Think jury is still out on Pogba.

comment by KLS - I like it rough and I like it fast, I wish that 4skin would park his 6 inch Donkey in my ass (U1695)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneReds (U1721)
posted 59 seconds ago
Can I ask how many votes Pogba needs until he's added to the list?

Thanks.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He gets my vote but the op would rather take everyone out the argument, rather than add him in.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pogba isn’t halfway through his contract, let’s judge him when we get shot.

Also he’s been a far better player than anyone on the current list. Has he justified 89m yet no? But does that make him a “flop”? No

comment by dangerdog (U20986)
posted 1 second ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Now you're back tracking trying to justify your stupid comment
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No it's a consistent stance.

You have to factor in how stupid you are of course.

Remember when I said that you're so stupid I'm surprised that you haven't killed yourself by accident?

Your reply? Don't mock suicide.

You're good value though.

comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 3 minutes ago

LQ would presumably have branded Gareth Bale a flop at Spurs.

How did that turn out?

Oh.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
That would be a fair comparison had Spurs paid 90m for Bale
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You will have to forgive winston he’s an insufferably tedious pedant and can’t get simple things like that correct.

Bale went for 90 million because of his performances to Real Madrid there’s no way Pogba at juventus he approached bales level as a player.

Another stupid comment from winston.

"That would be a fair comparison had Spurs paid 90m for Bale"

So a player can only be a flop if signed for a large amount of money?

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by dangerdog (U20986)
posted 1 second ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Now you're back tracking trying to justify your stupid comment
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No it's a consistent stance.

You have to factor in how stupid you are of course.

Remember when I said that you're so stupid I'm surprised that you haven't killed yourself by accident?

Your reply? Don't mock suicide.

You're good value though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Its not a consistent stance at all. You blatantly said that he would go for £65m and the you realised what a stupid comment that was and start bringing in your own rules i.e. the Kroos vs VVD argument

Fecking idiot

"Bale went for 90 million because of his performances to Real Madrid there’s no way Pogba at juventus he approached bales level as a player."

What's that sound?

Oh, don't worry... it's just the point flying way above LQ's head.

Pogba has had 2 seasons, that is plenty of time to be judged.

Plenty were happy to discuss Ibrahimovic's contribution and he's played less in 2 seasons.

Pogba 100% is undoubtedly the biggest flop the Premier League has ever seen. Only he can change that now.

comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 40 seconds ago
comment by KLS - I like it rough and I like it fast, I wish that 4skin would park his 6 inch Donkey in my ass (U1695)
posted 29 seconds ago
comment by There'sOnlyOneReds (U1721)
posted 59 seconds ago
Can I ask how many votes Pogba needs until he's added to the list?

Thanks.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He gets my vote but the op would rather take everyone out the argument, rather than add him in.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pogba isn’t halfway through his contract, let’s judge him when we get shot.

Also he’s been a far better player than anyone on the current list. Has he justified 89m yet no? But does that make him a “flop”? No
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You’ve moved the goal posts again.

First it was you weren’t including players still at they’re clubs, yet Shaw was a good shout.

Bravo & Mangala both still at the clubs they signed for yet still in.

Now it’s players who are halfway through contracts.

The simple fact that Pogba left Utd for free because united’s Greatest ever manager didn’t rate him, then was signed back for £90,000,000 and has been garbage puts him on the list.

Phakt

comment by dangerdog (U20986)
posted 51 seconds ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by dangerdog (U20986)
posted 1 second ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Now you're back tracking trying to justify your stupid comment
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No it's a consistent stance.

You have to factor in how stupid you are of course.

Remember when I said that you're so stupid I'm surprised that you haven't killed yourself by accident?

Your reply? Don't mock suicide.

You're good value though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Its not a consistent stance at all. You blatantly said that he would go for £65m and the you realised what a stupid comment that was and start bringing in your own rules i.e. the Kroos vs VVD argument

Fecking idiot
----------------------------------------------------------------------



Yes it is a consistent stance. All the way through. I believe that a transfer would be possible at around those amounts. See, I'm doing it now.

Have a nap, read a book and sort yourself out kid.

comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 47 seconds ago

"That would be a fair comparison had Spurs paid 90m for Bale"

So a player can only be a flop if signed for a large amount of money?
--------------------------------------------------------------------
No but they are certainly a bigger flop if they arrive having been signed for a large amount of money because the expectations are higher.

This wasn't the case for Bale at Spurs and also he was a young lad not a grown man who had played in a CL final and won everything on offer in Italy.

Literally only United fans argue that Pogba isnt a flop. Everyone else is happy to call it as they see it.

Dangermutt reading a book..........

Make sure it’s got plenty of pictures.

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 56 seconds ago
comment by dangerdog (U20986)
posted 51 seconds ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by dangerdog (U20986)
posted 1 second ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 1 minute ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Now you're back tracking trying to justify your stupid comment
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No it's a consistent stance.

You have to factor in how stupid you are of course.

Remember when I said that you're so stupid I'm surprised that you haven't killed yourself by accident?

Your reply? Don't mock suicide.

You're good value though.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Its not a consistent stance at all. You blatantly said that he would go for £65m and the you realised what a stupid comment that was and start bringing in your own rules i.e. the Kroos vs VVD argument

Fecking idiot
----------------------------------------------------------------------



Yes it is a consistent stance. All the way through. I believe that a transfer would be possible at around those amounts. See, I'm doing it now.

