or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 76 comments are related to an article called:

New era in football

Page 1 of 4

posted on 3/3/18

Gianni Infantino says: "As of today, Video Assistant Refereeing is part of football."

Infantino: "We came to the conclusion that VAR was good for football, was good for refereeing. It brings more fairness."

Infantino: "We are living in a digital age [...] We cannot be oblivious to technological demand."

posted on 3/3/18

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 3/3/18

The ensuing carnage will be fun

posted on 3/3/18

FAW chief executive Jonathan Ford hails a "very historical meeting".

FA CEO Martin Glenn adds: "We all agreed there's still work to do."

IFA CEO Patrick Nelson says: "Of the 132 Annual General Meetings, this would no doubt be in the top 10 or so."

The FA are all on board with it, can see it coming into place after next season. Finally the likes of Dean, Atkinson and Anthony Taylor and the other useless refs won't be able to show themselves up again.

posted on 3/3/18

Ashame it wasn’t at the 86 World Cup.

posted on 3/3/18

comment by Edward Elizabeth Hitler. (U14393)
posted 7 minutes ago
Ashame it wasn’t at the 86 World Cup.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Or indeed 66

comment by Shugs (U14253)

posted on 3/3/18

Hate it personally... Its been awful so far

Nothing should be in the laws of the game that can't be enforced at every level... And this can't

posted on 3/3/18

I'm yet to be convinced by it. Decisions seem to take too long. Having said that, we might get used to it taking the amount of time it does.

posted on 3/3/18

The main issues with VAR so far have been the awful refs who don't understand the rules and can't make simple decisions even after 2 minutes of replays.

posted on 3/3/18

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 1 minute ago
I'm yet to be convinced by it. Decisions seem to take too long. Having said that, we might get used to it taking the amount of time it does.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
other countries are coping fine with it, and that's because they eventually got used to it. Just like we will in England.

posted on 3/3/18

Any time taken by VAR needs to be added on at the end of each half, that's the stupidest thing that's happened so far

posted on 3/3/18

comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 3 minutes ago
I'm yet to be convinced by it. Decisions seem to take too long. Having said that, we might get used to it taking the amount of time it does.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Maybe as the officials get used to it the amount of time to make decisions will naturally reduce.

posted on 3/3/18

and like I said, we need a proper training programme in place to get the officials used to it and stop wasting time in coming to a decision. That's what the other countries have done.

posted on 3/3/18

comment by Big Shaq (U11781)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Life is short. Make the most of it. (U9094)
posted 1 minute ago
I'm yet to be convinced by it. Decisions seem to take too long. Having said that, we might get used to it taking the amount of time it does.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
other countries are coping fine with it, and that's because they eventually got used to it. Just like we will in England.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's still a pain in the @ss in MLS. Still takes minutes to make decisions

posted on 3/3/18

I can see the arguments for it, and I can see why it's been resisted for so long. I think next season is too soon for use in the PL, because, as Arab says, the training for referees needs to be comprehensive.

comment by AlexTia (U7067)

posted on 3/3/18

And there goes any controversy that made football great. What next , 11 robots instead of humans?

posted on 3/3/18

Infantino puts his faith in Pierluigi Collina to make sure referees are ready: "He's a workaholic; he's a working maniac."

who better to train the officials than one of the greatest refs seen in the game? Another good decision from Gianni.

posted on 3/3/18

If after 30 seconds it's not an obvious error then the ref's decision should stand IMO.

If the technology doesn't allow you to make a decision in this timeframe then we need better tech before we can use it.

For factual decisions (offside, part of the field incident happened etc) then I'd leave that to the VAR but for the ones where interpretation is involved I'd rather the ref have access to an instant replay so as to maintain consistency during any one game at least in how it's reffed. Can't have VAR saying red when the ref all through the game has been erring on the side of yellows.

posted on 3/3/18

Football is always evolving. In the past some of the things introduced in the game which were opposed by some include a referee, linesmen, penalties, crossbar and nets, yellow and red cards, substitutions, injury time, goal line technology etc. VAR is just the latest change to be opposed. In a few years time it will be part and parcel of the game at the top level.

posted on 3/3/18

IFAB technical director David Elleray confirms competition organisers will be allowed to show VAR incidents on a the big screen (as they are in the trials if they choose to do so). But he rules out a pick-and-mix approach to incidents covered under VAR. It's all or nothing.

posted on 3/3/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by Kobra (U19849)

posted on 3/3/18

Worse thing to happen in football.

This chit destroyed cricket

posted on 3/3/18

The concept of cricket destroyed cricket

posted on 3/3/18

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

comment by MBL. (U6305)

posted on 3/3/18

comment by Big Shaq (U11781)
posted 50 minutes ago
Infantino puts his faith in Pierluigi Collina to make sure referees are ready: "He's a workaholic; he's a working maniac."

who better to train the officials than one of the greatest refs seen in the game? Another good decision from Gianni.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Can’t disagree with that.

Page 1 of 4

Sign in if you want to comment