or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 88 comments are related to an article called:

Mphela on trial

Page 3 of 4

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by polloks (U2971)

posted on 18/7/11

Stokes more goals and more assists than jelavic. ergo in Pollockworld Stokes is the better player. Now let's take a show of hands to see who agrees with Pollock. <Laugh> Stop it Pollock your only hurting yourself I dont sense much support for your opinion mate, not even from the dafties on your side
-
and i don't understand why you would feel the need to make these things up

i said Papac was better than izzaguire because he is a better left back no because of what he has won

you made that bit up yourself


by the way the smileys are just to show you how ridiculious it makes a post look

posted on 18/7/11

papac is better cos he won more prizes than izzy

craig beattie won as many titles as any player at ibrox

papac is better cos he had more goals and assists than izzy

stokes had more goals and assists than jelavic

i hope these simplified examples prove what utter pash your talking

im only trying to help you

someone should

no smileys

just facts

izzy scottish player's player of the year

izzy scottish journalists player of the year

izzy celtic player of the year

just facts son

izzy better than papac

only a dunderheed would disagree

comment by polloks (U2971)

posted on 18/7/11

by the way pollock is some sort of fish

pollok is a place

not a plaice

posted on 18/7/11

Another blue-chip signing ....

The biscuit tin is alive and well !

posted on 18/7/11

"2nd stint at Europe"...he must be good

posted on 18/7/11

so why ar'nt the top teams in england interested then?
=============================================

What does that have to do with the fact that he played well for Celtic for more than half a season?

Funnily enough, THE top team in England were apparently interested in him in January. That doesn't fit in with a single thing you've said.

You claimed he started to play well after January and then you claim no top English teams have shown an interest. Yet Man U were sniffing about BEFORE he started to play well?

You've got your argument all mixed up.

comment by polloks (U2971)

posted on 18/7/11

darky if izzaguire was so good then why only 4 assists and 1 goal all season?

i would agree he is a good player and is better than Papac but why do you pretend to yourselves he is an amazing player?

he's good but like either of us get a good player we go over the top with how good they supposedly are

you see it all the time

Jelavic is amazing,Kayal is amazing,Davis,Izzaguire etc are amazing

the fact is they are good players

nothing more





posted on 18/7/11

i never said izzy was amazing i just said last season he was better than papac. his fellow professionals and sports writers agree.

posted on 18/7/11

you mean Papac with 3 league winners medals who's been to the UEFA cup final ? And Izzaguire has done wot exactly ?....a Scottish Cup medal you say ?

have you submitted yourself for drug testign son

posted on 18/7/11

3 league medals and a UEFA final?

Like Rab Douglas you mean?



You boys really are funny

posted on 18/7/11

Aye ah hear yeez need a keeper...you might huv tae do wi Rab

Whit a dhim-wit you are. A guy plays a couple of good games and yeez idolize him despite winning nothing of significance. Papac is 10 times the player of izzegawin or izzystayin....

We are the Champs. We feel your pain. Pyoor beelin so yees ur

posted on 18/7/11

Wanyama? Aye he's certainly no Kerkar eh?

or Healy

or Broadfoot

or mcCulloch

or Beattie

Now that's tap kwality eh?

posted on 18/7/11

you mean Papac with 3 league winners medals who's been to the UEFA cup final ? And Izzaguire has done wot exactly ?....a Scottish Cup medal you say ?


----------------------------------------------------------------------------

YES! that Papac, with those medals that wasn't voted Players' Player of the Year!

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

66 comments and not one vote!

I'll never get a job wi the News Of The World at this rate!

posted on 18/7/11

there ye go son...1 star...like yer team. Another accolade for yezz tae bang on aboot

posted on 18/7/11

Yey!!!

posted on 18/7/11

there ye go son...1 star...like yer team

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Our 1 gold star is deserved - as for your cheap 5 stars on your cheap shirts

posted on 18/7/11

ah ws wonderin how long it would take for the wee comfy blanket tae come oot...

Should you no be doin the house work or somethin luv ? Your opinion is as worthless as a runners up medal

comment by DC (U8199)

posted on 18/7/11

Cheap shirts? Whose is the ones made outta recycled plastic bottles?

comment by (U5278)

posted on 18/7/11

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 18/7/11

Papac and Izzy are two completely different players even though they both play Left back.

Papac is much more solid player and better defensively. Izzy is a lot better going forward.

Celtics defence was awful last season (even though they had the least goals conceded in the league) Celtic used attack as there form of defence. When we sat back against Celtic we lost. Most teams invinted Celtic on to them and when they did Izzy was a great player.

However as was said above when people had a go at Celtic and Izzy in particular he was a weak link.

For that reason alone I would take Papac everyday of the week.

Izzy won player of the year, as it's voted for earlier than it should be and it's easier to vote for attack minded players. He can't defend for toffee though.

posted on 18/7/11

was in febuary. after x-mas.
========================

The player himself said it was January.

He didn't start to play well UNTIL January going by what you said. I'm more inclined to believe that Man U had him watched for more than a few weeks.

posted on 18/7/11

DC76 - there is nothing wrong with recycling - we should all be doing more of it

Page 3 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment