or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 112 comments are related to an article called:

If you were the gaffer for the day

Page 2 of 5

posted on 8/11/11

Adam Johnson, do you think bill is made of transfer funds!



352 can be as defensive as a 451 can be offensive.

You pick my opinion apart then give this half arrsed reply

posted on 8/11/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 8/11/11

comment by Fellaini's pirouette to perfection (U1308)
posted 16 hours, 17 minutes ago

Easy

Howard in goal, he is a good goalie

A back three of Distin, Johnny and Jags giving better distribution from the back.

A midfield or Coleman, Rodwell, Fellaini, Barkley and Barnes

and a front pair of Bily and Saha.

I would only want £1M a year as boss too

==

As you seem lazy and unable to look at my original post I have stuck it up for you.

posted on 8/11/11

I am not asking the two to play LB and RB, I am making them part of a midfield 5!

Three defenders at the back to mark in essence the one striker 95% of teams play should allow for more than enough cover.

Also how can an oppositions wide player get forward as much when they are markingin a 5 man midfield with just 4 players?

posted on 8/11/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 8/11/11

But I dont plan to use Royston as a WB, he is not even in my selection.

Why do you think Fellani is in the side I picked, I can tell you its not for his defence bursting surges forward.

It also allows for the inclusin of barkley (box to box midfielder) in the side.

posted on 8/11/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 8/11/11

Again this is my team, what i feel will work and get players into suitable position.

posted on 8/11/11

3-5-2 ?

Did you know The Stone Roses are back?

posted on 8/11/11

Phil,
i know you have some,shall we say,novel ideas re football tactics.
The innovative idea of bombarding a goalkeeper with free kicks whilst taking advantage of the sun shining in his eyes was memorable to say the least.
I must take you to task on your latest formation.
3-5-2 does not work in modern football,otherwise we would have teams playing in the top divisions of Europe playing 3-5-2 every week.
To my knowledge i dont know of 1 team playing that formation.
I would be grateful if you can let me know of any teams that play 3-5-2.

posted on 8/11/11

Tell me why it won't work?

posted on 8/11/11

Ask the 20 managers in the prem.
If they wont tell you,ask the mangers from La Liga,Serie A,Bundesliga etc,etc

posted on 8/11/11

So you don't know why then

posted on 8/11/11

Yes i do.
It wont be sunny most Saturdays

posted on 8/11/11

Its okay that you don't know.

posted on 8/11/11

posted on 8/11/11

Have you ever considered the Ricky Tomlinson part

posted on 9/11/11

Phil,

I will try in simple terms where your 3-5-2 formation does not work.
Quite a lot of teams play 4-3-3 nowadays.
Do you know of a manager,any manager,who would leave his defenders 1 on 1.
3 on 3 if that helps to clarify it for you.

posted on 9/11/11

You still not managed to make a valid point on this.....yet

posted on 9/11/11

posted on 9/11/11

3-5-2 ?

My ar$e....as Mr Barett would say.

posted on 9/11/11

He builds nice houses, but what does Mr Barett know about football

posted on 9/11/11

He knows the same as you

posted on 9/11/11

Ooohh,the spill cheque people are here

posted on 9/11/11

Are you going to give your counter argument against my point re 3 defenders marking 3 forwards?

Page 2 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment