Mata + Masch + Kompany + Hazard
for
Neymar + Yaya + Essien + Pique
-----------------------------
I'd argue I'm losing out three times here, I know you disagree but I still rate Mata higher than Neymar at the moment, Essien < Hazard and Pique < Kompany. And the difference between Yaya and Masch. is debatable, personally think Yaya adds more to your team than he would in mine, and Masch adds more to mine than he would yours.
Ramos, Alonso, Higuain
For
Piqué, Busquets, Aguero?
Oh yeah ok would have to be Yaya then as with Essien just losing out.
I rate them on par, Yaya rated more on his offensive abilities then defensive though.
Can't do anything with Essien I'm afraid.
Neymar + Piqué + Yaya for di Maria + Alonso + Ramos
Add Hig-Aguero and then would probs do that.
Prefer Chiellini really or would add that if you can add Cole-Clichy?
I'm losing out if the ST's aren't added ..
Bale for Neymar
-----
yes... I can deal on that
Any chance of including Lloris for Cesar? Nothing for you but big for me.
-----------------
sorry but Lloris is a very good keeper and a great back-up for Casillas.
no can do mate
Bale for Neymar is about perfect.
Can't add anyone else to be honest.
Nice one.
I agree - no harm in trying.
Cheers mate
Silva + Buffon + Falcao + Robben
for
Neymar + Pique + Aguero + Cesar
-------------
Personally, I feel I lose out on 3 (or 2, and CB's are even) and the gain (Neymar/Robben) is only slight.
If it were Nasri....
Pedro + de Rossi
for
Gordon + Bale + Essien
----
no sorry cant sell derossi
marchisio+x = essien+x
am looking for evans' replacement
Silva + Buffon + Arbeloa + Falcao
for
Pique + Lahm + Cesar + Aguero
-------
Silva = Pique
Arbeloa < Lahm
Buffon >> Cesar
Falcao > Aguero
I still feel I lose out too much there.
Any chance of loaning Caulker for 2 weeks?
-------------
yes you can
Not sure why I would do that, I'm losing out x3.
Not formally rejected but if I am to sell Iniesta I would be looking for improvement where I really need it. Suarez is fine for me.
Can use him in other deals though rather then losing out.
Can you answer my foreign bids please?
Bale + Aguero
for
Nasri + Falcao
Or
Bale + Essien + Aguero
for
Nasri + Falcao + Cabaye
Bale + Essien + Aguero + Cesar
for
Nasri + Falcao + Cabaye + Buffon?
Bale >> Nasri
Aguero =< Falcao
Essien > Cabaye
Cesar < Buffon
----------
I understand your views on Essien as i've seen them on other peoples pages. But we both know that he's never going to be as rated on here as he ever was.
I know its not the greatest gap between Falcao. But it is more considerable than you're saying. Aguero wouldn't be in the worlds top 5.
And it's also a huge goalkeeper improvement.
I feel that a CM of Cabaye + Essien wouldn't be rated at all on here.
RVP, Falcao, Ibra, Messi/Ronaldo (I know, I know, lol) as one level.
Then Aguero, Suarez, Benzema, Higuain, all in the second bracket.
Sign in if you want to comment
FPL 2 - Stoke City
Page 8 of 16
9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13
posted on 13/1/13
Mata + Masch + Kompany + Hazard
for
Neymar + Yaya + Essien + Pique
-----------------------------
I'd argue I'm losing out three times here, I know you disagree but I still rate Mata higher than Neymar at the moment, Essien < Hazard and Pique < Kompany. And the difference between Yaya and Masch. is debatable, personally think Yaya adds more to your team than he would in mine, and Masch adds more to mine than he would yours.
posted on 13/1/13
Ramos, Alonso, Higuain
For
Piqué, Busquets, Aguero?
posted on 13/1/13
Oh yeah ok would have to be Yaya then as with Essien just losing out.
posted on 13/1/13
I rate them on par, Yaya rated more on his offensive abilities then defensive though.
Can't do anything with Essien I'm afraid.
posted on 13/1/13
Neymar + Piqué + Yaya for di Maria + Alonso + Ramos
Add Hig-Aguero and then would probs do that.
posted on 13/1/13
Prefer Chiellini really or would add that if you can add Cole-Clichy?
posted on 13/1/13
I'm losing out if the ST's aren't added ..
posted on 14/1/13
Bale for Neymar
-----
yes... I can deal on that
posted on 14/1/13
???
posted on 14/1/13
Any chance of including Lloris for Cesar? Nothing for you but big for me.
-----------------
sorry but Lloris is a very good keeper and a great back-up for Casillas.
no can do mate
posted on 14/1/13
Bale for Neymar is about perfect.
Can't add anyone else to be honest.
posted on 14/1/13
Nice one.
I agree - no harm in trying.
Cheers mate
posted on 14/1/13
Silva + Buffon + Falcao + Robben
for
Neymar + Pique + Aguero + Cesar
-------------
Personally, I feel I lose out on 3 (or 2, and CB's are even) and the gain (Neymar/Robben) is only slight.
If it were Nasri....
posted on 14/1/13
Pedro + de Rossi
for
Gordon + Bale + Essien
----
no sorry cant sell derossi
marchisio+x = essien+x
am looking for evans' replacement
posted on 14/1/13
Silva + Buffon + Arbeloa + Falcao
for
Pique + Lahm + Cesar + Aguero
-------
Silva = Pique
Arbeloa < Lahm
Buffon >> Cesar
Falcao > Aguero
I still feel I lose out too much there.
posted on 14/1/13
Any chance of loaning Caulker for 2 weeks?
-------------
yes you can
posted on 14/1/13
Not sure why I would do that, I'm losing out x3.
posted on 14/1/13
Not formally rejected but if I am to sell Iniesta I would be looking for improvement where I really need it. Suarez is fine for me.
posted on 14/1/13
Can use him in other deals though rather then losing out.
Can you answer my foreign bids please?
posted on 14/1/13
Bale + Aguero
for
Nasri + Falcao
Or
Bale + Essien + Aguero
for
Nasri + Falcao + Cabaye
posted on 14/1/13
Bale + Essien + Aguero + Cesar
for
Nasri + Falcao + Cabaye + Buffon?
posted on 14/1/13
Bale >> Nasri
Aguero =< Falcao
Essien > Cabaye
Cesar < Buffon
----------
I understand your views on Essien as i've seen them on other peoples pages. But we both know that he's never going to be as rated on here as he ever was.
I know its not the greatest gap between Falcao. But it is more considerable than you're saying. Aguero wouldn't be in the worlds top 5.
posted on 14/1/13
And it's also a huge goalkeeper improvement.
posted on 14/1/13
I feel that a CM of Cabaye + Essien wouldn't be rated at all on here.
posted on 14/1/13
RVP, Falcao, Ibra, Messi/Ronaldo (I know, I know, lol) as one level.
Then Aguero, Suarez, Benzema, Higuain, all in the second bracket.
Page 8 of 16
9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13