or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 88 comments are related to an article called:

Mphela on trial

Page 1 of 4

comment by Tully (U4246)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

A trial cannot hurt, because you are not losing anything as opposed to jumping right in and signing him. Celtic seem to have a scout who is now scouting the African market. Very good players in Africa, but teams from the continent never win the World Cup because all their good players are scattered across different nations.

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IRhhLJMB2J4

Wow! What a goal that was!

posted on 18/7/11

Scheidt was over 10 years ago and it still haunts us to this very day, even more than Du Wei!

it's a fair point though Tully,

posted on 18/7/11

Laugh all you want Dados but our scouting is going to be worth a lot financially. I am happy that we go out there looking for the Borucs, Nakamuras and Izzys of this world. Much happier than just feeding off the scraps of unwanted Premiership players and SPL players.

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

I am happy that we go out there looking for the Borucs, Nakamuras and Izzys of this world.

Made a fortune off those guys!

Izzy Man U 10m

posted on 18/7/11

and how did miller do when he moved to Turkey?

Or Boydy and Thomson at the 'Boro?

Or Cuellar? Has he re-signed for Real McDrid yet?

Chris Burke?! Anyone?

posted on 18/7/11

Boruc, rated as one of the top five goalkeepers in the world and is actually doing well at Fiorentina.

Nakamura was quality and there is no denying that he had over 80 appearances in Serie A before joining us and he scored some amazing goals. He was eventually home sick and returned to Japan.

Izzy won every POTY award going. He had a couple of bad games since ICT, and the bears treat that as half a season.

posted on 18/7/11

you know that lot Henrik, never let the facts get in the way of a good pffft.....

posted on 18/7/11

and how did naka do in la liga? flop fair to say?

and boruc hows he doin? setting the world on fire at Fiorentina?

izzy, half a good season in the spl a good player does not make.
==============================================

It's totally irrelevant what those players achieve once they've moved from Celtic. What matters is that were major successes while they were here.

And as for your comment about Izzy. Did you only watch half of last season or something?

posted on 18/7/11

They just cannot accept that we have a manager who is fed up being a retirement home for EPL duds. We have moved on to go for young player with technical ability and sell them on. They can sign the EPL rejects: Cuellar, Healy, Diouf etc all they want but Celtic should not. We look across the world and the lower English leagues so we do not end up paying over the price for pash. I accept we signed Ljungberg but that was solely for experience. But we should not pay 20k a week for players past it.

comment by polloks (U2971)

posted on 18/7/11

Boruc, rated as one of the top five goalkeepers in the world and is actually doing well at Fiorentina.

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

and where was izzy when ypou got humped out of europe?
========================================

He didn't play in Europe for Celtic.


where was izzy when you got humped by rangers?
=======================================

When? He played 7 games against Rangers last season having lost only 2.


where was izzy when you couldnt beat hamilton
====================================
Do you know how many games there are in season? You've cited 3 games - only 2 of which were defeats. How does that cover half a season?

It's pretty clear that you don't know what you're on about when it comes to Izaguirre.

posted on 18/7/11

that is 4 games isn't it. Add ICT and it's 5. We only playing a 10 game season now?

comment by polloks (U2971)

posted on 18/7/11

whatever way you look at he is nowhere near as good as you pretend that he is

4 assists and 1 goal over a whole season is not the mark of an amzing attacking fullback who is better than Roberto Carlos and Lizirazu morphed into one body is it

he is a good player but nowhere near as good as you tell yourselves he is

posted on 18/7/11

Andy, according to that particular Rangers fan, players are only judged on the odd defeat (2 of them) and games they didn't even play in. Celtic players that is.

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

Who said we thought he was as good as roberto carlos? I love it how the rangers fans make stuff up to make their point. I'll put my life on the fact that no celtic fan that knows what they are talking about has ever compared emilio to roberto. He is without a doubt the best LB in the league at the present and has settled very well in the scottish game. We cant judge him on europe as he hasnt played yet, but he will. Hows the next robbie keane, healy getting on? haha.

posted on 18/7/11

stormed home.... by a point....

comment by polloks (U2971)

posted on 18/7/11

he's not as good as papac

nowhere near as good actually

he can do wee step overs but that about it

he really is nowhere near as good as you tell yourselves

posted on 18/7/11

short memories bhoys.
===================

I clearly remember Izzaguire having a great debut season. A season for me covers more than 3 games though.

posted on 18/7/11

stormed home.... by a point....

He is talking as if we played them every game in the season. The fact you were in europe had no effect on us whatsoever we play dundee, hearts, killie and so on regardless of watty catching a plane to park a bus. you beat us by one point. As has been said before it would have been enough to win it the past few seasons. What were we meant to do? play extra friendlies the nights you had to play in europe? would that mean we have the right to be proud of producing the closest league battle there has been since tommy was incharge. Phannies

Page 1 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment