They have no history.
When Whytey sold the Arsenal shares he pawned the silverware at the same time.
There have been posts on here about this all week. They are clinging to this like some sort if comfort pillow. We didn't go into liquidation, there was no break in our history. We won the big one, deal with it.
desperate times calls for desperate measures.
Have to say I have heard this loads today and to be honest is a desperate attempt that if Rangers start again then they keep the trophy record
Like forever says it dies with the club
Will it be the same club? no. Will it be the same team, yes.
The Celtic name change & the Rangers name change (if it happens are exactly the same, so far as Companies House are concerned.
The reasons behind the change would of course be different - Rangers through insolvency, Celtic to enable raising of capital (so not THAT different - both financial reasons).
Bu the same team, playing in the same league, with the same colours & crest, and the same name (I don't see Celtic PLC at the top of any league), would be the same team as founded in 1872.
Just as the current Celtic team is the same team founded in 1888.
The ONLY way it would be different is if another's teams league membership was used by Rangers NewCo - as Airdrie did.
Of course then, it would be a completely different scenario, and a completely new team.
Forever,
They just cant seem to grasp your second point.
Some of their absolute stupidity has really surprised me today.
The thing I found absolutely risable was that none of the commentators actually took up this point. Surely they are not daft enough to try to support this point of view.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Doesnt really matter. Even if we go down the NewCo route, we still keep your history. Uefa have set a precedent for this.
Doesnt really matter. Even if we go down the NewCo route, we still keep your history. Uefa have set a precedent for this.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
seen your post about this on the gers board, im not convinced, if you are able to forfit your history of debt like Fiorentina done then surely you forfit the rest of your history aswell you are a new organisation it should work both ways
Eh..wasn't the daft mare also missing another point. Haven't Rangers themselves been a plc and de-listed and changed their status several times already...no 54 titles anyway by her logic. They are dangerous when they get that desperate
"seen your post about this on the gers board, im not convinced, if you are able to forfit your history of debt like Fiorentina done then surely you forfit the rest of your history aswell you are a new organisation it should work both ways"
Dunno, till I seen uefa's stance on it I would probably have agreed with you.
That team was totally gone though! A year went by when they didnt even play!
Uefa still handed them back all theri historical achievements when they were NewCo'd though.
To be honest, Im not even that bothered if we lose the history. Better than nothing! Least we will have a cleaner record than you lot when it comes to disciplinary situations!
Did Fiorentina go inot liquidation or were they simply in hybernation. Agree the name changed, but did the club cease to exist????
Fiorentina went into liquidation
Page 1 of 1
First
Previous
1
Next
Latest
Sign in if you want to comment
Daft woman on Clyde tonight
Page 1 of 1
posted on 22/2/12
They have no history.
When Whytey sold the Arsenal shares he pawned the silverware at the same time.
posted on 22/2/12
There have been posts on here about this all week. They are clinging to this like some sort if comfort pillow. We didn't go into liquidation, there was no break in our history. We won the big one, deal with it.
posted on 22/2/12
desperate times calls for desperate measures.
posted on 22/2/12
Have to say I have heard this loads today and to be honest is a desperate attempt that if Rangers start again then they keep the trophy record
Like forever says it dies with the club
posted on 22/2/12
Will it be the same club? no. Will it be the same team, yes.
The Celtic name change & the Rangers name change (if it happens are exactly the same, so far as Companies House are concerned.
The reasons behind the change would of course be different - Rangers through insolvency, Celtic to enable raising of capital (so not THAT different - both financial reasons).
Bu the same team, playing in the same league, with the same colours & crest, and the same name (I don't see Celtic PLC at the top of any league), would be the same team as founded in 1872.
Just as the current Celtic team is the same team founded in 1888.
The ONLY way it would be different is if another's teams league membership was used by Rangers NewCo - as Airdrie did.
Of course then, it would be a completely different scenario, and a completely new team.
posted on 22/2/12
Forever,
They just cant seem to grasp your second point.
Some of their absolute stupidity has really surprised me today.
posted on 22/2/12
The thing I found absolutely risable was that none of the commentators actually took up this point. Surely they are not daft enough to try to support this point of view.
posted on 22/2/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 22/2/12
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 22/2/12
Doesnt really matter. Even if we go down the NewCo route, we still keep your history. Uefa have set a precedent for this.
posted on 22/2/12
^our history
posted on 22/2/12
Doesnt really matter. Even if we go down the NewCo route, we still keep your history. Uefa have set a precedent for this.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
seen your post about this on the gers board, im not convinced, if you are able to forfit your history of debt like Fiorentina done then surely you forfit the rest of your history aswell you are a new organisation it should work both ways
posted on 22/2/12
Eh..wasn't the daft mare also missing another point. Haven't Rangers themselves been a plc and de-listed and changed their status several times already...no 54 titles anyway by her logic. They are dangerous when they get that desperate
posted on 22/2/12
"seen your post about this on the gers board, im not convinced, if you are able to forfit your history of debt like Fiorentina done then surely you forfit the rest of your history aswell you are a new organisation it should work both ways"
Dunno, till I seen uefa's stance on it I would probably have agreed with you.
That team was totally gone though! A year went by when they didnt even play!
Uefa still handed them back all theri historical achievements when they were NewCo'd though.
To be honest, Im not even that bothered if we lose the history. Better than nothing! Least we will have a cleaner record than you lot when it comes to disciplinary situations!
posted on 23/2/12
Did Fiorentina go inot liquidation or were they simply in hybernation. Agree the name changed, but did the club cease to exist????
posted on 23/2/12
Fiorentina went into liquidation
Page 1 of 1