Not the worst, pretty even, ish. But i'd prefer to have a stronger striker than a stronger CM
It's in my favour for sure but gives you Xaviesta which is hugely powerful. Veloso is ok behind them. Higuain will score goals.
The danger for you is injuries to either or both of them since your back up is weak at present.
I am tempted to do it if it were made a firm offer but it is a gamble on both sides since my defence remains weak.
That's fine mate. Let me know when you're ready.
enq
bale silva
=
ribery ivanovic
made that same enq yesterday
Sanchez + Puyol
=
Hulk + Ramos
Enq. at the moment, not sure if I'd go through with this, but just wanna see what options I've got at the moment
enq
higuain bale silva
=
ibra ribery ivanovic
ribery is a left winger mate
ibra > higuain
ribery > bale
i know that the difference between silva and ivanovic is big that's why you gain twice in the deal
how about if i add a bench player in the deal
i hate sanchez btw
so should i play messi on rw ???
i saw ribery playing on the left but not sure about messi and messi is a left footed player so
id need a replacement for schwein and i cant see one id replace him with from yr squad (who you would let go of)
I thought the whole point of injuries was to encourage transfers. I replaced him and it's been a game week since it also clearly says on the rules page once a player has been transferred his injury is void.
i can see why you'd think your offer is better but i think long term i prefer the other one
I don't agree with that tbh the main point of injuries is to encourage deals so I don't see anything wrong with it.
It's hardly manipulation, I didn't offload Ramos to intend to get him back and as I stated theres nothing in the rules to state otherwise.
We didn't 'attempt' to do it, I only just realised when you bought it up. I think most would prefer Kompany to Ramos atm anyway so I'd hardly do it intentionally.
Ok can just deal elsewhere to replace Ramos if need be.
i think ill stick with my players for the moment
I'd be interested in Silva but I rate Ramos higher, what would the offer be?
Not too convinced about Puyol's ratings.
Ramos + Coentrao = T.Silva + Marcelo?
Coentrao has been roating with Marcelo this season and Ramos > T.Silva since his move to PSG.
Puyol's not a weakness but I'd rather my CB combo, above is best I could do.
crap Thought I saw someone else do it My fault for not checking it out with you I suppose. Got De Jong to bring in instead then, least he's a DM...
Tevez is better then Higuain ....
I comfortably prefer Tevez, Higuain's more of a poacher and fortunate at times that he's playing for a top side.
Sign in if you want to comment
FPL 2 - Stoke City
Page 11 of 16
12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16
posted on 18/1/13
Not the worst, pretty even, ish. But i'd prefer to have a stronger striker than a stronger CM
posted on 18/1/13
It's in my favour for sure but gives you Xaviesta which is hugely powerful. Veloso is ok behind them. Higuain will score goals.
The danger for you is injuries to either or both of them since your back up is weak at present.
I am tempted to do it if it were made a firm offer but it is a gamble on both sides since my defence remains weak.
posted on 18/1/13
That's fine mate. Let me know when you're ready.
posted on 19/1/13
enq
bale silva
=
ribery ivanovic
posted on 19/1/13
made that same enq yesterday
posted on 19/1/13
Sanchez + Puyol
=
Hulk + Ramos
Enq. at the moment, not sure if I'd go through with this, but just wanna see what options I've got at the moment
posted on 19/1/13
enq
higuain bale silva
=
ibra ribery ivanovic
posted on 19/1/13
ribery is a left winger mate
ibra > higuain
ribery > bale
i know that the difference between silva and ivanovic is big that's why you gain twice in the deal
how about if i add a bench player in the deal
i hate sanchez btw
posted on 19/1/13
so should i play messi on rw ???
i saw ribery playing on the left but not sure about messi and messi is a left footed player so
posted on 19/1/13
id need a replacement for schwein and i cant see one id replace him with from yr squad (who you would let go of)
posted on 19/1/13
i prefer captains offer
posted on 19/1/13
I thought the whole point of injuries was to encourage transfers. I replaced him and it's been a game week since it also clearly says on the rules page once a player has been transferred his injury is void.
posted on 19/1/13
i can see why you'd think your offer is better but i think long term i prefer the other one
posted on 19/1/13
I don't agree with that tbh the main point of injuries is to encourage deals so I don't see anything wrong with it.
posted on 19/1/13
It's hardly manipulation, I didn't offload Ramos to intend to get him back and as I stated theres nothing in the rules to state otherwise.
posted on 19/1/13
We didn't 'attempt' to do it, I only just realised when you bought it up. I think most would prefer Kompany to Ramos atm anyway so I'd hardly do it intentionally.
posted on 19/1/13
So are you allowing it?
posted on 19/1/13
Ok can just deal elsewhere to replace Ramos if need be.
posted on 19/1/13
i think ill stick with my players for the moment
posted on 19/1/13
I'd be interested in Silva but I rate Ramos higher, what would the offer be?
posted on 19/1/13
Not too convinced about Puyol's ratings.
Ramos + Coentrao = T.Silva + Marcelo?
Coentrao has been roating with Marcelo this season and Ramos > T.Silva since his move to PSG.
posted on 19/1/13
Puyol's not a weakness but I'd rather my CB combo, above is best I could do.
posted on 19/1/13
crap Thought I saw someone else do it My fault for not checking it out with you I suppose. Got De Jong to bring in instead then, least he's a DM...
posted on 19/1/13
Tevez is better then Higuain ....
posted on 19/1/13
I comfortably prefer Tevez, Higuain's more of a poacher and fortunate at times that he's playing for a top side.
Page 11 of 16
12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16