He has scored 5 so far this season, and 3 of his goals were scored whilst thrashing a poor Sunderland side. Which is an indication that he is not an inconsistent striker
==========
The higher rated Berahino has scored in the same number of games as Kone, but scored less and hasn't assisted.
Berahino's goals have come against the same Sunderland team (where he couldn't even score a hat trick) and the even worse Villa side.

So - using the criteria you claimed to use.... Justify that!

Sterling as frustrating as he can be should be higher than 4/10. More like 6.

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 6 minutes ago
Loriks criteria:
How would you rate these Premier League strikers and forwards based on their current form this season, so far ?
========
Loriks later justification:
'I am not sure he can keep it up, that's what I am saying'

Hardly basing it on current form!


Loriks criteria:
My rating is based on the contributions (i.e. assists and goals),
======
Loriks justification:
I am not convinced by Kone despite having a better scoring records so far



Sorry, but you are having a mare.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think it's just you that can't grasp a simple logic. Don't know how many more time I have to repeat this to you, before you get it. It's ok, you can form an opinion, if you take into consideration Kone's consistency this season

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 3 minutes ago
He has scored 5 so far this season, and 3 of his goals were scored whilst thrashing a poor Sunderland side. Which is an indication that he is not an inconsistent striker
==========
The higher rated Berahino has scored in the same number of games as Kone, but scored less and hasn't assisted.
Berahino's goals have come against the same Sunderland team (where he couldn't even score a hat trick) and the even worse Villa side.

So - using the criteria you claimed to use.... Justify that!
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Look it's not just scoring against Sunderland and also the way the game panned out for Everton in that match.

I think it's just you that can't grasp a simple logic.
=========
My rating is based on the contributions (ie assists and goals)

MY RATING IS BASED ON ASSISTS AND GOALS

Where did you criteria once say you are basing it on consistancy?
And why is Berahino rated ahead Kone?

It is your own criteria and you cannot even understand it

Look it's not just scoring against Sunderland and also the way the game panned out for Everton in that match.
=========
Even if he only scored once in that game he would still have the same number of goals as Berahino, plus 3 more assists than the assist-less Albion striker.
Your criteria clearly states you are basing it on goals and assists this season - not consistancy, not what they may do in the future.

You have had a mare here.

Plus the game panned out that way largely to the very impressive, man of the match performance of Kone.

comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 6 minutes ago
Harry Kane scored a hattrick in a thrashing of a poor Bournemouth side.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Daza - Kane has scored 10 goals in all competition, also he overall contribution to his team is impressive

Also Rooney is rated too high

comment by Lorik ⚽ (U16190)
posted 17 minutes ago
comment by H (U9129)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Lorik ⚽ (U16190)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by What a hit son! What a hit. (U18710)
posted 7 minutes ago
Coutinho?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He is a midfielder, isn"t he ? Good player though
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So are half your list
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think this link will help you out with players positions ?

http://www.premierleague.com/en-gb/players/ea-sports-player-performance-index.html?paramPosition=MIDFIELDER
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wijnaldum who is on your list is on that link you provided

Maybe you should have used it

comment by Spurtle2 (U1608)
posted 26 seconds ago
Also Rooney is rated too high


----------------------------------------------------------------------
No , he slightly better than Falcao

But he has 8 premier league goals. That's one more than Giroud, who didn't score a hattrick against a shiiiiit Bournemouth side, and has actually scored in seven separate games.

Whether it's by your orignial criteria or the revised one in terms of consistency, in which Giroud should then be higher, it's a bit of a mess, mate.

Maybe you should have thought more about the criteria you decided on to judge these strikers, Lorik.
If you cannot be consistent in following the criteria then how is anyone else expected to follow?

comment by Darren The King Fletcher (U10026)
posted 20 seconds ago
But he has 8 premier league goals. That's one more than Giroud, who didn't score a hattrick against a shiiiiit Bournemouth side, and has actually scored in seven separate games.

Whether it's by your orignial criteria or the revised one in terms of consistency, in which Giroud should then be higher, it's a bit of a mess, mate.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
I said 10 in all competition mate, didn't I ?

Is it by design or by mistake, I let you be the judge

I would like to think that I have been consistent in my rating whilst using my criteria

Why judge pl performance on all competitions? Not all teams play in Europe.

I would like to think that I have been consistent in my rating whilst using my criteria

===========

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 2 minutes ago
Maybe you should have thought more about the criteria you decided on to judge these strikers, Lorik.
If you cannot be consistent in following the criteria then how is anyone else expected to follow?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I am consistent mate. It's just that you refuse to accept the consistency using my criteria

I am consistent mate. It's just that you refuse to accept the consistency using my criteria
=====
But your criteria is stated as being assists and goals, yet you have players with more assists and goals below players with less.

My rating is based on the contributions (i.e. assists and goals), that each of these strikers/forwards have made for their respective teams.
===========
So the list should be in order of who has the most goals and assists. End of story.

You are forgeting the third and the crucial element I mentioned, their overall contribution to their team

You are forgeting the third and the crucial element I mentioned, their overall contribution to their team
========
Nope - you clearly stated that by contribution you meant goals and assists.
"My rating is based on the contributions (i.e. assists and goals), that each of these strikers/forwards have made for their respective teams."

My rating is based on the contributions (i.e. assists and goals), that each of these strikers/forwards have made for their respective teams.:

My rating is based on the contributions (i.e. assists and goals), that each of these strikers/forwards have made for their respective teams.:

Yes, contributions and then followed by i.e. goals and assists