comment by St3vie (U11028)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Why the pallaver, aka Count Binface (a little ... (U10168)
posted 15 minutes ago
comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 58 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For repeatedly feckin up from a position of strength? Not ridiculous at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't mean to sound daft....but see when you are on top, it's somewhat inevitable that the only way is down after a while
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Of course it is, but we don’t need to actively make it happen? Desmond and Lawwell excel in this. I can accept others doing better, making it happen, that deserves respect. Making decisions that negatively impact a multi million pound business, repeatedly? No

posted on 17/12/23

I'd keep all of them and get the manager to fvck.

He's ruined kyogo, mcgregor, aj, and taylor.

On that basis i have no idea if any of our summer signings are good, all i know is we have manager who pushes boring, schite, football to an extent that its buggered some standout players last season.

I've no idea if any of them are any good, he's dragged pur best down so who is to say he hasnt done the same to them?

He's a joke.

comment by 12In13 (U9258)

posted on 17/12/23

comment by Why the pallaver, aka Count Binface (a little more apathetic) (U10168)
posted 35 minutes ago
comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 58 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For repeatedly feckin up from a position of strength? Not ridiculous at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's just such a reductionist view point. I look at the bigger picture in regards to how healthy the club is overall, the trophies won over the years etc. What football club doesn't hit a bad patch now n again? Let's just settle down a bit n see what happens after the window closes

posted on 17/12/23

comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Why the pallaver, aka Count Binface (a little more apathetic) (U10168)
posted 35 minutes ago
comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 58 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For repeatedly feckin up from a position of strength? Not ridiculous at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's just such a reductionist view point. I look at the bigger picture in regards to how healthy the club is overall, the trophies won over the years etc. What football club doesn't hit a bad patch now n again? Let's just settle down a bit n see what happens after the window closes
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I do too. Have seen this too many times to know it's not a one off, not even the 2nd time

posted on 17/12/23

comment by Why the pallaver, aka Count Binface (a little more apathetic) (U10168)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Why the pallaver, aka Count Binface (a little more apathetic) (U10168)
posted 35 minutes ago
comment by EightThrees (U9258)
posted 58 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 5 hours, 8 minutes ago
comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 30 minutes ago
comment by ritchiebhoy (U10107)
posted 15 minutes ago
Have to say the current generation of hoops supporters come across as a spoiled entitled bunch .
That list is ridiculous you've made judgement on players who haven't even been seen in the hoops yet .
Ridiculous overreaction to a bad spell of form ,let's analyse

1. Sack rhe board who have been in charge for the most successful period the club has known both in terms of trophies and finance
2.Sack the manager who until this season has won every domestic trophy he has competed for as our manager .

Look at Man City's run of form just now are they calling for peps head or the board to be sacked ??

As I say bunch of entitled muppets do we want Lenny back FFS

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh come on Mabawza, it’s only a bit of light hearted fun. No need to get upset eh?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm not upset mate just dismayed at the whole entitled agenda that my fellow hoops fans are displaying.On another matter the atmosphere at celtic park is utter pash now too ,some blame the banning of the ridiculously self important and entitled GB but the atmosphere at Celtic Park was always good long before the GB ever existed,another sign of the entitlement our fan base now displays ??
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agreed. Sack the board?? Biggest load a pi55 I've heard.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For repeatedly feckin up from a position of strength? Not ridiculous at all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's just such a reductionist view point. I look at the bigger picture in regards to how healthy the club is overall, the trophies won over the years etc. What football club doesn't hit a bad patch now n again? Let's just settle down a bit n see what happens after the window closes
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I do too. Have seen this too many times to know it's not a one off, not even the 2nd time
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Btw, don't make the mistake of thinking anyone complaining is young and spoiled with success. I am not.

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 17/12/23

comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 3 hours ago
comment by Silver (U6112)
posted 1 hour, 1 minute ago
And, out of interest, Heed, what other academy prospects would you keep for potential?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Haven’t seen enough of them to form an opinion
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Come now, you've been convinced by seeing 20m of a LB you've never seen before played at LW.

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment