or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 68 comments are related to an article called:

bargain players

Page 3 of 3

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 23/10/13

i just have an issue with those that sit at home scratching their áss, while i have to sit on 606 all day getting paid

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 23/10/13

On that subject though - on average what is your daily work/606 split?

posted on 23/10/13

im at work from 9 til 5 15, and i actually do about an hours work

posted on 23/10/13

there are plenty of bargain players out there who could be snapped up at a pittence.

Juan Quintero

-

Who?

Sorry, but there simply isn't an abundance of quality bargain buys out there. Some teams get lucky or do an exceptional bit of business on a surplus player, but rarely is a superstar bought for peanuts.

comment by Jay. (U16498)

posted on 23/10/13

Pretty similar to mine then 9-5:30/6...

The problem is when I actually do work, I work faster than everyone else, so they look bad. I'm slacking for the good of the team

posted on 23/10/13

comment by Long time reader, first time poster... (U9335)
posted 1 minute ago
there are plenty of bargain players out there who could be snapped up at a pittence.

Juan Quintero

-

Who?

Sorry, but there simply isn't an abundance of quality bargain buys out there. Some teams get lucky or do an exceptional bit of business on a surplus player, but rarely is a superstar bought for peanuts.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

dont assume everyone is as ignorant as you on players in europe, you'd never heard of Koke the other day, he's one of the best midfielders in europe, plenty of people had heard of Quintero and we were even linked with him, and yes he is a superstar who's been picked up for peanuts

posted on 23/10/13

comment by Dunc _ never eating digestives again (U11713) posted 12 minutes ago
im at work from 9 til 5 15, and i actually do about an hours work

===

45 minutes more than I do

posted on 23/10/13

Mex just because plenty of people have heard of a player and someone bought him doesn't detract from the fact that not many of the top players these days were bought for peanuts.

Buying a player who has shown potential in Portugal for big money is more of a risk than a bargain.

Buying Ozil for £12m was a bargain.

However, the top players don't tend to move for cheap.

Nobody was going to spend £35m on this guy. If he proves to be a good buy then he can be described as a bargain. Suggesting that a manager should be able to pick up top players on the cheap is unrealistic and the exception to the rule.

posted on 23/10/13

gundogan
kagawa

both signed by dortmund for a total of 6 million.

posted on 23/10/13

Dortmund built an entire squad with bargains, only Mkhitaryan, Aubameyang and Reus cost more than 10m

posted on 23/10/13

Getting Hummels from Bayern's youth was a great move as well.

posted on 23/10/13

I'm sorry, but my interpretation of the word bargain in footballing terms is buying a player for a fraction of what they are worth. In football if you buy a player for cheap who becomes a superstar it is lucky. Look at the 'potential' we have wasted money on in the past.

Few of those players signed by Dortmund would have commanded much higher fees had other clubs tried to sign them.

Dortmund got very lucky.

posted on 23/10/13

comment by Long time reader, first time poster... (U9335)
posted 49 seconds ago
I'm sorry, but my interpretation of the word bargain in footballing terms is buying a player for a fraction of what they are worth. In football if you buy a player for cheap who becomes a superstar it is lucky. Look at the 'potential' we have wasted money on in the past.

Few of those players signed by Dortmund would have commanded much higher fees had other clubs tried to sign them.

Dortmund got very lucky.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No they didn't.

You get lucky like that multiple times.

They had Sahin come through their ranks. And had a few good seasons and they knew he was going to leave, so they set about signing a replacement. Gundogan is essentially Sahin.

posted on 23/10/13

comment by Long time reader, first time poster... (U9335)
posted 1 minute ago
I'm sorry, but my interpretation of the word bargain in footballing terms is buying a player for a fraction of what they are worth. In football if you buy a player for cheap who becomes a superstar it is lucky. Look at the 'potential' we have wasted money on in the past.

Few of those players signed by Dortmund would have commanded much higher fees had other clubs tried to sign them.

Dortmund got very lucky.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

there's no luck involved in what Dortmund have done, it has come from fantastic coaching, scouting and playing a system to suit the players, which is what we should be doing, i think we lack a philosophy these days at united, we seem to have a mish mash of formations, which in tern leads to poor quality of football, and a squad full of players who aren;t good enough at the very highest level, we have some exceptions of course

posted on 23/10/13

i think we lack a philosophy these days at united, we seem to have a mish mash of formations.

-

100% agree. There's no identity at the club anymore. We seem to buy players suited to different formations and we have totally digressed from our traditional style of the past 25 years. Was probably to be expected with SAF leaving, but I'd argue that even for the past 3 or 4 years we have had the same issue.

No fluency. Too cautious. We even lack pace these days and it seems to take an age to get the ball for DF to ATT.

posted on 23/10/13

No fluency. Too cautious. We even lack pace these days and it seems to take an age to get the ball for DF to ATT.

---

That's more with the evolution of tactics in football. Teams tend to play with 3 men in midfield now, and it's difficult to quickly break through teams who eliminate that much space on the pitch. So you have to slow it down and drag them around the pitch more.

Obviously playing with a high tempo is still entirely possible, but it's more intertwined into the slow build up play. With teams picking their moments to change up the pace when it benefits them more. Or using countering play to much more effect.

Having insane off the ball movement ala Bayern is also key to playing quicker. Utd - among more or less every other team - don't have the players to consistently use a high tempo effectively.

posted on 23/10/13

Teams tend to play with 3 men in midfield now, and it's difficult to quickly break through teams who eliminate that much space on the pitch.

-

Surely why we used to spread the ball wide quickly to bypass narrow 3 man midfields?

Teams were still using 3 man midfields in 2007/8, but that didn't stop us.

I think it's more to do with the players than the system.

posted on 23/10/13

It's probably been mentioned but Porto don't make huge profits on these players. They are mainly third party owned and hardly owned by Porto.

Page 3 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment