comment by HB Fash (U21935)
posted 5 minutes ago
I'd play
McLaughlin > De Gea
Barasic > Firpo
Davies > Worrall / McKenna
Goldson > Maguire
Tavernier > Emerson / Tomiyasu
Lundstram > McTominay
Davis > Fred
Kent > Rashturd
Tillman > Alli / Christie
Lawrence > Kabano / Elyounoussi
Colak > Adams / PL Edouard
Plus
Morelos, Kamara, Jack, Hagi, Matondo, Roofe (if he could stay fit)
Yilmaz (we spent loads for us on him so i suspect he will be a talent)
I reckon all of those could in the right team under the right conditions play PL week in week out.
We sold Aribo who will be Southampton best player as was Van Dijk when Celtic sold him to them. In conclusion our league is better than it gets credit for and the PL not as good as it gets credit for.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
there is a debate to be had with most of your choices tbh, but the colak one?? he wouldnt do well in EPL.
He would score a lot of goals for a top EPL team ... loads IMO but they can find better players, and he wouldnt score goals for teams that dont create chances.
The Kris Boyd effect , he is only as effective as the team you put around him. If your teams creates loads of chances and dominates the ball Colak is very handy, if your asking that forward to be the link man or stretch defences he isnt the answer
I switched on Clyde SSB last week and within 30 seconds a Rangers fan had phoned in and said Tavernier was the best right back in Europe
I'm no sure who laughed more me or Marvin Bartley
I'd like to refer the gentleman to the Chelsea game at the weekend, if you think Tav is even in the same league as Reece James then you need locked up
on his worst day de gea is better than mclaughing behave you
do you think if rangers signed him he would have a fight to get the jersey?
"need to be patient davie"
If we wanted to sign him we're in trouble, they guy has been consistently dropping clangers for years now. Lives off a reputation that should be long gone.
I'd like to refer the gentleman to the Chelsea game at the weekend, if you think Tav is even in the same league as Reece James then you need locked up
=======
tavernier getting in the england team is about as likely as thompson was.
you can be as good as you want, you play in scotland so they will scoff at it.
walker, arnold, james.
he's no chance because of the calibre ahead of him.
Colak would do better than Benteke at Palace for instance. Couldn't finish a whank.
This is what i'm saying it's really not difficult to be better than some of the guys down there have done. Of course you can debate them but it's nonsense to say only 3 guys from Rangers could play regularly down there.
In the right circumstances i stand by 75% of our squad could.
As for Tav - 4th best in England if he went down there and we considered Cancelo as a LB
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 4 minutes ago
I'd like to refer the gentleman to the Chelsea game at the weekend, if you think Tav is even in the same league as Reece James then you need locked up
=======
tavernier getting in the england team is about as likely as thompson was.
you can be as good as you want, you play in scotland so they will scoff at it.
walker, arnold, james.
he's no chance because of the calibre ahead of him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Trent is basically Tav but with +2 on every stat. Thats no slight on Tav cos Trent on his day is an outstanding RB. If Trent can keep the heid focused and continue working on his game he can be the best RB in the world IMO.
Try the opposite name some of the worst players for a position, that starts regularly in the PL that would get in the Celtic team.
How many of these get in the Celtic side.
GK Ward
LB Firpo
CB Worrall
CB McKenna
RB Dalot
CM Fred
CM McTominay
CM Colback
LW Kabano
RW Fraser
FW Edouard
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
If these players were deemed good enough, there’s no shortage of money in the EPL that any Scottish club would turn their nose up at. They’d be bid for, bargained with and then sold. If not, they’d be deemed not good enough for not that much money for an EPL side.
Now who is being bid for again? And that includes those clubs who supposedly have “rubbish” players.
TAA, Walker, James, Trippier are all better
I'd say he's maybe in the same bracket as Ayling/Cash
as long as united have that dumping at CB and as captain they will struggle.
he's not a leader, he's not a quality player, he's the english scott mckenna
Who is good enough to play down there and who will go on to play down there are very different questions.
A lot more variables on the second one but on a strictly quality basis we have lots of players up here good enough to play down there but you will be here to big up England and tell Scotland how schitey it is. A theme.
comment by Gingernuts (U2992)
posted 2 minutes ago
If these players were deemed good enough, there’s no shortage of money in the EPL that any Scottish club would turn their nose up at. They’d be bid for, bargained with and then sold. If not, they’d be deemed not good enough for not that much money for an EPL side.
Now who is being bid for again? And that includes those clubs who supposedly have “rubbish” players.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cos its not as black and white as that.
You could argue many players are a slight improvement or equal to what some EPL teams have.
Why would a team go out and spend money on a slight or equal improvement.
Your tilting your argument towards certain rangers/celtic players being better than other EPL players.
Id say there are plenty at a similar level. Shane Duffy for eg I wouldnt say many would argue that he isnt at least the same level of Goldson & CCV ? same can be said about Worral.
Plenty of our players can cut it at EPL level at some level even if that is the bottom level teams
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pretty much sums it up
comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)
posted 2 minutes ago
TAA, Walker, James, Trippier are all better
I'd say he's maybe in the same bracket as Ayling/Cash
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They two aint even in the same bracket ffs
Ayling is schite. Cash is good.
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
McTominay
Fred
Dalot
Who you replacing in our squads for these guys?
in our teams even.
Squads McTominay might get a chance at Stephen Kelly's role.
comment by HB Fash (U21935)
posted 5 seconds ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
McTominay
Fred
Dalot
Who you replacing in our squads for these guys?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dalot would run riot in scotland his game would be perfect for an OF in scotland ..... if someone offered me Mctominay or Fred for free and 15k-20k a week then Jack/Kamara dont get a game
No straight swaps only.
Who you taking
Dalot or Tavernier
Jack or McTominay
Fred or Lundstram
Dalot, Fred and Mctominay
well I would actually reject them all if we had to pay the wages they were on cos regardless of how good they are it would mess up our finances, hence why i said if they were on similar wages then thats who I would take
for eg Fred is on 120k a week doesnt matter if he is xavi .. we can afford that.
Sancho would be the best player in our squad, would tear it up, smash teams week in week out, but if he had to be paid 350k a week I would reject him
Sign in if you want to comment
RANGERS V PSV
Page 18 of 19
15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19
posted on 17/8/22
comment by HB Fash (U21935)
posted 5 minutes ago
I'd play
McLaughlin > De Gea
Barasic > Firpo
Davies > Worrall / McKenna
Goldson > Maguire
Tavernier > Emerson / Tomiyasu
Lundstram > McTominay
Davis > Fred
Kent > Rashturd
Tillman > Alli / Christie
Lawrence > Kabano / Elyounoussi
Colak > Adams / PL Edouard
Plus
Morelos, Kamara, Jack, Hagi, Matondo, Roofe (if he could stay fit)
Yilmaz (we spent loads for us on him so i suspect he will be a talent)
I reckon all of those could in the right team under the right conditions play PL week in week out.
We sold Aribo who will be Southampton best player as was Van Dijk when Celtic sold him to them. In conclusion our league is better than it gets credit for and the PL not as good as it gets credit for.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
there is a debate to be had with most of your choices tbh, but the colak one?? he wouldnt do well in EPL.
He would score a lot of goals for a top EPL team ... loads IMO but they can find better players, and he wouldnt score goals for teams that dont create chances.
The Kris Boyd effect , he is only as effective as the team you put around him. If your teams creates loads of chances and dominates the ball Colak is very handy, if your asking that forward to be the link man or stretch defences he isnt the answer
posted on 17/8/22
I switched on Clyde SSB last week and within 30 seconds a Rangers fan had phoned in and said Tavernier was the best right back in Europe
I'm no sure who laughed more me or Marvin Bartley
I'd like to refer the gentleman to the Chelsea game at the weekend, if you think Tav is even in the same league as Reece James then you need locked up
posted on 17/8/22
on his worst day de gea is better than mclaughing behave you
do you think if rangers signed him he would have a fight to get the jersey?
"need to be patient davie"
posted on 17/8/22
If we wanted to sign him we're in trouble, they guy has been consistently dropping clangers for years now. Lives off a reputation that should be long gone.
posted on 17/8/22
I'd like to refer the gentleman to the Chelsea game at the weekend, if you think Tav is even in the same league as Reece James then you need locked up
=======
tavernier getting in the england team is about as likely as thompson was.
you can be as good as you want, you play in scotland so they will scoff at it.
walker, arnold, james.
he's no chance because of the calibre ahead of him.
posted on 17/8/22
Colak would do better than Benteke at Palace for instance. Couldn't finish a whank.
This is what i'm saying it's really not difficult to be better than some of the guys down there have done. Of course you can debate them but it's nonsense to say only 3 guys from Rangers could play regularly down there.
In the right circumstances i stand by 75% of our squad could.
