or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 31 comments are related to an article called:

Mark Hughes

Page 1 of 2

posted on 25/10/11

It's exactly the way Man City went.

Thai Owners, Give Sven the job, Sack Sven, Bring in Mark Hughes, Does a good job, Sack Mark Hughes.

I wouldn't mind him tbh.

posted on 25/10/11

meh. Okayish.

posted on 25/10/11

Please god no! Average manager unproven at this level.

posted on 25/10/11

The cabin boy - who do you want?

posted on 25/10/11

Mark Hughes is a good manager. However, I think he's more interested in himself and his own ego rather than others, hence why he left fulham, and would probably walk away from us after one season.

posted on 25/10/11

No thanks. He clearly comes with Issues...

posted on 25/10/11

For the record i'm not too keen on Hughes myself. But compared to some of the other names (Keane, McLaren etc) then yes please.

MON or Billy Davies are the only two names that would appease me after getting rid of someone of Sven's calibre.

posted on 25/10/11

Someone like Dave Jones or Billy Davies would be fine - they know this division. I also want to be loved.

posted on 25/10/11

Don't we all?

But what about their history of not taking clubs up out of the division, sometimes (particularly in Dave Jones' case) when he probably should have given the talent at his disposal?

posted on 25/10/11

Dave Jones took Wolves up?

Billy Davies took Derby up?

posted on 25/10/11

They had crap teams, imagine what they could do with a decent one!

posted on 25/10/11

Doctor Fox - And both went straight back down again, in Derby's case with added humiliation.

The cabin boy - Did they have crap teams, or did they bring in crap players?

posted on 25/10/11

Quite correct Dunge but they did get them there! And judging by our owners apparant desparation for getting exactly that.....!

posted on 25/10/11

Dave jones should have got Cardiff promoted with the squad he had.

Billy Davies should have got Forest promoted with the squad he had.

Iain Dowie got Crystal palace promoted - does that make him a good manager? - Probably not for me.

comment by Fox_14 (U2869)

posted on 25/10/11

Ian Holloway got Blackpool promoted - does that make him a good manager? - Definitely not for me!!

comment by Vulpes (U6011)

posted on 25/10/11

Personally, I'd rather Mark Hughes cut out the middle man and walked (quite a long way) away from us before his appointment, rather than waiting a year.

comment by Vulpes (U6011)

posted on 25/10/11

Just seen this on BBC Sport:

Former Leicester midfielder Neil Lennon has backed Martin O'Neill to return to the club as the successor to Sven-Goran Eriksson.

"It would be great to see him back in the game, first of all," Lennon said. "One of his old adages was that you never go back, but I think it is very, very tempting for him."

posted on 25/10/11

In one way I'd love to think it may be true but if, as Lennon says, it was one of Martin's old adages that you never go back I'd doubt it. I'm not sure about Mark Hughes but would prefer him to Davies & Jones. I just hope the owners make a wise choice and give whoever it is a fair crack of the whip.

posted on 25/10/11

Mark Hughes is a good shout, he would be second on my list behind the obvious and if he wanted to come, then I'd be happy to have him. I don't think he can accuse us of not being ambitious enough though.

comment by Culle (U1873)

posted on 25/10/11

Where Man City & Blackburn happy with Mark?

posted on 25/10/11

Man City weren't happy with him, they sacked him but I think he was unlucky to lose his job. I think he was only a couple of places off the Champions League places at the time. Blackburn, he did very well there and left to take up the Man City job.

comment by Vulpes (U6011)

posted on 25/10/11

Blackburn finished bottom of the Prem fair play league in all 4 seasons Hughes was in charge there – is that really what we want, a team of cloggers?

posted on 25/10/11

Well our disciplinary record isn't great as it is.

posted on 25/10/11

Don't want Hughes, he's very uninspiring and has only really done midtable jobs without any 'fireworks' (and no I'm not on about Balotelli).

I mean he's not a terrible manager but he's never going to be a great one either.

If we can't get O'Neill I'd like to see us go for Di Matteo. Failing that, you could throw a blanket over Billy Davies, Lee Clark and Karl Robinson, all offer something a bit different and have impressive CVs - the latter 2 not in this division but they are young and you have to start somewhere.

posted on 25/10/11

I doubt we'll get RDM, recently appointed number 2 at Chelsea so I don't think he'll leave there.

But you're right in that, behind O'Neill, there are many candidates who all have pro's and con's. It's vital we get this decision right though.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment