or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 56 comments are related to an article called:

Pogba at 89 million or Stones at 48 million

Page 1 of 3

posted on 9/8/16

Who's the OP? Why does he keep polluting the United board ?

posted on 9/8/16

It's a better question to ask in five years time really. Value is different to different clubs too, you needed A midfielder and we needed a defender.

posted on 9/8/16

Trc that's mean

posted on 9/8/16

What Melton said

posted on 9/8/16

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Bruno (U1664)

posted on 9/8/16

comment by The_Red_Cognoscente (U9741)
posted 2 minutes ago
Who's the OP? Why does he keep polluting the United board ?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Juan Matador

comment by Superb (U6486)

posted on 9/8/16

Kante for only £30 million is better value than both put together

posted on 9/8/16

Super, kante is not in this article,feel free to make your own.

posted on 9/8/16

comment by Superb (U6486)
posted 57 seconds ago
Kante for only £30 million is better value than both put together
-----------------------------------
apart from the fact Kante cost more than £30m

posted on 9/8/16

Melton, do you think it's likely that Stones will go into the starting 11 for the weekend?

posted on 9/8/16

Kante is bald and cannot change his hairstyle to include one of our sponsors each week.

He would be a waste of £30m.

posted on 9/8/16

comment by meltonblue (U10617)
posted 6 minutes ago
It's a better question to ask in five years time really. Value is different to different clubs too, you needed A midfielder and we needed a defender.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
why did you sign stones then Melts

posted on 9/8/16

I believe pogba has had a luxury of playing alongside pirlo,marchisio and vidal etc who have done most his work for him in a 1 team league where nobody else can win the league so has hardly done much to justify the fee.

But Stone has literally done nothing and is already 22 and all I see is mistakes...football has gone crazy

posted on 9/8/16

Stones.

He'll learn so much under Pep and will be a much better defender for it.

United let Pogba go for free and had to pay a fortune to get him back so they've already lost.

posted on 9/8/16

48m for a lad who isnt even good enough for the england team? And that england team are onenof the worst we have ever had? That money is just insane to me. As bad a buy as sterling.

Pogba buy is awful too. He is a good cm but he is replaceable. For that money you would want to buy a difference maker. Someone like a messi, a zidane or a maradonna. Someone who can do stuff that nobody else in the world can do. An irreplacable and indispinsible player. To pay 90m for a guy who is just a cog in the wheel is insane.

posted on 9/8/16

comment by meltonblue (U10617)
posted 22 minutes ago
It's a better question to ask in five years time really. Value is different to different clubs too, you needed A midfielder and we needed a defender.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agree

posted on 9/8/16

For that money you would want to buy a difference maker.

-

He is.

posted on 9/8/16

I love the fact that just because Pogba won a few things playing for the only team that could win anything in an extremely slow Italian league, next to other good players. utd fans are bugging him up to be the best thing ever!

the best manager you've ever had facked him off because he didn't rate him. he had a poor euros!

is he a good player, with potential? undoubtedly yes but he's not a great player yet and could very well go the same way as DI Maria and Falcao!

comment by Ron (U1646)

posted on 9/8/16

Football clubs are businesses and Pogba was arguably the most talked about player in world football going to early cup, he will sell lots of merchandise and attract fans, ignoring his ability on the pitch.

I don't even think stones would get into city team based on ability, good prospect and cover for injuries.

posted on 9/8/16

Theres gona be some many people eating their words at the end of the season, Pogba is just pure class, if he plays that number 10 role for us he will score at least 15 goals in his first season and will assist plenty, the only fear i have is that Mou will stick with Rooney

posted on 9/8/16

comment by The Lambeau Leap (U21050)
posted 5 minutes ago
For that money you would want to buy a difference maker.

-

He is.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He really isnt. He is a box to box midfielder of which there are dozens of similar ones in the world. you could replace him with many other players with minimal impact either way. With messi, zidane, maradonna players that was never the case. Thats who this sort of money should be spent on.

Either way i doubt the money matters to united, as rich as they are. Just more wasted money in football. I am sure fans earning 20k a year will idolise pogbas replaceable talents whilst they pay his 300k a week wages

comment by Ron (U1646)

posted on 9/8/16

World cup.

posted on 9/8/16

Pogbs easily.

posted on 9/8/16

comment by RedDevil7 - Mourinho - THE UNITED ONE (U5029)
posted 16 seconds ago
Theres gona be some many people eating their words at the end of the season, Pogba is just pure class, if he plays that number 10 role for us he will score at least 15 goals in his first season and will assist plenty, the only fear i have is that Mou will stick with Rooney
----------------------------------------------------------------------
bookmarked. I believe toure only ever scored more than 15 goals one year and he took pens and free kicks. good luck pogba.

posted on 9/8/16

Pogba was juves worst cm for much of his time there. He now slots into a much much worse team and midfield.

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment