or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 116 comments are related to an article called:

Pound for pound best player

Page 1 of 5

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 13/6/24

James Milner played in pretty much every position in his career, bar GK and CF! Not sure his quality would be high enough for this conversation though.

Gullet was pretty versatile and ended up playing at CB/Sweeper for Chelsea. Certainly capable of playing all the attacking positions in his prime.

posted on 13/6/24

Kobbie Mainoo

posted on 13/6/24

comment by Szoboss (U6997)
posted 21 seconds ago
James Milner played in pretty much every position in his career, bar GK and CF! Not sure his quality would be high enough for this conversation though.

Gullet was pretty versatile and ended up playing at CB/Sweeper for Chelsea. Certainly capable of playing all the attacking positions in his prime.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

the dutch were mentioned more than any other in our debate.

Gullit, Rijkaard and Koeman especially.

posted on 13/6/24

Scholes

posted on 13/6/24

To be fair it's hard to look past Steven Gerrard for this.

He was class in every position he played for LFC. He played every position except goalie and was excellent in them all.

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 13/6/24

comment by Just another Tottenham fan (U7471)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Szoboss (U6997)
posted 21 seconds ago
James Milner played in pretty much every position in his career, bar GK and CF! Not sure his quality would be high enough for this conversation though.

Gullet was pretty versatile and ended up playing at CB/Sweeper for Chelsea. Certainly capable of playing all the attacking positions in his prime.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

the dutch were mentioned more than any other in our debate.

Gullit, Rijkaard and Koeman especially.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Seedorf would do well in most positions as well. Probably too small to be CB, but most others.

Zanetti played just about everywhere in defence and midfield as well.

Gerrard and Rooney are both decent shouts though.

posted on 13/6/24

Gerrard and Rooney aren't bad shouts to be fair

Both had the competitive edge, desire and all round skill set to be able to step in any position enough to at least cover it and not make an erse of it, I juts asked this question in my work and there's at least two arguements started already

posted on 13/6/24

Rooney and Gerrard are great shouts.

Seedorf could do everything.

Roy Keane could do everything.

KDB can do everything.

It’ll shock you but I’m going to go with Gerrard. He’s played pretty much every position bar GK for club and country.

posted on 13/6/24

Kante in his prime.

posted on 13/6/24

comment by Insufferable-Piffle (U4388)
posted 42 seconds ago
Gerrard and Rooney aren't bad shouts to be fair

Both had the competitive edge, desire and all round skill set to be able to step in any position enough to at least cover it and not make an erse of it, I juts asked this question in my work and there's at least two arguements started already
----------------------------------------------------------------------

ours is so heated its become ridiculous. we have one fella who is saying zidane and is willing to die on his hill without anyone else backing it whatsoever. such a weird debate dismissing zidane in a best ever conversation.

posted on 13/6/24

Yaya Toure

posted on 13/6/24

comment by Peeb (U3245)
posted 28 seconds ago
Yaya Toure
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Great shout

comment by Szoboss (U6997)

posted on 13/6/24

Going back a bit further in time, you could have put Bryan Robson anywhere on a pitch imo. Probably true of Souness as well.

posted on 13/6/24

Koeman

posted on 13/6/24

Lorenzo Insigne

small lad, helluva player

pound for pound we're talking about here, no ?

posted on 13/6/24

comment by LordDowlias (U3236)
posted 14 minutes ago
To be fair it's hard to look past Steven Gerrard for this.

He was class in every position he played for LFC. He played every position except goalie and was excellent in them all.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
True tbf

posted on 13/6/24

I mean it’s too early but throwing in Bellingham as a pound for pound heir apparent

posted on 13/6/24

comment by Szoboss (U6997)
posted 2 minutes ago
Going back a bit further in time, you could have put Bryan Robson anywhere on a pitch imo. Probably true of Souness as well.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Oh Good call there it seems to be the more "competative type of player in the discussion

posted on 13/6/24

Essien

posted on 13/6/24

Might be an unpopular one, but Ronaldo (Cr7). Physical freak - has the athleticism to get by anywhere on the pitch.

posted on 13/6/24

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 1 minute ago
Might be an unpopular one, but Ronaldo (Cr7). Physical freak - has the athleticism to get by anywhere on the pitch.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
True but does he have the cajones and bravery to throw himself into 50/50 tackles against other big strong players if he was stuck in DC or FB? maybe could do to be fair?

posted on 13/6/24

comment by -bloodred- (U1222)
posted 2 minutes ago
Might be an unpopular one, but Ronaldo (Cr7). Physical freak - has the athleticism to get by anywhere on the pitch.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ronaldo has to be in the equation certainly.
can obvsiously play striker and wide and be one of if not the greatest there has ever been.
we said positionally he would be found out at the back with absolutely no credentials or expertise backing us whatsoever.

posted on 13/6/24

Kane - played in goal once as well.

posted on 13/6/24

Schweinsteiger

posted on 13/6/24

Looking at Rodri in todays football

Page 1 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment