or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 119 comments are related to an article called:

Squad values

Page 1 of 5

posted on 1/3/14

Szczesny 14m (20m)
Fabianski 5m
Sagna 9m
Mertesacker 11m
Koscielny 26m
Gibbs 18m
Vermaelen 10m
Monreal 8m
Jenkinson 4m
Wilshere 20m (35m)
Ramsey 25m (40m)
Flamini 6m
Arteta 5m
Ozil 40m
Cazorla 18m
Rosicky 6m
Zelalem 6m (50m)
Gnabry 6m (25m)
Oxlade-Chamberlain 16m (40m)
Walcott 30m
Podolski 10m
Giroud 16m
Sanogo 4m (18m)
Bendtner 6m


Why do people always over-rate their own players? (I probably have as well tbf)

posted on 1/3/14

Szczesny 18m (30m)
Fabianski 5m
Sagna 5m
Mertesacker 20m
Koscielny 25m
Gibbs 15m
Vermaelen 10m
Monreal 10m
Jenkinson 4m
Wilshere 20m
Ramsey 25m
Flamini 5m
Arteta 4m
Ozil 40m
Cazorla 20m
Rosicky 5m
Zelalem 5m
Gnabry 7m
Oxlade-Chamberlain 16m
Walcott 30m
Podolski 10m
Giroud 15m
Sanogo 4m
Bendtner 4m

posted on 1/3/14

absolutely right

posted on 1/3/14

some of these figures tho





posted on 1/3/14

You have to remember that you are worth what someone is willing to pay for you. That is what I based my numbers on.

posted on 1/3/14

You have to remember that you are worth what someone is willing to pay for you. That is what I based my numbers on.
_____
Fabianski 5m
Bendtner 4m

you couldnt give them away

posted on 1/3/14

I've seen it all now.....

8bit this must be a joke mate.

Your either a 9 year old or a toolbit.

posted on 1/3/14

IMO Some of the op's figures are too high, some too low, mine ;

the ones in brackets are potential values

Szczesny 18m (30m)
Fabianski 7m
Sagna 8m (great player but getting on, as evidenced by his injury woes)
Mertesacker 18m
Koscielny 23m (28m)
Gibbs 14m
Vermaelen 10m
Monreal 8m
Jenkinson 6m (12m)
Wilshere 25m (40m)
Ramsey 30m (45m)
Flamini 7m
Arteta 5m
Ozil 40m
Cazorla 16m
Rosicky 8m
Zelalem 4m (far too early to say)
Gnabry 10m (35m)
Oxlade-Chamberlain 22m (40m)
Walcott 30m
Podolski 14m
Giroud 18m
Sanogo 4m (22m)
Bendtner 8m

These prices are of course not taking into account their current contract situation (ie Sagna)

posted on 1/3/14

What has Zalalem done to be worth 6 million? He's proved nothing. He's all potential at the moment and there have been players who have been better at his age that have ended up shyyt.

posted on 1/3/14

8bit



I thought you were sensible.

You do realise Fabianski is Free. Players over 30 are hardly worth anything and those without first team experience are worth very little.

Rosicky £8m? Arteta £5m? Sagna is Free not £15m. The club would bite your hands off.

posted on 1/3/14

Oh my days

posted on 1/3/14

Wow

posted on 1/3/14

Ollie asks why people overrate their own players just after putting Zelalem at £50m

posted on 1/3/14

I love these articles.

comment by (U18814)

posted on 1/3/14

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 1/3/14

Wenger hasn't always got the best deals when selling players. I know he's made huge profits on alot of his signings but 2 of the best players to play under him were sold for less then they should have. Henry and Fabregas.

Fabregas was sold for 35m not long after torres was sold for 50. It was a joke.

And Henry was sold for less than 20m at a time when he was still in the top 5 players in the world. If someone like ibrahimovic was injured and was being sold there is no way PSG would sell him for less than 20m so why did we with Henry?

posted on 1/3/14



The Zelalam one was the best

posted on 1/3/14

i'd like the rosicky ones & flamini


too much football manager bs with these evaluations


posted on 1/3/14

FrimBoue, was his contract nearing the end I can't remember?

He was 30 and wanted to leave as well.

That said, I was a little stunned he only went for £16m.

Especially as Spurs paid more for Darren Bent.

posted on 1/3/14

Why would anyone pay £9m for Flamini when they could just wait and sign him for free?

posted on 1/3/14

comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 44 seconds ago
FrimBoue, was his contract nearing the end I can't remember?

He was 30 and wanted to leave as well.

That said, I was a little stunned he only went for £16m.

Especially as Spurs paid more for Darren Bent.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He signed a new contract the year before he left. We had offers of £30M+ for him and rejected them. In hindsight it was a blunder because he did fack all in his last season.

posted on 1/3/14

Ahh ok, Bats.

I'm pretty sure it was revealed you'd turned down a £50m bid from Barca the year before.

I also heard you'd turned down a £30m bid for Viera the year before you sold him for £12m - and he did fack all in his final season as well.

That's a potential loss of £52m!

For an accountant like Wenger that must have stung.

posted on 1/3/14

He's learned from those errors to be fair. These days you just have to make a bid with a random figure and Wenger sells instantly

posted on 1/3/14

posted on 1/3/14

8 bit you've under rated Gnabry here. He's worth double figures right now. Sanogo potential value is also very little, he'll be worth well into 50mill+. There's something about him that looks like a young Anelka in a way no one knew who he is but turns out to be top top class.

Ramsey at his peak will be worth as much Bale was bought for, same with Wilshere. The rest I agree.

Page 1 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment