or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 771 comments are related to an article called:

Hearts v Celtic LIVE!

Page 30 of 31

posted on 22/10/22

comment by son of quebec (U8127)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Dave The Jackal (U22179)
posted 2 hours, 50 minutes ago
Sub par performance from us, but a huge and deserved win in the circumstances. Left side of our starting defence was honking, Berni especially. Gave the ball away in dangerous areas all game until he was hooked … for the match winner. Shout out to Taylor BTW.

Ref beyond poor … VAR ref not much better. Scottish football in a nutshell. It’s not VAR’s fault though, just the numpties officiating.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This.^^^^^^^
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Totally agree

Said it before regarding Bernabei , definitely has attributes but he is nowhere near as polished as Taylor - although think he will be a better player in time

Taylor - yes big shout out . Tidy , industrious and is actually a good player using Anges system where he doesn't have to take on a man to cross . Weirdly inverted fullback Totally suits him

posted on 22/10/22

Aaron Mooy though

I feel he's ruining the style and identity a bit , why does Ange pkay him ? He's really not an ange style player

Btw Hatate again , involved in everything we do well

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 22/10/22

Criticism of the var is harsh imho. First week ffs! Yes the hand ball balance of public opinion is pen but there are always going to be these marginal interpretations. Listened to the bears game on Clyde and to a man said the yellow was never a red and all changed their mind on review. That is a success. All the other decisions a success. More correct decisions a success. We should celebrate that!

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 22/10/22

And >700 comments!

I didn’t realise you’d missed my live threads so much?

posted on 22/10/22

For me that tackle is never a red on multiple showings , like never a red

He lifts his foot up to pull it out the tackle and they kept showing that bit on repeat without the context

He didn't go in with his foot up , did they say on Clyde its a red ?

Agree with what you say Silver it doesn't totally take away interpretation and maybe that's a good thing

It will definitely showcase who understands the game

posted on 22/10/22

Stewart saying the handball wasn't a pen 🤣

posted on 22/10/22

Michael Stewart is a fcking Muppet, "never a pen" for the hand ball, shut up ya rocket

posted on 22/10/22

Shelly Kerr telling him he is full of shìťe

posted on 22/10/22

And on the pen retake, "half his body was still outside"?

Throbber

posted on 22/10/22

comment by Insufferable-Piffle, just in case, I'm sorry! (U4388)
posted 17 seconds ago
And on the pen retake, "half his body was still outside"?

Throbber
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wearing his Hearts sleeve in full tonight

posted on 22/10/22

comment by GTB Cinched it (U14017)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle, just in case, I'm sorry! (U4388)
posted 17 seconds ago
And on the pen retake, "half his body was still outside"?

Throbber
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wearing his Hearts sleeve in full tonight
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems like it, I'm in my local and it's full of Jambos and all of them to a man a) felt the handball was a pen and b) he was in early, along with the Celtic players

They are however FULL of bitterness and it's superb

posted on 22/10/22

comment by GTB Cinched it (U14017)
posted 3 minutes ago
Shelly Kerr telling him he is full of shìťe
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And that Prince Adam and Cringer need sacked

posted on 22/10/22

‘Criticism of the var is harsh imho.’

This is one of the things that gets to me-VAR isn’t some automated, non-organic entity. It’s another human making the decisions. That’s what cracks me up-how can a human, and in our case a current referee-look at that handball incident and not give it as a penalty. 2 referees have looked at that, and decided against giving it. That’s incredulous.

posted on 22/10/22

comment by Insufferable-Piffle, just in case, I'm sorry! (U4388)
posted 31 seconds ago
comment by GTB Cinched it (U14017)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle, just in case, I'm sorry! (U4388)
posted 17 seconds ago
And on the pen retake, "half his body was still outside"?

Throbber
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wearing his Hearts sleeve in full tonight
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems like it, I'm in my local and it's full of Jambos and all of them to a man a) felt the handball was a pen and b) he was in early, along with the Celtic players

They are however FULL of bitterness and it's superb
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Things you love to read 🤣

posted on 22/10/22

comment by My POV (U10636)
posted 3 seconds ago
‘Criticism of the var is harsh imho.’

This is one of the things that gets to me-VAR isn’t some automated, non-organic entity. It’s another human making the decisions. That’s what cracks me up-how can a human, and in our case a current referee-look at that handball incident and not give it as a penalty. 2 referees have looked at that, and decided against giving it. That’s incredulous.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Stunning, it was about as clear a pen as I have seen for handball, that said I also think both our pens were nailed on

posted on 22/10/22

comment by GTB Cinched it (U14017)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle, just in case, I'm sorry! (U4388)
posted 31 seconds ago
comment by GTB Cinched it (U14017)
posted 8 seconds ago
comment by Insufferable-Piffle, just in case, I'm sorry! (U4388)
posted 17 seconds ago
And on the pen retake, "half his body was still outside"?

Throbber
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Wearing his Hearts sleeve in full tonight
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems like it, I'm in my local and it's full of Jambos and all of them to a man a) felt the handball was a pen and b) he was in early, along with the Celtic players

They are however FULL of bitterness and it's superb
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Things you love to read 🤣
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh GTB I get it tight from them when they manage a result so any win is magnificent

posted on 22/10/22

The Hearts incidents were both penalties. The moaning about how Walsh didn’t give the first one instantly is laughable.

posted on 22/10/22

comment by My POV (U10636)
posted 12 seconds ago
The Hearts incidents were both penalties. The moaning about how Walsh didn’t give the first one instantly is laughable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agree, watched it again there and at first it looked like a collision, on a rewatch and VAR it was a pen no doubt

posted on 22/10/22

Piff, enjoy your night and winding up the diets 🍺🥃😂

posted on 22/10/22

comment by MaHeed'sNippin aka I’m the competent Wullie Collum (U3633)
posted 5 seconds ago
Piff, enjoy your night and winding up the diets 🍺🥃😂
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm about one giggle away from getting a slap from some of them, my oldest boy is in with his mates, all Jambos and has barely glanced in my direction

posted on 22/10/22

comment by My POV (U10636)
posted less than a minute ago
The Hearts incidents were both penalties. The moaning about how Walsh didn’t give the first one instantly is laughable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yip both pens

Walsh maybe thought it was a coming together so VArR helped

No idea why Neilson has any issues with that

Would like to see how he would have coped with no handball for our pen

Pwick

posted on 22/10/22

comment by CelticTornado (U4316)
posted 9 seconds ago
comment by My POV (U10636)
posted less than a minute ago
The Hearts incidents were both penalties. The moaning about how Walsh didn’t give the first one instantly is laughable.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Yip both pens

Walsh maybe thought it was a coming together so VArR helped

No idea why Neilson has any issues with that

Would like to see how he would have coped with no handball for our pen

Pwick
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Absolutely, would have liked the interviewer to have asked his opinion on the handball? Robbie is a whinging pwick at best anyway

comment by Silver (U6112)

posted on 22/10/22

Fair play piff, nice to have your kids hanging about the same places you do too. That’s nice.

posted on 22/10/22

comment by Silver (U6112)
posted about a minute ago
Fair play piff, nice to have your kids hanging about the same places you do too. That’s nice.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
primary school ?

posted on 22/10/22

Apologies piffle, that josh was a bit uncalled for

Page 30 of 31

Sign in if you want to comment