or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 139 comments are related to an article called:

Mata Is Criminally Overrated

Page 3 of 6

comment by Samir (U2630)

posted on 27/1/14

Dubbed, Darren does have a point to be fair.

Even if you think people are ''criminally overrating'' him, so what?

Every individual is entitled to their opinion.

posted on 27/1/14

Criminally overrating is unfair.
No one is comparing him to the Messi's and Ronaldo's of this world.
He is what he is. A very good player. His hype is justified.
An example of someone getting criminally overrated would be Andros Townsend.

posted on 27/1/14

Ozil > Silva > Cazorla > Mata

When on form of course. Tbf Mata has been much more consistent than Silva and Santi.

posted on 27/1/14

Darren- this is surely worse than Adam vs Modric?

http://www.ja606.co.uk/articles/viewArticle/18147

posted on 27/1/14

"Even if you think people are ''criminally overrating'' him, so what?

Every individual is entitled to their opinion."

I'm sharing my opinion. No different from Darren or any of the other guys.

posted on 27/1/14

Definately been Chelseas best player over the past 2 seasons, hence the club player of the year awards he's won.

If you asked any to rank Ozil, Mata, Carzola, Silva, you'll get plenty of different opinions and orders.

posted on 27/1/14

its not a fair comparison because the PL is easy to get assists and goals in.

Also Jose liked Ozil at Madrid but dislikes Mata (as a player).

Therefore if you consider Jose's opinion,

ozil > mata.

PS Silva is terrible and not fit to lace either's boots.

posted on 27/1/14

The same way mata is over rated as Suarez? Dubbed really has no clue on players.

posted on 27/1/14

"PS Silva is terrible and not fit to lace either's boots."

You know nothing about football.


posted on 27/1/14

Arsenal fans are so desperate to try and justify Ozil's price tag He started off looking a class act but after his first month or two has gone off the boil. Definitely not a better player that Mata

I wonder how many off Ozil's assists were 5 yard passes to Ronaldo who then smashed it in the top corner?

posted on 27/1/14

No one has read my link.

posted on 27/1/14

comment by 50Mill (U1147)
posted 2 minutes ago
The same way mata is over rated as Suarez? Dubbed really has no clue on players.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dubbed fam he's calling you out!

posted on 27/1/14

It's ridiculous Marcelino

posted on 27/1/14

comment by Bennyville (U8058)




posted 5 minutes ago



"PS Silva is terrible and not fit to lace either's boots."

You know nothing about football.


You're telling me, I hate football.

posted on 27/1/14

Silva/Ozil > Santi > Mata

My opinion is fact.

posted on 27/1/14

Arsenal fans are so desperate to try and justify Ozil's price tag
---------------------------------

Arsenal paid top price for a top class player.

Tottenham paid £30m for Lamela and £26m for Loldado,

Goodbye.

posted on 27/1/14

comment by Serial WUManiser - The Chosen One (U1410)
posted 3 minutes ago
Arsenal fans are so desperate to try and justify Ozil's price tag
---------------------------------

Arsenal paid top price for a top class player.

Tottenham paid £30m for Lamela and £26m for Loldado,

Goodbye.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The difference is spurs fans don't have the need to justify their price tags. We overpaid for Soldado, whilst Lamela is one for the future who will probably be an excellent player.


If we're talking about value for money, Eriksen >>> Ozil

posted on 27/1/14

"If we're talking about value for money, Eriksen >>> Ozil"
===

this again?

Eriksen wouldn't even make our bench.

posted on 27/1/14

Lamela is one for the future who will probably be an excellent player.
-------------------------------------

Yep, for another club when you sell him on.

Spurs fans on their high horse discussing value for money....

posted on 27/1/14

Actually, Mata would start for Arsenal in my opinion. He is better than Walcott. Creates more, good performer, premier league experience, top player, good value for money.

It's not as if Ozil is playing in a different league to him, both players are very similar in quality, although, the differences between the 2 get cancelled out eventually.

posted on 27/1/14

I'm an unbiased fan..

Mata > Ozil > Cazorla > Silva > Everyone else

posted on 27/1/14

mata was a big player for chelsea. He seemed to love scoring against man utd, 3 goals I remember one at OT squeezed it in off post, the two games man utd scored 3 at stamford bridge he scored one from a volley in box as well as one from a freekick. Torres never scared me when he was playing it was mata who was hard to stop.

comment by Samir (U2630)

posted on 27/1/14

''I'm sharing my opinion. No different from Darren or any of the other guys.''

Of course. But sometimes you present your opinion like it's a fact and that if anyone thinks otherwise, it's ''delusional'' or ''incorrect''. There can't be an ''incorrect'' opinion. Because it's all subjective.

And to the user who said Silva is terrible, you are either wumming or you don't watch football.

''Arsenal fans are so desperate to try and justify Ozil's price tag''

He's been here for 5 months. 5 months. He is not going to justify his price tag in 5 months. No-one does. Over the course of the next few years in terms of how he develops as a Premier League player will show whether the price tag is justified or not (it is IMO).

Either way, to get quality, you have to pay premium prices and that's what we've done. We made a calculated risk, something your mob don't understand it seems

posted on 27/1/14

Hafi has spoken. Discussion over.

posted on 27/1/14

Hafi is home from school.

Page 3 of 6

Sign in if you want to comment