or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 130 comments are related to an article called:

PFA Player or the Year Shortlist

Page 1 of 6

posted on 16/4/12

Krul has been better than Hart.

posted on 16/4/12

Parker?

posted on 16/4/12

RVP will win surely?

posted on 16/4/12

I am very surprised Hart and Parker were both nominated.

posted on 16/4/12

By the way, Young Player of the year:

Agüero, Welbeck, Sturridge, Oxlade-Chamberlain, Bale, Walker.

comment by Damo69 (U1004)

posted on 16/4/12

RVP will pi55 it.

posted on 16/4/12

RVP will win.

Scott Parker should be nowhere near that list.

posted on 16/4/12

Thought a Newcastle player would've made the list

posted on 16/4/12

RVP will win, with Rooney second and Aguero third

comment by Damo69 (U1004)

posted on 16/4/12

Aguero for young player

posted on 16/4/12

Wtf is Parker doing on that list?

No Koscielny?

No Kompany?

No Evans?

posted on 16/4/12

Parker? I'm not advocating an Arsenal Player (Although Song has been better than Parker) But surely a Newcastle or Swansea player?

posted on 16/4/12

I think the top 3 will be RVP, Silva and Rooney. Young player of the year will probably be Bale although I firstly think that he shouldn't be on the shortlist if he won the senior award last year and secondly of the 6 names on that list Aguero has been by a mile the best player.

posted on 16/4/12

Sorry Batmanu I posted a new article without seeing this one.

Parker
Hart
No Krul
No Szczesny

And Ox hasn't done much yet either

posted on 16/4/12

To be fair, Silva was good for the first half of the season but has done jack in the second half. By that logic Ba should be on the list.

posted on 16/4/12

CMs who have been comfortably better than Parker this season:

Cabaye
Tiote
Toure
Carrick
Arteta
Britton
Allen

I could probably name a few more too.

posted on 16/4/12

Joe Allen not there for young player?
Also, Vorm has been much better than Hart. But I wouldn't have either of them there, or Parker.

posted on 16/4/12

Wow Juan Mata completely ignored. He's only 23 as well- same age as Aguero. PFA

posted on 16/4/12

Once again Tony Hibbert is cruelly ignored......I don't want to live on this planet anymore.

Lists like these basically show us what we know in that many footballers know pisssss all about football and vote for whoever The Sun and other aspects of the English media have been hyping up.

No Vincent Kompany is ridiculous especially when you see Parker being there.

posted on 16/4/12

due to the xenophobia in the media etc in this country it will be Rooney and Bale and not the true winners of RVP and Aguero

posted on 16/4/12

Why has Dempsey not been mentioned?

posted on 16/4/12

Remember that it is the players that vote for these people, it is not a randomly decided shortlist. Basically the media hypes up certain players and then the players fall for the hype, hence the inclusion of the likes of Hart (best keeper we have had since Seaman) and Parker (nice guy and currently England captain). Likewise with the young player of the year, AOC has only played a handful of games, he shouldn't be anywhere near that list but Gary Neville is in love with him so people pay attention. G.Nev loves Bale and Walker too so no surprise to see their inclusions.

posted on 16/4/12

Well this is easy then. RVP to win it by a mile.

He can then place his trophy in the Emirates trophy cabinet and we can claim an end to our drought

posted on 16/4/12

I know its a bias view point but Skrtel has been pretty immense this year, Parker shouldn't be anywhere near that list.

posted on 16/4/12

where is Valencia

Page 1 of 6

Sign in if you want to comment