You'll probably get quite a few posts about those not on the list, but no Pires?

comment by Playmaker (U22780)
posted 1 minute ago
You'll probably get quite a few posts about those not on the list, but no Pires?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I just couldn’t find space for him as the other 5 were too good

comment by Robb - Paddystinian 🫶 (U22716)
posted 15 seconds ago
comment by Playmaker (U22780)
posted 1 minute ago
You'll probably get quite a few posts about those not on the list, but no Pires?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I just couldn’t find space for him as the other 5 were too good
----------------------------------------------------------------------

He's way ahead of Bale or Hazard though

No Beckham

Manchester United runs through my veins, but the truth here is there is no one on that list above Mo Salah.

Beckham
Pires
Even Sterling ahead of Bale

Okay, due to popular demand I swapped Bale for Pires

I think you forgot Obertan.............

Salah

comment by Robb - Paddystinian 🫶 (U22716)
posted 2 minutes ago
Okay, due to popular demand I swapped Bale for Pires
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Don't know who to pick now

Poor Giggs being forgotten by the annals of time 😭

I like traditional wingers as there's more to their game rather than wing forwards.

You might as well include Henry if you're including Salah.

Personally, Pires or Giggs for me in the PL era. Just outstanding wingers.

quite like Doku TBF

Kanchelskis at United was a handful too

Wanted to vote on DeJesus article but I'm filtered so I'll do it here. Best young player, Salah.

Rooney

Would have Beckham above most of those. Must be some others we're forgetting though?

comment by Two Balls, One Saka (U19684)
posted 33 seconds ago
Would have Beckham above most of those. Must be some others we're forgetting though?


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Llundberg, Robben?

There’s a mix of wingers and more inside forwards in there, not sure they’re really comparables.

Mohammed Salah isn't a winger. Wonderful player but not a winger. End of discussion.

Wingers?

Robben ahead of any of these non wingers.

Ginola was quality, too.

comment by Cinciwolf-----JA606 NFL fantasy champ 2023 (U11551)
posted 4 minutes ago
Wingers?

Robben ahead of any of these non wingers.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He was a cheet tho

comment by Tyranny of the majority (SE85) (U21241)
posted 22 minutes ago
Mohammed Salah isn't a winger. Wonderful player but not a winger. End of discussion.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The discussion remains because you haven't decided who the best winger is, you only said Salah isn't a winger.
Carry on.

The game has changed so much, that what is considered a winger in today's game is nothing like winger was back in the Giggs era.

But the best of each type would be Salah & Giggs

comment by Tyranny of the majority (SE85) (U21241)
posted 38 minutes ago
Mohammed Salah isn't a winger. Wonderful player but not a winger. End of discussion.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He is a wing forward, same as everyone else on the list with exception to Giggs.

Anyway Ronaldo wins