As for Tav - 4th best in England if he went down there and we considered Cancelo as a LB
posted on 17/8/22
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 4 minutes ago
I'd like to refer the gentleman to the Chelsea game at the weekend, if you think Tav is even in the same league as Reece James then you need locked up
=======
tavernier getting in the england team is about as likely as thompson was.
you can be as good as you want, you play in scotland so they will scoff at it.
walker, arnold, james.
he's no chance because of the calibre ahead of him.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Trent is basically Tav but with +2 on every stat. Thats no slight on Tav cos Trent on his day is an outstanding RB. If Trent can keep the heid focused and continue working on his game he can be the best RB in the world IMO.
posted on 17/8/22
Try the opposite name some of the worst players for a position, that starts regularly in the PL that would get in the Celtic team.
How many of these get in the Celtic side.
GK Ward
LB Firpo
CB Worrall
CB McKenna
RB Dalot
CM Fred
CM McTominay
CM Colback
LW Kabano
RW Fraser
FW Edouard
posted on 17/8/22
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
posted on 17/8/22
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
posted on 17/8/22
If these players were deemed good enough, there’s no shortage of money in the EPL that any Scottish club would turn their nose up at. They’d be bid for, bargained with and then sold. If not, they’d be deemed not good enough for not that much money for an EPL side.
Now who is being bid for again? And that includes those clubs who supposedly have “rubbish” players.
posted on 17/8/22
TAA, Walker, James, Trippier are all better
I'd say he's maybe in the same bracket as Ayling/Cash
posted on 17/8/22
as long as united have that dumping at CB and as captain they will struggle.
he's not a leader, he's not a quality player, he's the english scott mckenna
posted on 17/8/22
Who is good enough to play down there and who will go on to play down there are very different questions.
A lot more variables on the second one but on a strictly quality basis we have lots of players up here good enough to play down there but you will be here to big up England and tell Scotland how schitey it is. A theme.
posted on 17/8/22
comment by Gingernuts (U2992)
posted 2 minutes ago
If these players were deemed good enough, there’s no shortage of money in the EPL that any Scottish club would turn their nose up at. They’d be bid for, bargained with and then sold. If not, they’d be deemed not good enough for not that much money for an EPL side.
Now who is being bid for again? And that includes those clubs who supposedly have “rubbish” players.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Cos its not as black and white as that.
You could argue many players are a slight improvement or equal to what some EPL teams have.
Why would a team go out and spend money on a slight or equal improvement.
Your tilting your argument towards certain rangers/celtic players being better than other EPL players.
Id say there are plenty at a similar level. Shane Duffy for eg I wouldnt say many would argue that he isnt at least the same level of Goldson & CCV ? same can be said about Worral.
Plenty of our players can cut it at EPL level at some level even if that is the bottom level teams
posted on 17/8/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Pretty much sums it up
posted on 17/8/22
comment by Ghod#18 (U9390)
posted 2 minutes ago
TAA, Walker, James, Trippier are all better
I'd say he's maybe in the same bracket as Ayling/Cash
----------------------------------------------------------------------
They two aint even in the same bracket ffs
Ayling is schite. Cash is good.
posted on 17/8/22
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
McTominay
Fred
Dalot
Who you replacing in our squads for these guys?
posted on 17/8/22
in our teams even.
Squads McTominay might get a chance at Stephen Kelly's role.
posted on 17/8/22
comment by HB Fash (U21935)
posted 5 seconds ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by JFK (U8919)
posted 34 seconds ago
mctominay is a better player than we are seeing right now, not top tier man utd level imo but teams in 6-10 he's a good player i think.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
lets not beat about the bush the whole man utd squad if you looking at individual ability would take the spots of any of either our teams.
that club is in a toxic position just now. And if your seriously thinking that Sancho isnt better than Jota and Kent then your mad , regardless of his form at another club.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
McTominay
Fred
Dalot
Who you replacing in our squads for these guys?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dalot would run riot in scotland his game would be perfect for an OF in scotland ..... if someone offered me Mctominay or Fred for free and 15k-20k a week then Jack/Kamara dont get a game
posted on 17/8/22
No straight swaps only.
Who you taking
Dalot or Tavernier
Jack or McTominay
Fred or Lundstram
posted on 17/8/22
Dalot, Fred and Mctominay
posted on 17/8/22
well I would actually reject them all if we had to pay the wages they were on cos regardless of how good they are it would mess up our finances, hence why i said if they were on similar wages then thats who I would take
posted on 17/8/22
for eg Fred is on 120k a week doesnt matter if he is xavi .. we can afford that.
Sancho would be the best player in our squad, would tear it up, smash teams week in week out, but if he had to be paid 350k a week I would reject him
posted on 17/8/22
*we cant afford that
Page 18 of 19
15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19