or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 430284 comments are related to an article called:

Fan's Barclays Premiership Season 16

Page 992 of 17212

posted on 12/11/11

yes aslong as its not going over the squad limit for the first team renegade

posted on 12/11/11

seriously wigan after going on about it for ages

posted on 12/11/11

look at the voting page it will tell you why

posted on 12/11/11

if you had a two stage vote i whould be yes... but as it is it is 3...

posted on 12/11/11

yeah i know but your reasons dont make sense, henderson is 21 now anyway and most under 18s wont be playing at full international stage if this was allowed the best teams would get better and the gap wider

posted on 12/11/11

also i feel under 18s is to young they still wont be ready or good enough

posted on 12/11/11

what do you vote for then?

posted on 12/11/11

also i feel under 18s is to young they still wont be ready or good enough

---------------------------------------

Isn't that the whole point?

Otherwise you're just ruining the point of the 30 squad limit.

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 12/11/11

Under 18s is too young
what, you'd have players like Alex Oxlade Chamberlain in the top teams academy while other teams are struggling

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 12/11/11

AOC is probably 18 or under bad example but players like that

posted on 12/11/11

no put it up to 21... at that point they are able to come out of the acadamy and play...

if they are 18 there is no piont of an acadamy at all you may aswell just have them in your squad

posted on 12/11/11

the whole point is that its talent that is going to develop lol otherwise the squad limits is pointless

and dont see why 18 is too young either plenty of talented 18 year olds around playing regularly, AOC, mceachran ect

posted on 12/11/11

but wigan you were complaining about not having room for feruz who is 15/16 lol

if its 21 year olds its widening the gap and defeating the object of the squad rules, therefore completley pointless

posted on 12/11/11

up the squads to 35

18 foreign rule still applies
5 x U-18 to be included - but 5 must be U-18 all time so when they hit 18 they cant be counted

posted on 12/11/11

but if someone has talent they dont have to stay in the squad till 21 they can come out early...

but some players who are good but dont really get first team oppertunites till they are slightly earlyer

anyway why does my oppionion matter the votes are cast and at the minuet yes is winning though its pritty even in the 2 ideas

posted on 12/11/11

i was just saying what your saying wouldnt work 21 is way too old for an academy age

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 12/11/11

imo it all

posted on 12/11/11

lol kanga

Chelsea 5-2 Fulham full time
Baker
Swift
Piazon
Kimwoya(2)

mesca 2 for fulham

kimwoya the 2nd fastest englishman under 15 ever recorded lol beats walcott but 0.3 seconds which is a lot in terms of 100m his second was a great goal too

posted on 12/11/11

what happends if yes wins but the ideas are even with people who want it seeming to go for both ideas...

posted on 12/11/11

mancini and Gael Clichy hanging out in the ferrari garage at f1 lol

posted on 12/11/11

wigan which ever gets most votes wins unless i decide its too close in which case it stays the same

posted on 12/11/11

the vote is just to get an idea of what people would prefer of the three, in the end its my decision

comment by Kanga (U3095)

posted on 12/11/11

can I cast a vote to make it a draw lol

posted on 12/11/11

no lol

posted on 12/11/11

results up tomorrow?

Page 992 of 17212

Sign in if you want to comment