Have a nap, read a book and sort yourself out kid.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Zidane for £65m and VVD for £75m, what a delusional muppet

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 5 minutes ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So here’s the list of players who sold for more than 65m

Neymar £198m
Mbappe £125m
Coutinho £105m
Dembele £98m
Pogba £89m
Bale £83m
Ronaldo £80m
Higuan £75
Vvd £75m
Lukaku £75m
Suarez £75m
James £69m
Bakambu £66m

So zidane would not be worth more than any of that lot right?

comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 4 seconds ago
comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 5 minutes ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So here’s the list of players who sold for more than 65m

Neymar £198m
Mbappe £125m
Coutinho £105m
Dembele £98m
Pogba £89m
Bale £83m
Ronaldo £80m
Higuan £75
Vvd £75m
Lukaku £75m
Suarez £75m
James £69m
Bakambu £66m

So zidane would not be worth more than any of that lot right?

----------------------------------------------------------------------
watch hoody now bring up his own rules in to counter what an idiot he is

Dangerdong & Winston on the same thread?!? this could take a while.....


To answer the OP, Pogba obviously.

comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 18 seconds ago

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 5 minutes ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So here’s the list of players who sold for more than 65m

Neymar £198m
Mbappe £125m
Coutinho £105m
Dembele £98m
Pogba £89m
Bale £83m
Ronaldo £80m
Higuan £75
Vvd £75m
Lukaku £75m
Suarez £75m
James £69m
Bakambu £66m

So zidane would not be worth more than any of that lot right?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Depends who's buying and how long he has on his contract and what age he is.

If he was going to PSG or the Prem he's going to cost a lot more than 65m, if he's going to Germany or Italy then 65m is about right

Fellaini £27m

comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 18 seconds ago

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 5 minutes ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So here’s the list of players who sold for more than 65m

Neymar £198m
Mbappe £125m
Coutinho £105m
Dembele £98m
Pogba £89m
Bale £83m
Ronaldo £80m
Higuan £75
Vvd £75m
Lukaku £75m
Suarez £75m
James £69m
Bakambu £66m

So zidane would not be worth more than any of that lot right?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Depends who's buying and how long he has on his contract and what age he is.

If he was going to PSG or the Prem he's going to cost a lot more than 65m, if he's going to Germany or Italy then 65m is about right
----------------------------------------------------------------------
75m higuan

Next

Well as stated PSG have changed things. Neymar means Cout value went up, then VVD and so on. So a deal being done for €75m or there abouts is not exactly crazy. You clearly hate that, I'm not too fussed.

comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Winston (U16525)
posted 47 seconds ago

"That would be a fair comparison had Spurs paid 90m for Bale"

So a player can only be a flop if signed for a large amount of money?
--------------------------------------------------------------------
No but they are certainly a bigger flop if they arrive having been signed for a large amount of money because the expectations are higher.

This wasn't the case for Bale at Spurs and also he was a young lad not a grown man who had played in a CL final and won everything on offer in Italy.

Literally only United fans argue that Pogba isnt a flop. Everyone else is happy to call it as they see it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Some of the more balanced united fans can admit this but the blinkered idiots like winston are more likely to attack the individual making the statement irrespective of the statement being correct if we are being honest.

It’s never usually a problem as it says filtered and he can ruin threads without me seeing what he’s said.

Unfortunately replies still pop up.

Something for the admins to have a look at perhaps.

Anyway on topic even though Mangala is still at city he’s been a monumental flop as was Robinho, and samaras our unpolished diamond 😂

Pogba is a flop also.

comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 1 minute ago

comment by RonaldVilliers (U21490)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Benji Veniamin (U19953)
posted 18 seconds ago

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 5 minutes ago
Right worth and cost are very different. Do you think VVD is worth £75m compared to Kroos £20m? No.

Just calm down. Other than the PSG money it would have Zidane as one of the most expensive players of all time. How crazy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So here’s the list of players who sold for more than 65m

Neymar £198m
Mbappe £125m
Coutinho £105m
Dembele £98m
Pogba £89m
Bale £83m
Ronaldo £80m
Higuan £75
Vvd £75m
Lukaku £75m
Suarez £75m
James £69m
Bakambu £66m

So zidane would not be worth more than any of that lot right?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Depends who's buying and how long he has on his contract and what age he is.

If he was going to PSG or the Prem he's going to cost a lot more than 65m, if he's going to Germany or Italy then 65m is about right
----------------------------------------------------------------------
75m higuan

Next
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Goalscorers cost more than creators.

Next

comment by Robbing_Hoody - sometimes I jump into people and then charge them with assault (U6374)
posted 23 seconds ago
Well as stated PSG have changed things. Neymar means Cout value went up, then VVD and so on. So a deal being done for €75m or there abouts is not exactly crazy. You clearly hate that, I'm not too fussed.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
PSG have changed what?

Suarez, Ronaldo, bale, James all sold before they blew it up with Neymar and mbappe.

"but the blinkered idiots like winston are more likely to attack the individual making the statement irrespective of the statement being correct if we are being honest."

There's only one person attacking others here, and it isn't me.

I'll pick up the discussion with the adults here I think, as some people clearly aren't comfortable with their opinion being challenged.

Yeah for similar money to what I'm suggesting so thanks for agreeing.