or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 35 comments are related to an article called:

A Hypothetical Question

Page 1 of 2

posted on 9/2/12

1. joy with
2. phil brown
3. zero
4. how dare you to take my name

posted on 9/2/12

1. Yeehah

2. Hodgson

3. Slightly better if Harry controls the players and not the other way round.

4. She may act as an agent for some of them.





P.S. There are no serious posters on here.

posted on 9/2/12

1. If he walks out of the club before May I'd be pi$$ed off and would be tempted to boycott England, if he focusses on us and leaves after May 13 I'd be gutted as he is a very good manager but resigned to the fact that he views the job as bigger than Spurs and would wish him well.

2. Jose, Hiddink,Van Gaal, Mancini (if he gets sacked at City)

3. If you mixed Alf Ramsey, Jose, Bill Shankly and Alex Ferguson we wouldn't win EURO 2012, players aren't good enough frankly, I think Harry would make a decent fist of it though

4. Rosie is the brains behind the operation so why not.

posted on 9/2/12

2. Jose, Hiddink,Van Gaal, Mancini (if he gets sacked at City)

--

you miss pep guardiola

posted on 9/2/12

1. Disappointed if it happened now, would accept it in the summer.
2. Would love Mourinho, more realistically Rijkard/Hiddink/Moyes
3. Zero with anyone in charge

posted on 9/2/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/2/12

I don't think Jose would goto Spurs. Hiddink would be a great choice for you and would continue on, with what you have, I believe.

Nobody would consider Rafa, La Liga, UEFA Cup and Champions League winner?

posted on 9/2/12

Can't he manage both?

posted on 9/2/12

1.
2.
3.
4.

posted on 9/2/12

To be honest I think Harry is a very good manager but I also think he will get found out tactically if he takes the England job.

Yes he has done great for Spurs but look at the disasters when he tried to be clever and switch things about for what are seen as lesser competitions, eg. Carling Cup, Europa League.

The likes of SAF and whinger field weakened sides and still reach finals because tactically they are very astute. Harry tries to do the same and we get a good hiding.

Good manager yes , top class international manager no. The fact that we dont have the players to win the euros anyway will see the press turn on him after about 30 seconds. Bad mistake by him if he takes it but I think he will.

posted on 9/2/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/2/12

2. Who would you want to replace him?

Who? My inner monologue? Well, I think Joe Pasquale would be quite funny for a while...a hmmm hmmmm
----------------
Gotta be James earl jones

posted on 9/2/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by GOODBYE (U1029)

posted on 9/2/12

1. What would your thoughts on this be? - Pride
2. Who would you want to replace him? - Big Sam
3. What would you think of England's chances? - Slim
4. Will Rosie take over the U21's? - No

posted on 9/2/12



That's the NOOOOOOOooooooo from the end of the last (new) one, that bit cracked me up!

posted on 9/2/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/2/12

comment by grandspurs (U3810)
posted 10 minutes ago
To be honest I think Harry is a very good manager but I also think he will get found out tactically if he takes the England job.

Yes he has done great for Spurs but look at the disasters when he tried to be clever and switch things about for what are seen as lesser competitions, eg. Carling Cup, Europa League.

The likes of SAF and whinger field weakened sides and still reach finals because tactically they are very astute. Harry tries to do the same and we get a good hiding.

Good manager yes , top class international manager no. The fact that we dont have the players to win the euros anyway will see the press turn on him after about 30 seconds. Bad mistake by him if he takes it but I think he will.
-----------------------------------------
I don't think you have to be a tactical master to manage an international team through a major tournament. You don't have to rest players or even change things too much, especially if you're lucky enough to manage one of the best teams in the world, which England still are. I mean it shouldn't be too testing until the quarters, if the draw doesn't turn out too nasty.

posted on 9/2/12

I don't think you have to be a tactical master to manage an international team through a major tournament
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tell me you are not serious please

posted on 9/2/12

comment by grandspurs (U3810)
posted 2 minutes ago
I don't think you have to be a tactical master to manage an international team through a major tournament
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tell me you are not serious please
------------------------------------------------------
Indeed I am. Look at Scolari for an example.

posted on 9/2/12

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 9/2/12

Galv

posted on 9/2/12

Indeed I am. Look at Scolari for an example
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Great example because he won what at international level ?

posted on 9/2/12

and dont mention his world cup with Brazil Rosie could win the world cup with a brazilian team

posted on 9/2/12

comment by grandspurs (U3810)
posted 2 minutes ago
Indeed I am. Look at Scolari for an example
-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Great example because he won what at international level ?
--------------------------------
Only the World Cup.

posted on 9/2/12

comment by grandspurs (U3810)
posted 42 seconds ago
and dont mention his world cup with Brazil Rosie could win the world cup with a brazilian team
------------------------------------------
Exactly. Which was the point I was trying to make. At an international tournament you don't have to have a tactical master, to do well, when you are lucky enough to be coaching one of the top teams. You just have to motivate them and you'll do well.

Page 1 of 2

Sign in if you want to comment